redux-devtools-extension vs @ngrx/store-devtools vs @ngneat/elf-devtools
State Management DevTools Comparison
1 Year
redux-devtools-extension@ngrx/store-devtools@ngneat/elf-devtoolsSimilar Packages:
What's State Management DevTools?

State management devtools are essential tools that enhance the development experience by providing a way to inspect, debug, and manipulate the state of applications built with various state management libraries. They allow developers to visualize state changes, track actions, and understand the flow of data within their applications. These tools are particularly useful for debugging complex applications, as they provide insights into how state changes over time, making it easier to identify issues and optimize performance. Each of the packages mentioned serves a specific purpose and is tailored to different state management paradigms, offering unique features that cater to various development needs.

Package Weekly Downloads Trend
Github Stars Ranking
Stat Detail
Package
Downloads
Stars
Size
Issues
Publish
License
redux-devtools-extension806,59713,498-2654 years agoMIT
@ngrx/store-devtools616,6278,107437 kB5818 days agoMIT
@ngneat/elf-devtools23,5731,6379.35 kB92 years agoMIT
Feature Comparison: redux-devtools-extension vs @ngrx/store-devtools vs @ngneat/elf-devtools

Integration

  • redux-devtools-extension:

    redux-devtools-extension is built to work with Redux, providing a rich set of debugging tools that enhance the Redux development experience. It integrates well with any Redux-based application, offering features like action logging and state inspection.

  • @ngrx/store-devtools:

    @ngrx/store-devtools integrates directly with NgRx, allowing developers to leverage NgRx's store architecture for enhanced debugging. It provides a seamless experience for tracking actions and state changes, making it a natural fit for Angular applications using NgRx.

  • @ngneat/elf-devtools:

    @ngneat/elf-devtools is specifically designed to integrate with the Elf state management library, providing tailored debugging features that align with Elf's modular architecture. It allows developers to easily inspect and manipulate state changes within Elf-managed stores.

Time Travel Debugging

  • redux-devtools-extension:

    redux-devtools-extension provides robust time travel debugging, allowing developers to navigate through the history of state changes. This feature helps in visualizing how actions affect the state over time, making it easier to debug and test applications.

  • @ngrx/store-devtools:

    @ngrx/store-devtools offers time travel capabilities, enabling developers to rewind and replay actions to see how the state changes. This feature is particularly useful for debugging complex state transitions and understanding the impact of specific actions on the application state.

  • @ngneat/elf-devtools:

    @ngneat/elf-devtools supports time travel debugging, allowing developers to step through state changes over time. This feature is invaluable for understanding how state evolves in response to actions, making it easier to identify bugs and optimize performance.

State Inspection

  • redux-devtools-extension:

    redux-devtools-extension offers powerful state inspection capabilities, allowing developers to view the entire Redux state tree and track how it changes in response to actions. This visibility is essential for debugging and optimizing Redux applications.

  • @ngrx/store-devtools:

    @ngrx/store-devtools provides comprehensive state inspection tools that allow developers to view the current state of the NgRx store, including the ability to see the state tree and the effects of dispatched actions. This is crucial for debugging and ensuring the application behaves as expected.

  • @ngneat/elf-devtools:

    @ngneat/elf-devtools allows for detailed state inspection, enabling developers to view the current state of Elf-managed stores at any point in time. This feature helps in understanding the structure and content of the state, facilitating easier debugging and optimization.

Performance Impact

  • redux-devtools-extension:

    redux-devtools-extension is built to minimize performance overhead, ensuring that the debugging features do not hinder the performance of Redux applications. This balance allows developers to utilize powerful debugging tools without sacrificing application speed.

  • @ngrx/store-devtools:

    @ngrx/store-devtools is optimized for performance, providing debugging capabilities without significantly affecting the runtime performance of NgRx applications. It allows developers to debug effectively while maintaining application responsiveness.

  • @ngneat/elf-devtools:

    @ngneat/elf-devtools is designed to have minimal performance impact on Elf applications, ensuring that debugging features do not slow down the application during development. This allows for efficient debugging without compromising application performance.

Community Support

  • redux-devtools-extension:

    redux-devtools-extension enjoys widespread adoption within the React and Redux communities, offering extensive documentation, tutorials, and community support. This makes it a reliable choice for developers looking for robust debugging tools.

  • @ngrx/store-devtools:

    @ngrx/store-devtools is backed by a large community of Angular developers, with extensive documentation and resources available. This strong community support makes it easier for developers to find solutions and best practices when using NgRx.

  • @ngneat/elf-devtools:

    @ngneat/elf-devtools benefits from a growing community around the Elf state management library, providing support and resources for developers using this tool. While it may not be as widely adopted as others, the community is active and supportive.

How to Choose: redux-devtools-extension vs @ngrx/store-devtools vs @ngneat/elf-devtools
  • redux-devtools-extension:

    Opt for redux-devtools-extension if you are using Redux for state management in React or other JavaScript applications. This package provides a powerful set of tools for inspecting and debugging Redux state, including time travel, action replay, and state persistence, making it a versatile choice for developers working with Redux.

  • @ngrx/store-devtools:

    Select @ngrx/store-devtools if you are working with NgRx, a popular state management library for Angular applications. This package integrates seamlessly with NgRx, offering time-travel debugging, state inspection, and action logging, making it ideal for complex Angular applications that require robust state management.

  • @ngneat/elf-devtools:

    Choose @ngneat/elf-devtools if you are using the Elf state management library, which is designed for Angular applications and emphasizes a modular and scalable approach to state management. This package provides powerful debugging capabilities tailored specifically for Elf's architecture.

README for redux-devtools-extension

Redux DevTools Extension's helper

Join the chat at https://gitter.im/zalmoxisus/redux-devtools-extension

Usage

Install:

npm install --save redux-devtools-extension

and use like that:

import { createStore, applyMiddleware } from 'redux';
import { composeWithDevTools } from 'redux-devtools-extension';

const store = createStore(
  reducer,
  composeWithDevTools(
    applyMiddleware(...middleware)
    // other store enhancers if any
  )
);

or if needed to apply extension’s options:

import { createStore, applyMiddleware } from 'redux';
import { composeWithDevTools } from 'redux-devtools-extension';

const composeEnhancers = composeWithDevTools({
  // Specify here name, actionsBlacklist, actionsCreators and other options
});
const store = createStore(
  reducer,
  composeEnhancers(
    applyMiddleware(...middleware)
    // other store enhancers if any
  )
);

There’re just few lines of code. If you don’t want to allow the extension in production, just use ‘redux-devtools-extension/developmentOnly’ instead of ‘redux-devtools-extension’.

License

MIT