@radix-ui/react-alert-dialog vs react-modal vs @reach/dialog
React Dialog Libraries Comparison
1 Year
@radix-ui/react-alert-dialogreact-modal@reach/dialogSimilar Packages:
What's React Dialog Libraries?

Dialog libraries in React provide a way to create modal dialogs that can display alerts, confirmations, or other types of content over the main application. These libraries help manage accessibility, focus control, and user interactions, ensuring that dialogs are user-friendly and comply with web standards. They often come with built-in features to handle keyboard navigation, screen reader support, and customizable styling, making it easier for developers to implement modals in their applications without reinventing the wheel.

Package Weekly Downloads Trend
Github Stars Ranking
Stat Detail
Package
Downloads
Stars
Size
Issues
Publish
License
@radix-ui/react-alert-dialog1,765,63716,61589.7 kB567a month agoMIT
react-modal1,736,0067,399188 kB2003 months agoMIT
@reach/dialog183,1705,98753.3 kB97-MIT
Feature Comparison: @radix-ui/react-alert-dialog vs react-modal vs @reach/dialog

Accessibility

  • @radix-ui/react-alert-dialog:

    Radix UI Alert Dialog is designed with accessibility in mind, following WAI-ARIA guidelines. It ensures that all dialog interactions are keyboard-navigable and screen reader-friendly, providing a seamless experience for users with disabilities.

  • react-modal:

    React Modal offers basic accessibility features, but it requires additional configuration to fully comply with accessibility standards. Developers may need to implement focus trapping and ARIA attributes manually to ensure a fully accessible experience.

  • @reach/dialog:

    Reach Dialog emphasizes accessibility by default, ensuring that focus management and keyboard interactions are handled correctly. It provides ARIA roles and properties to help assistive technologies understand the dialog's purpose and state.

Customization

  • @radix-ui/react-alert-dialog:

    Radix UI allows for extensive customization of the dialog's appearance and behavior through its flexible API. Developers can easily style components using CSS-in-JS solutions or traditional CSS, making it suitable for applications with unique design requirements.

  • react-modal:

    React Modal offers limited customization options out of the box. While it allows for basic styling through props, achieving complex designs may require additional wrappers or custom components.

  • @reach/dialog:

    Reach Dialog provides a simple API for customization, but it may not offer as much flexibility as Radix UI. It allows for basic styling but may require additional work for complex designs or behaviors.

Learning Curve

  • @radix-ui/react-alert-dialog:

    Radix UI has a moderate learning curve due to its comprehensive API and focus on accessibility. Developers may need to familiarize themselves with the library's concepts and best practices to fully leverage its capabilities.

  • react-modal:

    React Modal is simple to use and has a low learning curve, making it accessible for beginners. However, developers may need to invest time in enhancing accessibility features for a production-ready implementation.

  • @reach/dialog:

    Reach Dialog is relatively easy to learn, especially for developers already familiar with React. Its straightforward API and emphasis on accessibility make it a good choice for those new to dialog components.

Integration

  • @radix-ui/react-alert-dialog:

    Radix UI integrates well with other Radix components, providing a cohesive development experience. It is designed to work seamlessly within the Radix ecosystem, making it ideal for projects that utilize multiple Radix components.

  • react-modal:

    React Modal can be integrated into any React application with minimal setup. Its simplicity makes it a popular choice for quick implementations, though it may require additional work for more complex use cases.

  • @reach/dialog:

    Reach Dialog is designed to integrate easily into existing React applications without requiring significant changes to the codebase. It works well alongside other libraries and frameworks, allowing for smooth implementation.

Performance

  • @radix-ui/react-alert-dialog:

    Radix UI Alert Dialog is optimized for performance, ensuring that rendering and updates are efficient. It minimizes unnecessary re-renders and provides a smooth user experience even with complex dialogs.

  • react-modal:

    React Modal is generally performant for basic use cases, but performance may degrade with complex modals or heavy content. Developers should be mindful of rendering strategies to maintain optimal performance.

  • @reach/dialog:

    Reach Dialog is lightweight and performs well, making it suitable for applications where performance is a concern. Its focus on simplicity helps maintain fast load times and responsiveness.

How to Choose: @radix-ui/react-alert-dialog vs react-modal vs @reach/dialog
  • @radix-ui/react-alert-dialog:

    Choose Radix UI Alert Dialog if you need a highly customizable and accessible dialog component that adheres to WAI-ARIA standards. It is ideal for projects that prioritize design consistency and accessibility, offering a flexible API for advanced use cases.

  • react-modal:

    Opt for React Modal if you need a simple and widely-used modal library that provides basic modal functionality with minimal setup. It is suitable for projects that require quick implementation and do not need extensive customization or advanced features.

  • @reach/dialog:

    Select Reach Dialog if you are looking for a lightweight and accessible solution that integrates well with existing React applications. It is particularly useful for developers who want a straightforward implementation with a focus on accessibility without additional overhead.

README for @radix-ui/react-alert-dialog

react-alert-dialog

Installation

$ yarn add @radix-ui/react-alert-dialog
# or
$ npm install @radix-ui/react-alert-dialog

Usage

View docs here.