Complexity and Customization
- react-draggable:
react-draggable
is focused on making elements draggable with minimal setup. It provides basic customization options for drag behavior, such as constraints and handle elements, but it does not support drop targets or complex drag-and-drop interactions. - react-dnd:
react-dnd
is highly customizable and designed for complex drag-and-drop interactions. It allows developers to define their own drag-and-drop logic, making it suitable for applications that require advanced features like nested drag-and-drop, custom drag previews, and more. - react-beautiful-dnd:
react-beautiful-dnd
provides a good balance of simplicity and customization. It allows for easy implementation of sortable lists and provides props for customizing the drag-and-drop experience, including animations, styles, and accessibility features. - @hello-pangea/dnd:
@hello-pangea/dnd
offers a simple API for basic drag-and-drop functionality, making it easy to implement without much configuration. However, it is not as customizable as some other libraries, which may limit its use in more complex scenarios.
Accessibility
- react-draggable:
react-draggable
provides basic accessibility features for draggable elements, but it is not specifically designed for drag-and-drop interactions. Developers may need to implement additional accessibility features, such as keyboard navigation and ARIA attributes, to make their draggable components fully accessible. - react-dnd:
react-dnd
provides basic accessibility features, but it requires developers to implement ARIA attributes and keyboard navigation manually. This library offers more flexibility for custom implementations but may require additional effort to ensure full accessibility. - react-beautiful-dnd:
react-beautiful-dnd
places a strong emphasis on accessibility, providing features like keyboard navigation, ARIA attributes, and support for screen readers. It is designed to be compliant with accessibility standards, making it a good choice for inclusive applications. - @hello-pangea/dnd:
@hello-pangea/dnd
is built with accessibility in mind, providing keyboard navigation and screen reader support out of the box. It follows WAI-ARIA guidelines to ensure that drag-and-drop interactions are usable by people with disabilities.
Performance
- react-draggable:
react-draggable
is lightweight and has minimal performance overhead for simple dragging interactions. However, performance may be affected if not implemented carefully, especially when dragging multiple elements or using complex animations. - react-dnd:
react-dnd
is flexible and can be optimized for performance, but it requires more manual effort to ensure efficient rendering and interaction. Developers need to be mindful of how they implement drag-and-drop logic to avoid performance issues, especially in complex or nested scenarios. - react-beautiful-dnd:
react-beautiful-dnd
is optimized for performance, especially in scenarios with large lists or complex drag-and-drop interactions. It uses techniques like virtual scrolling and optimized rendering to minimize performance bottlenecks, but it may require careful implementation to maintain performance in highly dynamic environments. - @hello-pangea/dnd:
@hello-pangea/dnd
is designed to be lightweight and performant, with minimal impact on rendering and interaction times. Its simple architecture and focus on core drag-and-drop functionality help keep performance overhead low.
Ease of Use: Code Examples
- react-draggable:
Basic Dragging with
react-draggable
import { Draggable } from 'react-draggable'; function App() { return ( <Draggable> <div style={{ width: '100px', height: '100px', background: 'lightgray' }}>Drag me</div> </Draggable> ); }
- react-dnd:
Basic Drag and Drop with
react-dnd
import { DndProvider, useDrag, useDrop } from 'react-dnd'; import { HTML5Backend } from 'react-dnd-html5-backend'; const ItemType = 'ITEM'; function DraggableItem() { const [{ isDragging }, drag] = useDrag({ type: ItemType, item: { id: 1 }, collect: (monitor) => ({ isDragging: monitor.isDragging() }), }); return <div ref={drag} style={{ opacity: isDragging ? 0.5 : 1 }}>Drag me</div>; } function DropZone() { const [{ isOver }, drop] = useDrop({ accept: ItemType, drop: (item) => console.log(`Dropped item: ${item.id}`), collect: (monitor) => ({ isOver: monitor.isOver() }), }); return <div ref={drop} style={{ background: isOver ? 'lightblue' : 'white', height: '100px' }}>Drop here</div>; } function App() { return ( <DndProvider backend={HTML5Backend}> <DraggableItem /> <DropZone /> </DndProvider> ); }
- react-beautiful-dnd:
Basic Drag and Drop with
react-beautiful-dnd
import { DragDropContext, Droppable, Draggable } from 'react-beautiful-dnd'; function App() { const onDragEnd = (result) => { // Handle the drag end event }; return ( <DragDropContext onDragEnd={onDragEnd}> <Droppable droppableId="droppable"> {(provided) => ( <div ref={provided.innerRef} {...provided.droppableProps}> <Draggable draggableId="draggable-1" index={0}> {(provided) => ( <div ref={provided.innerRef} {...provided.draggableProps} {...provided.dragHandleProps}> Drag me </div> )} </Draggable> {provided.placeholder} </div> )} </Droppable> </DragDropContext> ); }
- @hello-pangea/dnd:
Basic Drag and Drop with
@hello-pangea/dnd
import { DndProvider, DragDropContext, Droppable, Draggable } from '@hello-pangea/dnd'; function App() { return ( <DndProvider> <DragDropContext> <Droppable droppableId="droppable"> {(provided) => ( <div ref={provided.innerRef} {...provided.droppableProps}> <Draggable draggableId="draggable-1" index={0}> {(provided) => ( <div ref={provided.innerRef} {...provided.draggableProps} {...provided.dragHandleProps}> Drag me </div> )} </Draggable> {provided.placeholder} </div> )} </Droppable> </DragDropContext> </DndProvider> ); }