@radix-ui/react-accordion vs react-accessible-accordion vs @reach/accordion
React Accordion Libraries Comparison
1 Year
@radix-ui/react-accordionreact-accessible-accordion@reach/accordionSimilar Packages:
What's React Accordion Libraries?

Accordion components are essential UI elements that allow users to expand and collapse content sections, enhancing the user experience by organizing information in a space-efficient manner. These libraries provide accessible and customizable accordion implementations for React applications, ensuring that developers can create interactive interfaces while adhering to web accessibility standards. Each library offers unique features and design philosophies, catering to different development needs and preferences.

Package Weekly Downloads Trend
Github Stars Ranking
Stat Detail
Package
Downloads
Stars
Size
Issues
Publish
License
@radix-ui/react-accordion5,600,61517,07290.1 kB6243 days agoMIT
react-accessible-accordion117,190790108 kB2921 days agoMIT
@reach/accordion59,8905,99658.4 kB98-MIT
Feature Comparison: @radix-ui/react-accordion vs react-accessible-accordion vs @reach/accordion

Accessibility

  • @radix-ui/react-accordion:

    Radix UI emphasizes accessibility by providing a headless component architecture, allowing developers to implement their own styles while ensuring that the underlying functionality meets WAI-ARIA standards. This approach enables fine-tuned control over keyboard interactions and screen reader support.

  • react-accessible-accordion:

    React Accessible Accordion offers built-in accessibility features that comply with ARIA standards. It provides a simple API that allows developers to create accessible accordions quickly, ensuring that all users can interact with the content effectively.

  • @reach/accordion:

    Reach Accordion is designed with accessibility as a core principle, adhering closely to WAI-ARIA specifications. It ensures that all interactive elements are keyboard-navigable and screen reader-friendly, making it an excellent choice for projects focused on inclusivity.

Customization

  • @radix-ui/react-accordion:

    Radix UI's headless design allows for extensive customization, enabling developers to style the accordion components as needed without being constrained by predefined styles. This flexibility is ideal for projects requiring unique branding or design systems.

  • react-accessible-accordion:

    React Accessible Accordion offers basic customization options, allowing developers to style the accordion through props and CSS. However, it may not provide as much flexibility as Radix UI for complex designs.

  • @reach/accordion:

    Reach Accordion provides some level of customization, but it is more opinionated in terms of styling. While it allows for theming, developers may find it less flexible compared to Radix UI in terms of complete visual control.

Learning Curve

  • @radix-ui/react-accordion:

    The learning curve for Radix UI can be moderate due to its headless nature, requiring developers to understand how to implement their own styles and behaviors effectively. However, once grasped, it offers powerful customization capabilities.

  • react-accessible-accordion:

    React Accessible Accordion is designed for quick implementation, featuring a simple API that is easy to learn. Developers can get started rapidly, making it suitable for those who need to implement an accordion without extensive configuration.

  • @reach/accordion:

    Reach Accordion has a relatively gentle learning curve, making it easy for developers to integrate and use. Its straightforward API and adherence to accessibility standards make it accessible for developers of all skill levels.

Performance

  • @radix-ui/react-accordion:

    Radix UI is optimized for performance, allowing developers to create lightweight components that only render what is necessary. This can lead to improved performance in larger applications where many components are present.

  • react-accessible-accordion:

    React Accessible Accordion is also designed for performance, but it may not be as optimized as Radix UI. It provides a good balance between ease of use and performance, making it suitable for most applications.

  • @reach/accordion:

    Reach Accordion is lightweight and efficient, ensuring that it does not introduce significant overhead. Its design focuses on performance while maintaining accessibility, making it suitable for performance-sensitive applications.

Community and Support

  • @radix-ui/react-accordion:

    Radix UI has a growing community and is backed by a team focused on accessibility and design systems. This support can be beneficial for developers seeking guidance and best practices.

  • react-accessible-accordion:

    React Accessible Accordion has a smaller community compared to the others, but it is well-documented and offers sufficient support for developers looking to implement accessible accordions.

  • @reach/accordion:

    Reach Accordion is part of the Reach UI library, which has a solid reputation for accessibility. The community around Reach UI is active, providing resources and support for developers.

How to Choose: @radix-ui/react-accordion vs react-accessible-accordion vs @reach/accordion
  • @radix-ui/react-accordion:

    Choose Radix UI if you prioritize accessibility and a headless design approach, allowing for maximum customization of styles and behavior without being tied to a specific visual implementation.

  • react-accessible-accordion:

    Opt for React Accessible Accordion if you need a straightforward and easy-to-use accordion component that provides built-in accessibility features and a simple API for quick implementation.

  • @reach/accordion:

    Select Reach Accordion if you want a lightweight, accessible solution that follows WAI-ARIA guidelines closely, making it suitable for projects that require strict adherence to accessibility standards without extensive customization.

README for @radix-ui/react-accordion

react-accordion

View docs here.