Which is Better JavaScript Code Generation and Transformation Libraries?
typescript vs @babel/generator vs escodegen vs recast vs jscodeshift vs babel-generator
1 Year
typescript@babel/generatorescodegenrecastjscodeshiftbabel-generatorSimilar Packages:
What's JavaScript Code Generation and Transformation Libraries?

These libraries are used for generating, transforming, and manipulating JavaScript code programmatically. They facilitate tasks such as code generation, AST (Abstract Syntax Tree) manipulation, and code refactoring, making them essential tools for developers working with JavaScript, especially in build processes, transpilation, and code analysis. Each library has its unique features and use cases, catering to different aspects of code generation and transformation.

NPM Package Downloads Trend
Github Stars Ranking
Stat Detail
Package
Downloads
Stars
Size
Issues
Publish
License
typescript60,301,883100,43422.4 MB5,74423 days agoApache-2.0
@babel/generator56,162,52843,187487 kB783a month agoMIT
escodegen31,245,6532,647109 kB145a year agoBSD-2-Clause
recast11,244,0164,965245 kB2024 months agoMIT
jscodeshift6,790,1019,256466 kB1412 months agoMIT
babel-generator2,172,010---7 years agoMIT
Feature Comparison: typescript vs @babel/generator vs escodegen vs recast vs jscodeshift vs babel-generator

Code Generation

  • typescript: TypeScript generates JavaScript code from TypeScript files, adding static type checking. It enhances code quality and maintainability, especially in larger projects.
  • @babel/generator: @babel/generator excels in generating high-quality JavaScript code from an AST. It supports modern JavaScript syntax and optimizes the output for performance, making it suitable for projects that require the latest language features.
  • escodegen: escodegen is lightweight and straightforward, allowing for quick code generation from an AST. It is less feature-rich compared to Babel's generators but is sufficient for simpler tasks.
  • recast: recast can generate code while preserving the original formatting, which is useful for maintaining code style during transformations. It combines parsing and code generation seamlessly.
  • jscodeshift: jscodeshift focuses on code transformations rather than pure code generation. It allows you to manipulate existing code and generate new code as part of a transformation process, making it ideal for codemods.
  • babel-generator: babel-generator provides a simple API for generating JavaScript code, but it may not support the latest syntax as effectively as @babel/generator. It is useful for legacy projects that need basic code generation capabilities.

AST Manipulation

  • typescript: TypeScript allows for AST manipulation through its compiler API, enabling developers to analyze and transform TypeScript code before generating JavaScript.
  • @babel/generator: @babel/generator is part of the Babel ecosystem, which includes powerful tools for AST manipulation. It allows developers to transform code before generating it, enabling advanced code modifications.
  • escodegen: escodegen is primarily a code generator and does not offer extensive AST manipulation features. It is best used in conjunction with other libraries that handle ASTs.
  • recast: recast allows for AST manipulation while also providing pretty-printing capabilities. It is useful for developers who want to modify code and maintain its formatting simultaneously.
  • jscodeshift: jscodeshift is specifically designed for AST manipulation, providing a rich set of utilities to traverse and modify ASTs. It is ideal for developers looking to perform complex transformations on their code.
  • babel-generator: babel-generator does not provide built-in AST manipulation capabilities; it focuses primarily on code generation from ASTs created by other tools.

Ease of Use

  • typescript: TypeScript has a steeper learning curve due to its type system, but it provides excellent tooling and IDE support, making it easier to work with once you grasp the concepts.
  • @babel/generator: @babel/generator has a modern API that is easy to use, especially for developers familiar with Babel. Its integration with the Babel ecosystem simplifies the workflow for code generation.
  • escodegen: escodegen is known for its simplicity and ease of use, making it a good choice for developers who need a lightweight solution for code generation without complex configurations.
  • recast: recast is user-friendly and integrates well with existing codebases, making it easy to adopt for developers looking to perform code transformations while maintaining style.
  • jscodeshift: jscodeshift has a learning curve due to its focus on codemods and AST manipulation, but it provides powerful tools for those willing to invest the time to learn its API.
  • babel-generator: babel-generator is straightforward but may feel outdated compared to newer libraries. It is easy to use for basic code generation tasks but lacks advanced features.

Community and Support

  • typescript: TypeScript has a large and active community, with extensive documentation and resources available. Its popularity ensures that developers can find support and examples easily.
  • @babel/generator: @babel/generator is widely used in the JavaScript community and benefits from strong support and documentation due to its integration with Babel, which is a popular tool for modern JavaScript development.
  • escodegen: escodegen has a dedicated user base but is less popular than Babel-related tools. It has decent documentation but may not have as extensive community support.
  • recast: recast is well-supported and has a solid community, providing good documentation and examples for developers looking to perform code transformations while preserving formatting.
  • jscodeshift: jscodeshift has a growing community, especially among developers focused on code transformations. Its documentation is helpful for users looking to implement codemods effectively.
  • babel-generator: babel-generator has a smaller community compared to @babel/generator, and while it is still supported, it may not receive as many updates or have as much documentation available.

Performance

  • typescript: TypeScript's performance is generally good, but it can be slower than pure JavaScript in some scenarios due to type checking and compilation overhead.
  • @babel/generator: @babel/generator is optimized for performance, especially when generating large amounts of code. It efficiently handles modern JavaScript features, ensuring fast code generation.
  • escodegen: escodegen is lightweight and performs well for simple code generation tasks, but it may struggle with more complex ASTs compared to Babel's generators.
  • recast: recast maintains performance while ensuring that the original formatting is preserved, but it may not be as fast as dedicated code generators for large-scale code generation tasks.
  • jscodeshift: jscodeshift is designed for performance when running codemods on large codebases, but the performance can vary depending on the complexity of the transformations being applied.
  • babel-generator: babel-generator may not be as performant as @babel/generator, particularly with complex syntax, but it is sufficient for many use cases.
How to Choose: typescript vs @babel/generator vs escodegen vs recast vs jscodeshift vs babel-generator
  • typescript: Select TypeScript if you want to add static typing to your JavaScript code. It offers powerful type-checking features and is ideal for large codebases where type safety can help prevent runtime errors.
  • @babel/generator: Choose @babel/generator if you need a modern and efficient way to generate JavaScript code from an AST. It is part of the Babel ecosystem, making it ideal for projects that already use Babel for transpilation and require compatibility with ES6+ features.
  • escodegen: Opt for escodegen if you need a simple and lightweight solution for generating JavaScript code from an AST. It is easy to use and can be integrated into various projects without the overhead of a larger library.
  • recast: Choose recast if you require a tool that can parse and pretty-print JavaScript code while preserving the original formatting. It is particularly useful for code transformations where maintaining style is important.
  • jscodeshift: Use jscodeshift when you need to perform large-scale code transformations or refactoring. It is designed for codemods and provides utilities for traversing and manipulating ASTs, making it suitable for automated code updates.
  • babel-generator: Select babel-generator for legacy projects that still rely on older Babel versions. It provides a straightforward API for generating code but may lack some of the optimizations and features found in @babel/generator.
README for typescript

TypeScript

GitHub Actions CI npm version Downloads OpenSSF Scorecard

TypeScript is a language for application-scale JavaScript. TypeScript adds optional types to JavaScript that support tools for large-scale JavaScript applications for any browser, for any host, on any OS. TypeScript compiles to readable, standards-based JavaScript. Try it out at the playground, and stay up to date via our blog and Twitter account.

Find others who are using TypeScript at our community page.

Installing

For the latest stable version:

npm install -D typescript

For our nightly builds:

npm install -D typescript@next

Contribute

There are many ways to contribute to TypeScript.

This project has adopted the Microsoft Open Source Code of Conduct. For more information see the Code of Conduct FAQ or contact opencode@microsoft.com with any additional questions or comments.

Documentation

Roadmap

For details on our planned features and future direction, please refer to our roadmap.