react-accessible-accordion vs @chakra-ui/react vs @headlessui/react
React UI Component Libraries
react-accessible-accordion@chakra-ui/react@headlessui/reactSimilar Packages:

React UI Component Libraries

React UI component libraries provide pre-built components that help developers create user interfaces efficiently while ensuring accessibility and responsiveness. These libraries often follow design principles and best practices, allowing developers to focus on functionality rather than building components from scratch. Each library has its unique features and use cases, catering to different needs in web development, such as design consistency, accessibility, and customization.

Npm Package Weekly Downloads Trend

3 Years

Github Stars Ranking

Stat Detail

Package
Downloads
Stars
Size
Issues
Publish
License
react-accessible-accordion162,368791108 kB29a year agoMIT
@chakra-ui/react040,3072.62 MB225 hours agoMIT
@headlessui/react028,4291.02 MB825 months agoMIT

Feature Comparison: react-accessible-accordion vs @chakra-ui/react vs @headlessui/react

Accessibility

  • react-accessible-accordion:

    React Accessible Accordion is specifically designed to be accessible, following WAI-ARIA guidelines for accordions. It ensures that all interactive elements are keyboard accessible and provides proper roles and attributes for screen readers, making it a strong choice for accessibility-focused applications.

  • @chakra-ui/react:

    Chakra UI is built with accessibility in mind, providing components that are compliant with WAI-ARIA standards. It includes features like focus management and keyboard navigation out of the box, making it easier to create accessible applications without additional effort.

  • @headlessui/react:

    Headless UI focuses on accessibility by providing unstyled components that come with built-in accessibility features. It allows developers to implement their own styles while ensuring that components are keyboard navigable and screen reader friendly, adhering to best practices for accessibility.

Customizability

  • react-accessible-accordion:

    React Accessible Accordion provides a straightforward API for implementing accordions, but it is less customizable in terms of styling compared to Chakra UI and Headless UI. It focuses on functionality and accessibility rather than design flexibility.

  • @chakra-ui/react:

    Chakra UI offers extensive theming capabilities, allowing developers to customize styles easily through a theme provider. It supports responsive design and allows for component-level styling, making it flexible for various design needs.

  • @headlessui/react:

    Headless UI is highly customizable as it provides the logic and structure without any predefined styles. This allows developers to create unique designs tailored to their application's branding while maintaining accessibility features.

Component Variety

  • react-accessible-accordion:

    React Accessible Accordion is specialized for creating accordion components. It does not offer a wide variety of components but excels in its specific use case, making it ideal for applications that require accordion functionality.

  • @chakra-ui/react:

    Chakra UI includes a wide range of components such as buttons, forms, modals, and more, making it a comprehensive solution for building user interfaces. Its extensive component library allows for rapid development and consistent design across applications.

  • @headlessui/react:

    Headless UI offers a smaller set of components focused on common UI patterns like modals, dropdowns, and tabs. While it may not have as many components as Chakra UI, it provides essential building blocks that can be styled as needed.

Learning Curve

  • react-accessible-accordion:

    React Accessible Accordion is straightforward to use, with a simple API that makes it easy to implement accordions. Developers can quickly learn how to use it, especially if they have prior experience with React.

  • @chakra-ui/react:

    Chakra UI has a moderate learning curve, especially for developers familiar with React. Its well-documented API and component structure make it relatively easy to pick up, allowing for quick implementation of UI components.

  • @headlessui/react:

    Headless UI has a slightly steeper learning curve due to its unstyled nature. Developers need to have a good understanding of styling and design principles to effectively use the components, but it offers great flexibility once mastered.

Design Philosophy

  • react-accessible-accordion:

    React Accessible Accordion focuses on providing a functional and accessible accordion component. Its design philosophy is centered around usability and compliance with accessibility standards, making it a reliable choice for developers who prioritize these aspects.

  • @chakra-ui/react:

    Chakra UI follows a design philosophy that emphasizes simplicity, modularity, and accessibility. It encourages developers to build applications that are visually appealing and user-friendly while adhering to best practices.

  • @headlessui/react:

    Headless UI adopts a design philosophy that prioritizes functionality and accessibility over aesthetics. It provides the necessary tools to create accessible components while allowing developers to define their own styles and designs.

How to Choose: react-accessible-accordion vs @chakra-ui/react vs @headlessui/react

  • react-accessible-accordion:

    Opt for React Accessible Accordion if you specifically need an accessible accordion component that follows WAI-ARIA guidelines. It is focused on providing a simple and effective way to implement accordions while ensuring they are keyboard navigable and screen reader friendly.

  • @chakra-ui/react:

    Choose Chakra UI if you need a comprehensive design system that emphasizes accessibility, theming, and responsive design. It provides a wide range of customizable components that are easy to use and integrate into your application.

  • @headlessui/react:

    Select Headless UI if you prefer a more unopinionated approach to building accessible components. It provides the logic and accessibility features without imposing styles, allowing you to create your own designs while ensuring compliance with accessibility standards.

README for react-accessible-accordion

react-accessible-accordion npm Accessibility status

⚠️ Project status

In most cases, you no longer need a JS library like this to render fully functional, accessible accordions. For that reason, this project is no longer maintained.

This is because native HTML Disclosure (aka <details>/<summary>) elements are now widely supported.

Native disclosures offer several advantages over any JS-based solutions. For instance:

  • Because there is no JS to download/parse, they are far more performant.
  • They are framework-agnostic, and will work the same way whether you're using React, [other framework], or plain old HTML.
  • Collapsed content can still be found via find-on-page (ctrl/command+f) in supporting browsers, including Chrome.

Demo

Try a demo now.

Usage

First, grab the package from npm:

npm install --save react-accessible-accordion

Then, import the editor and use it in your code. Here is a basic example:

import React from 'react';

import {
    Accordion,
    AccordionItem,
    AccordionItemHeading,
    AccordionItemButton,
    AccordionItemPanel,
} from 'react-accessible-accordion';

// Demo styles, see 'Styles' section below for some notes on use.
import 'react-accessible-accordion/dist/fancy-example.css';

export default function Example() {
    return (
        <Accordion>
            <AccordionItem>
                <AccordionItemHeading>
                    <AccordionItemButton>
                        What harsh truths do you prefer to ignore?
                    </AccordionItemButton>
                </AccordionItemHeading>
                <AccordionItemPanel>
                    <p>
                        Exercitation in fugiat est ut ad ea cupidatat ut in
                        cupidatat occaecat ut occaecat consequat est minim minim
                        esse tempor laborum consequat esse adipisicing eu
                        reprehenderit enim.
                    </p>
                </AccordionItemPanel>
            </AccordionItem>
            <AccordionItem>
                <AccordionItemHeading>
                    <AccordionItemButton>
                        Is free will real or just an illusion?
                    </AccordionItemButton>
                </AccordionItemHeading>
                <AccordionItemPanel>
                    <p>
                        In ad velit in ex nostrud dolore cupidatat consectetur
                        ea in ut nostrud velit in irure cillum tempor laboris
                        sed adipisicing eu esse duis nulla non.
                    </p>
                </AccordionItemPanel>
            </AccordionItem>
        </Accordion>
    );
}

Styles

We strongly encourage you to write your own styles for your accordions, but we've published the styles used on our demo page to help you get up and running:

import 'react-accessible-accordion/dist/fancy-example.css';

We recommend that you copy them into your own app and modify them to suit your needs, particularly if you're using your own classNames.

Component API

Accordion

allowMultipleExpanded : boolean [optional, default: false]

Don't autocollapse items when expanding other items.

allowZeroExpanded : boolean [optional, default: false]

Allow the only remaining expanded item to be collapsed.

preExpanded: string[] [optional, default: []]

Accepts an array of strings and any AccordionItem whose uuid prop matches any one of these strings will be expanded on mount.

className : string [optional, default: 'accordion']

Class(es) to apply to element.

onChange : (string[]) => void [optional]

Callback which is invoked when items are expanded or collapsed. Gets passed uuids of the currently expanded AccordionItems.


AccordionItem

className : string [optional, default: accordion__item]

Class(es) to apply to element.

uuid : string|number [optional]

Recommended for use with onChange. Will be auto-generated if not provided.

dangerouslySetExpanded: boolean [optional]

Enables external control of the expansion.

Warning: This may impact accessibility negatively, use at your own risk


AccordionItemHeading

className : string [optional, default: 'accordion__heading']

Class(es) to apply to the 'heading' element.

aria-level : number [optional, default: 3]

Semantics to apply to the 'heading' element. A value of 1 would make your heading element hierarchically equivalent to an <h1> tag, and likewise a value of 6 would make it equivalent to an <h6> tag.

AccordionItemButton

className : string [optional, default: 'accordion__button']

Class(es) to apply to the 'button' element.


AccordionItemPanel

className : string [optional, default: 'accordion__panel']

Class(es) to apply to element.

region: boolean

Make the element have a region role.


AccordionItemState

children : ({ expanded: boolean, disabled: boolean }): JSX.Element [required]


Helpers

resetNextUuid : (): void

Resets the internal counter for Accordion items' identifiers (including id attributes). For use in test suites and isomorphic frameworks.


Accessibility Best-Practice

Authoring an 'accordion' component to the WAI ARIA spec can be complex, but React Accessible Accordion does most of the heavy lifting for you, including:

  • Applying appropriate aria attributes (aria-expanded, aria-controls, aria-disabled, aria-hidden and aria-labelledby).
  • Applying appropriate role attributes (button, heading, region).
  • Applying appropriate tabindex attributes.
  • Applying keyboard interactivity ('space', 'end', 'tab', 'up', 'down', 'home' and 'end' keys).

However, there's still a couple of things you need to keep in mind to remain spec-compliant:

  • Only ever use phrasing content inside of your AccordionItemHeading component. If in doubt, use text only.
  • Always provide an aria-level prop to your AccordionItemHeading component, especially if you are nesting accordions. This attribute is a signal used by assistive technologies (eg. screenreaders) to determine which heading level (ie. h1-h6) to treat your heading as.

If you have any questions about your implementation, then please don't be afraid to get in touch via our issues.

FAQs

React 18?

RAA supports React 18, and the new out-of-order streaming feature. See the CHANGELOG for details.

Which design patterns does this component aim to solve?

Those described by the WAI ARIA spec's description of an 'accordion':

An accordion is a vertically stacked set of interactive headings that each contain a title, content snippet, or thumbnail representing a section of content. The headings function as controls that enable users to reveal or hide their associated sections of content. Accordions are commonly used to reduce the need to scroll when presenting multiple sections of content on a single page.

Which design patterns does this component NOT aim to solve?

Components which are "accordion-like" but do not match the WAI ARIA spec's description, as written above. By "accordion-like", we mean components which have collapsible items but require bespoke interactive mechanisms in order to expand, collapse and 'disable' them. This includes (but is not limited to) multi-step forms, like those seen in many cart/checkout flows, which we believe require (other) complex markup in order to be considered 'accessible'. This also includes disclosure widgets.

How do I disable an item?

See "Which design patterns does this component NOT aim to solve?".

Browser Support

Supported browser / device versions:

BrowserDevice/OSVersion
Mobile SafariiOSlatest
ChromeAndroidlatest
IEWindows11
MS EdgeWindowslatest
ChromeDesktoplatest
FirefoxDesktoplatest
SafariOSXlatest