@radix-ui/react-portal vs react-portal vs @reach/portal
React Portal Libraries Comparison
1 Year
@radix-ui/react-portalreact-portal@reach/portal
What's React Portal Libraries?

Portal libraries in React provide a way to render children into a DOM node that exists outside the hierarchy of the parent component. This is particularly useful for modals, tooltips, and dropdowns, where the rendered content needs to visually break out of the parent container's overflow or positioning constraints. Each of these libraries offers unique features and design philosophies, catering to different use cases and developer preferences.

Package Weekly Downloads Trend
Github Stars Ranking
Stat Detail
Package
Downloads
Stars
Size
Issues
Publish
License
@radix-ui/react-portal9,889,51516,58710.7 kB566a month agoMIT
react-portal656,2792,15039.2 kB16a month agoMIT
@reach/portal429,8395,98620.7 kB97-MIT
Feature Comparison: @radix-ui/react-portal vs react-portal vs @reach/portal

Accessibility

  • @radix-ui/react-portal:

    Radix UI Portal is built with accessibility in mind, ensuring that the rendered content is keyboard navigable and screen reader friendly. It follows ARIA practices, making it suitable for applications that require compliance with accessibility standards.

  • react-portal:

    React Portal does not inherently provide accessibility features, as it is a low-level API. Developers must implement accessibility considerations themselves, which may require additional effort to ensure compliance with best practices.

  • @reach/portal:

    Reach Portal prioritizes accessibility by default, providing a simple API that ensures the rendered elements are accessible. It is designed to work seamlessly with other Reach UI components, which also focus on accessibility, making it a great choice for inclusive applications.

Customization

  • @radix-ui/react-portal:

    Radix UI Portal offers extensive customization options, allowing developers to style and structure the portal content as needed. It integrates well with other Radix components, enabling complex UI patterns while maintaining a consistent design language.

  • react-portal:

    React Portal provides a minimalistic approach, allowing developers to fully control the rendering of the portal content. This means you can implement any custom styles or behaviors, but it requires more effort to achieve consistency across different use cases.

  • @reach/portal:

    Reach Portal is designed to be simple and straightforward, with limited customization options. While it allows for basic styling, it may not provide the same level of flexibility as Radix UI for more complex use cases.

Integration

  • @radix-ui/react-portal:

    Radix UI Portal integrates seamlessly with other Radix components, making it an ideal choice for applications that utilize the Radix UI ecosystem. This integration simplifies the development process and ensures consistent behavior across components.

  • react-portal:

    React Portal is a standalone solution that can be integrated into any React application. However, it does not provide built-in integration with other libraries, meaning developers may need to handle compatibility issues manually.

  • @reach/portal:

    Reach Portal can be easily integrated with other Reach UI components, providing a cohesive experience for building accessible UIs. Its compatibility with Reach UI makes it a strong candidate for projects focused on accessibility.

Learning Curve

  • @radix-ui/react-portal:

    Radix UI Portal has a moderate learning curve, especially for developers familiar with the Radix ecosystem. Its comprehensive documentation and examples help ease the learning process, making it accessible to both beginners and experienced developers.

  • react-portal:

    React Portal has a low learning curve, especially for developers already familiar with React. Since it leverages the built-in Portal API, developers can quickly understand how to use it without needing to learn additional concepts.

  • @reach/portal:

    Reach Portal is designed to be simple and easy to use, making it suitable for developers of all skill levels. Its straightforward API and focus on accessibility reduce the learning curve, allowing for quick implementation.

Performance

  • @radix-ui/react-portal:

    Radix UI Portal is optimized for performance, ensuring that rendering is efficient and does not introduce unnecessary overhead. It is designed to handle complex UI patterns without compromising performance, making it suitable for high-performance applications.

  • react-portal:

    React Portal is inherently performant due to its low-level nature, allowing developers to optimize rendering as needed. However, performance may vary depending on how the portal is implemented and managed within the application.

  • @reach/portal:

    Reach Portal is lightweight and performs well, as it focuses on providing essential functionality without additional bloat. This makes it a good choice for applications where performance is a priority.

How to Choose: @radix-ui/react-portal vs react-portal vs @reach/portal
  • @radix-ui/react-portal:

    Choose Radix UI Portal if you need a highly customizable and accessible solution that integrates well with other Radix components. It is designed with a focus on accessibility and provides a solid foundation for building complex UI patterns.

  • react-portal:

    Opt for React Portal if you prefer a simple, minimalistic approach and want to leverage the built-in React Portal API without additional dependencies. It is best suited for projects where you want to keep the bundle size small and have full control over the rendering behavior.

  • @reach/portal:

    Select Reach Portal if you are looking for a lightweight and straightforward solution that emphasizes accessibility. It is part of the Reach UI library, which aims to provide accessible components for React applications without unnecessary complexity.

README for @radix-ui/react-portal

react-portal

Installation

$ yarn add @radix-ui/react-portal
# or
$ npm install @radix-ui/react-portal

Usage

View docs here.