Which is Better React Development Tools?
react-refresh vs @pmmmwh/react-refresh-webpack-plugin vs react-dev-utils vs react-hot-loader
1 Year
react-refresh@pmmmwh/react-refresh-webpack-pluginreact-dev-utilsreact-hot-loader
What's React Development Tools?

These npm packages are essential tools for enhancing the development experience in React applications, particularly when it comes to hot reloading and improving the speed of development. They facilitate a smoother workflow by allowing developers to see changes in real-time without losing the application state, thus significantly improving productivity and efficiency during the development process.

NPM Package Downloads Trend
Github Stars Ranking
Stat Detail
Package
Downloads
Stars
Size
Issues
Publish
License
react-refresh13,866,696228,51858.7 kB8356 months agoMIT
@pmmmwh/react-refresh-webpack-plugin6,360,4953,138133 kB625 months agoMIT
react-dev-utils4,322,921102,706111 kB2,256-MIT
react-hot-loader582,99612,256198 kB464-MIT
Feature Comparison: react-refresh vs @pmmmwh/react-refresh-webpack-plugin vs react-dev-utils vs react-hot-loader

Hot Reloading

  • react-refresh: This library is the foundation for React's fast refresh feature, enabling a more reliable and efficient hot reloading experience that works seamlessly with React's functional components and hooks.
  • @pmmmwh/react-refresh-webpack-plugin: This plugin integrates with Webpack to provide a fast refresh experience for React components. It allows components to be updated in real-time while preserving their state, which is crucial for a smooth development workflow.
  • react-dev-utils: While not primarily focused on hot reloading, it provides essential utilities that support development processes, including error overlays and performance monitoring, which can indirectly enhance the hot reloading experience.
  • react-hot-loader: This package is specifically designed for hot reloading React components. It allows developers to see changes instantly without losing the component's state, making it easier to iterate on UI designs.

Integration with Build Tools

  • react-refresh: This library can be used with various build tools, but it is primarily intended to work with modern React setups and is often used in conjunction with Webpack for optimal performance.
  • @pmmmwh/react-refresh-webpack-plugin: This package is tightly integrated with Webpack, making it an excellent choice for projects that use Webpack as their build tool. It simplifies the setup process for enabling fast refresh in React applications.
  • react-dev-utils: It is designed to work well with Create React App and other React setups, providing a range of utilities that enhance the development experience without requiring extensive configuration.
  • react-hot-loader: This package can be integrated into various build systems but is particularly effective with Webpack. It requires some configuration to set up properly, which can be a consideration for developers.

Ease of Use

  • react-refresh: This library is designed to be easy to integrate into existing React applications, especially those using functional components and hooks, providing a modern approach to hot reloading.
  • @pmmmwh/react-refresh-webpack-plugin: This plugin is straightforward to set up with Webpack, requiring minimal configuration to get started, making it user-friendly for developers.
  • react-dev-utils: It provides a set of pre-configured utilities that are easy to use, especially for those using Create React App, allowing developers to focus on building their applications without worrying about setup.
  • react-hot-loader: While powerful, it may require additional configuration compared to other options, which could pose a slight learning curve for new developers.

Community Support

  • react-refresh: Being part of the React ecosystem, this library benefits from strong community support and is actively maintained by the React team, ensuring it stays up-to-date with the latest React features.
  • @pmmmwh/react-refresh-webpack-plugin: As a popular choice among developers using Webpack, this plugin has a strong community backing and is actively maintained, ensuring ongoing support and updates.
  • react-dev-utils: This package is widely used in the React community, especially with Create React App, which means there is a wealth of resources and documentation available for developers.
  • react-hot-loader: Although it has been around for a while, its popularity has waned in favor of newer solutions like react-refresh. However, it still has a dedicated user base and community support.

Performance

  • react-refresh: This library is built with performance in mind, offering a more efficient hot reloading experience compared to older solutions, particularly in applications using hooks and functional components.
  • @pmmmwh/react-refresh-webpack-plugin: This plugin is optimized for performance, ensuring that updates are fast and efficient, which is critical for maintaining a smooth development experience.
  • react-dev-utils: While not directly impacting performance, it provides tools that help developers identify performance bottlenecks in their applications, contributing to overall efficiency.
  • react-hot-loader: It is designed to minimize the performance impact of hot reloading, but there can be instances where it may not perform as well as newer solutions, especially with complex component trees.
How to Choose: react-refresh vs @pmmmwh/react-refresh-webpack-plugin vs react-dev-utils vs react-hot-loader
  • react-refresh: Use this package if you want a more modern approach to hot reloading in React applications, as it is designed to work seamlessly with React's new features and provides a better developer experience.
  • @pmmmwh/react-refresh-webpack-plugin: Choose this plugin if you are using Webpack and want to enable fast refresh for React components, ensuring that your component state is preserved while making changes.
  • react-dev-utils: Opt for this package if you need a set of utility functions that enhance the development experience, especially when using Create React App, as it provides helpful scripts and configurations for development and testing.
  • react-hot-loader: Select this package if you are looking for a solution that allows you to edit React components in real-time without losing their state, making it ideal for rapid development cycles.
README for react-refresh

react-refresh

This package implements the wiring necessary to integrate Fast Refresh into bundlers. Fast Refresh is a feature that lets you edit React components in a running application without losing their state. It is similar to an old feature known as "hot reloading", but Fast Refresh is more reliable and officially supported by React.

This package is primarily aimed at developers of bundler plugins. If you’re working on one, here is a rough guide for Fast Refresh integration using this package.