bcrypt vs bcrypt-nodejs vs bcryptjs
Password Hashing Libraries
bcryptbcrypt-nodejsbcryptjsSimilar Packages:

Password Hashing Libraries

Password hashing libraries are essential tools in web development for securely storing user passwords. They implement cryptographic algorithms to transform plain-text passwords into hashed values, making it difficult for unauthorized users to retrieve the original passwords. These libraries typically provide functionalities for hashing passwords, comparing hashed values, and managing salt to enhance security. Choosing the right library is crucial for ensuring the security and performance of applications that handle sensitive user data.

Npm Package Weekly Downloads Trend

3 Years

Github Stars Ranking

Stat Detail

Package
Downloads
Stars
Size
Issues
Publish
License
bcrypt07,7801.11 MB3010 months agoMIT
bcrypt-nodejs0---13 years ago-
bcryptjs03,788112 kB44 months agoBSD-3-Clause

Feature Comparison: bcrypt vs bcrypt-nodejs vs bcryptjs

Performance

  • bcrypt:

    bcrypt is optimized for performance through native bindings, which provide faster hashing and comparison operations. This makes it suitable for applications with high user traffic, where speed is essential.

  • bcrypt-nodejs:

    bcrypt-nodejs is implemented entirely in JavaScript, which may result in slower performance compared to bcrypt. It is more suited for smaller applications or development environments where ease of use is prioritized over speed.

  • bcryptjs:

    bcryptjs is also a pure JavaScript implementation, offering decent performance but generally slower than bcrypt. It is ideal for projects that require simplicity and ease of integration without the need for native compilation.

Ease of Use

  • bcrypt:

    bcrypt requires native compilation, which can complicate installation and deployment, especially in serverless or containerized environments. However, once set up, it offers a straightforward API for hashing and verifying passwords.

  • bcrypt-nodejs:

    bcrypt-nodejs is easy to install and use, as it does not require any native dependencies. This makes it a good choice for developers looking for a hassle-free setup without the need for additional build tools.

  • bcryptjs:

    bcryptjs offers a simple and intuitive API, making it easy for developers to implement password hashing and verification without any complex setup. It is particularly useful for quick prototypes or smaller projects.

Security Features

  • bcrypt:

    bcrypt incorporates salting and adjustable work factors, which enhance security by making it more difficult for attackers to use precomputed hash tables (rainbow tables) to crack passwords. The work factor can be adjusted to increase hashing time as computational power increases over time.

  • bcrypt-nodejs:

    bcrypt-nodejs also supports salting and adjustable work factors, but being a pure JavaScript implementation, it may not be as secure as bcrypt in high-performance scenarios. It is still effective for many applications but may lag behind in security features compared to its native counterpart.

  • bcryptjs:

    bcryptjs supports salting and provides a configurable work factor, allowing developers to balance security and performance. However, it may not be as robust as bcrypt in high-security environments, making it more suitable for less critical applications.

Compatibility

  • bcrypt:

    bcrypt is compatible with various platforms and languages due to its native bindings, making it a versatile choice for applications that may need to interface with other languages or frameworks.

  • bcrypt-nodejs:

    bcrypt-nodejs is designed to work seamlessly in JavaScript environments, making it a good choice for Node.js applications. However, it may not be as compatible with other programming languages or platforms as bcrypt.

  • bcryptjs:

    bcryptjs is purely JavaScript and works well in any JavaScript environment, including Node.js and browser-based applications. Its compatibility makes it a flexible option for developers working within the JavaScript ecosystem.

Community Support

  • bcrypt:

    bcrypt has a large community and extensive documentation, making it easy to find resources, tutorials, and support. This can be beneficial for developers facing challenges during implementation.

  • bcrypt-nodejs:

    bcrypt-nodejs has a smaller community compared to bcrypt, which may result in fewer resources and community support. However, it is still widely used and has sufficient documentation for most use cases.

  • bcryptjs:

    bcryptjs enjoys a growing community and good documentation, providing developers with ample resources and examples to assist with implementation. Its popularity in the JavaScript community ensures ongoing support and updates.

How to Choose: bcrypt vs bcrypt-nodejs vs bcryptjs

  • bcrypt:

    Choose bcrypt if you need a widely-used, robust library that utilizes native bindings for performance. It is suitable for production environments where security and speed are critical, but it requires native compilation, which may complicate deployment.

  • bcrypt-nodejs:

    Choose bcrypt-nodejs if you prefer a pure JavaScript implementation that is easier to install and use in environments where native compilation is not feasible. However, it may not perform as well as its native counterpart, making it less suitable for high-load applications.

  • bcryptjs:

    Choose bcryptjs if you need a pure JavaScript implementation that is lightweight and easy to integrate into your project. It is a good choice for applications where performance is less critical, and it provides a straightforward API for hashing and comparing passwords.

README for bcrypt

node.bcrypt.js

ci

Build Status

A library to help you hash passwords.

You can read about bcrypt in Wikipedia as well as in the following article: How To Safely Store A Password

If You Are Submitting Bugs or Issues

Please verify that the NodeJS version you are using is a stable version; Unstable versions are currently not supported and issues created while using an unstable version will be closed.

If you are on a stable version of NodeJS, please provide a sufficient code snippet or log files for installation issues. The code snippet does not require you to include confidential information. However, it must provide enough information so the problem can be replicable, or it may be closed without an explanation.

Version Compatibility

Please upgrade to atleast v5.0.0 to avoid security issues mentioned below.

Node VersionBcrypt Version
0.4<= 0.4
0.6, 0.8, 0.10>= 0.5
0.11>= 0.8
4<= 2.1.0
8>= 1.0.3 < 4.0.0
10, 11>= 3
12 onwards>= 3.0.6

node-gyp only works with stable/released versions of node. Since the bcrypt module uses node-gyp to build and install, you'll need a stable version of node to use bcrypt. If you do not, you'll likely see an error that starts with:

gyp ERR! stack Error: "pre" versions of node cannot be installed, use the --nodedir flag instead

Security Issues And Concerns

Per bcrypt implementation, only the first 72 bytes of a string are used. Any extra bytes are ignored when matching passwords. Note that this is not the first 72 characters. It is possible for a string to contain less than 72 characters, while taking up more than 72 bytes (e.g. a UTF-8 encoded string containing emojis). If a string is provided, it will be encoded using UTF-8.

As should be the case with any security tool, anyone using this library should scrutinise it. If you find or suspect an issue with the code, please bring it to the maintainers' attention. We will spend some time ensuring that this library is as secure as possible.

Here is a list of BCrypt-related security issues/concerns that have come up over the years.

  • An issue with passwords was found with a version of the Blowfish algorithm developed for John the Ripper. This is not present in the OpenBSD version and is thus not a problem for this module. HT zooko.
  • Versions < 5.0.0 suffer from bcrypt wrap-around bug and will truncate passwords >= 255 characters leading to severely weakened passwords. Please upgrade at earliest. See this wiki page for more details.
  • Versions < 5.0.0 do not handle NUL characters inside passwords properly leading to all subsequent characters being dropped and thus resulting in severely weakened passwords. Please upgrade at earliest. See this wiki page for more details.

Compatibility Note

This library supports $2a$ and $2b$ prefix bcrypt hashes. $2x$ and $2y$ hashes are specific to bcrypt implementation developed for John the Ripper. In theory, they should be compatible with $2b$ prefix.

Compatibility with hashes generated by other languages is not 100% guaranteed due to difference in character encodings. However, it should not be an issue for most cases.

Migrating from v1.0.x

Hashes generated in earlier version of bcrypt remain 100% supported in v2.x.x and later versions. In most cases, the migration should be a bump in the package.json.

Hashes generated in v2.x.x using the defaults parameters will not work in earlier versions.

Dependencies

  • NodeJS
  • node-gyp
  • Please check the dependencies for this tool at: https://github.com/nodejs/node-gyp
  • Windows users will need the options for c# and c++ installed with their visual studio instance.
  • Python 2.x/3.x
  • OpenSSL - This is only required to build the bcrypt project if you are using versions <= 0.7.7. Otherwise, we're using the builtin node crypto bindings for seed data (which use the same OpenSSL code paths we were, but don't have the external dependency).

Install via NPM

npm install bcrypt

Note: OS X users using Xcode 4.3.1 or above may need to run the following command in their terminal prior to installing if errors occur regarding xcodebuild: sudo xcode-select -switch /Applications/Xcode.app/Contents/Developer

Pre-built binaries for various NodeJS versions are made available on a best-effort basis.

Only the current stable and supported LTS releases are actively tested against.

There may be an interval between the release of the module and the availabilty of the compiled modules.

Currently, we have pre-built binaries that support the following platforms:

  1. Windows x32 and x64
  2. Linux x64 (GlibC and musl)
  3. macOS

If you face an error like this:

node-pre-gyp ERR! Tried to download(404): https://github.com/kelektiv/node.bcrypt.js/releases/download/v1.0.2/bcrypt_lib-v1.0.2-node-v48-linux-x64.tar.gz

make sure you have the appropriate dependencies installed and configured for your platform. You can find installation instructions for the dependencies for some common platforms in this page.

Usage

async (recommended)

const bcrypt = require('bcrypt');
const saltRounds = 10;
const myPlaintextPassword = 's0/\/\P4$$w0rD';
const someOtherPlaintextPassword = 'not_bacon';

To hash a password:

Technique 1 (generate a salt and hash on separate function calls):

bcrypt.genSalt(saltRounds, function(err, salt) {
    bcrypt.hash(myPlaintextPassword, salt, function(err, hash) {
        // Store hash in your password DB.
    });
});

Technique 2 (auto-gen a salt and hash):

bcrypt.hash(myPlaintextPassword, saltRounds, function(err, hash) {
    // Store hash in your password DB.
});

Note that both techniques achieve the same end-result.

To check a password:

// Load hash from your password DB.
bcrypt.compare(myPlaintextPassword, hash, function(err, result) {
    // result == true
});
bcrypt.compare(someOtherPlaintextPassword, hash, function(err, result) {
    // result == false
});

A Note on Timing Attacks

with promises

bcrypt uses whatever Promise implementation is available in global.Promise. NodeJS >= 0.12 has a native Promise implementation built in. However, this should work in any Promises/A+ compliant implementation.

Async methods that accept a callback, return a Promise when callback is not specified if Promise support is available.

bcrypt.hash(myPlaintextPassword, saltRounds).then(function(hash) {
    // Store hash in your password DB.
});
// Load hash from your password DB.
bcrypt.compare(myPlaintextPassword, hash).then(function(result) {
    // result == true
});
bcrypt.compare(someOtherPlaintextPassword, hash).then(function(result) {
    // result == false
});

This is also compatible with async/await

async function checkUser(username, password) {
    //... fetch user from a db etc.

    const match = await bcrypt.compare(password, user.passwordHash);

    if(match) {
        //login
    }

    //...
}

ESM import

import bcrypt from "bcrypt";

// later
await bcrypt.compare(password, hash);

sync

const bcrypt = require('bcrypt');
const saltRounds = 10;
const myPlaintextPassword = 's0/\/\P4$$w0rD';
const someOtherPlaintextPassword = 'not_bacon';

To hash a password:

Technique 1 (generate a salt and hash on separate function calls):

const salt = bcrypt.genSaltSync(saltRounds);
const hash = bcrypt.hashSync(myPlaintextPassword, salt);
// Store hash in your password DB.

Technique 2 (auto-gen a salt and hash):

const hash = bcrypt.hashSync(myPlaintextPassword, saltRounds);
// Store hash in your password DB.

As with async, both techniques achieve the same end-result.

To check a password:

// Load hash from your password DB.
bcrypt.compareSync(myPlaintextPassword, hash); // true
bcrypt.compareSync(someOtherPlaintextPassword, hash); // false

A Note on Timing Attacks

Why is async mode recommended over sync mode?

We recommend using async API if you use bcrypt on a server. Bcrypt hashing is CPU intensive which will cause the sync APIs to block the event loop and prevent your application from servicing any inbound requests or events. The async version uses a thread pool which does not block the main event loop.

API

BCrypt.

  • genSaltSync(rounds, minor)
    • rounds - [OPTIONAL] - the cost of processing the data. (default - 10)
    • minor - [OPTIONAL] - minor version of bcrypt to use. (default - b)
  • genSalt(rounds, minor, cb)
    • rounds - [OPTIONAL] - the cost of processing the data. (default - 10)
    • minor - [OPTIONAL] - minor version of bcrypt to use. (default - b)
    • cb - [OPTIONAL] - a callback to be fired once the salt has been generated. uses eio making it asynchronous. If cb is not specified, a Promise is returned if Promise support is available.
      • err - First parameter to the callback detailing any errors.
      • salt - Second parameter to the callback providing the generated salt.
  • hashSync(data, salt)
    • data - [REQUIRED] - the data to be encrypted.
    • salt - [REQUIRED] - the salt to be used to hash the password. if specified as a number then a salt will be generated with the specified number of rounds and used (see example under Usage).
  • hash(data, salt, cb)
    • data - [REQUIRED] - the data to be encrypted.
    • salt - [REQUIRED] - the salt to be used to hash the password. if specified as a number then a salt will be generated with the specified number of rounds and used (see example under Usage).
    • cb - [OPTIONAL] - a callback to be fired once the data has been encrypted. uses eio making it asynchronous. If cb is not specified, a Promise is returned if Promise support is available.
      • err - First parameter to the callback detailing any errors.
      • encrypted - Second parameter to the callback providing the encrypted form.
  • compareSync(data, encrypted)
    • data - [REQUIRED] - data to compare.
    • encrypted - [REQUIRED] - data to be compared to.
  • compare(data, encrypted, cb)
    • data - [REQUIRED] - data to compare.
    • encrypted - [REQUIRED] - data to be compared to.
    • cb - [OPTIONAL] - a callback to be fired once the data has been compared. uses eio making it asynchronous. If cb is not specified, a Promise is returned if Promise support is available.
      • err - First parameter to the callback detailing any errors.
      • same - Second parameter to the callback providing whether the data and encrypted forms match [true | false].
  • getRounds(encrypted) - return the number of rounds used to encrypt a given hash
    • encrypted - [REQUIRED] - hash from which the number of rounds used should be extracted.

A Note on Rounds

A note about the cost: when you are hashing your data, the module will go through a series of rounds to give you a secure hash. The value you submit is not just the number of rounds the module will go through to hash your data. The module will use the value you enter and go through 2^rounds hashing iterations.

From @garthk, on a 2GHz core you can roughly expect:

rounds=8 : ~40 hashes/sec
rounds=9 : ~20 hashes/sec
rounds=10: ~10 hashes/sec
rounds=11: ~5  hashes/sec
rounds=12: 2-3 hashes/sec
rounds=13: ~1 sec/hash
rounds=14: ~1.5 sec/hash
rounds=15: ~3 sec/hash
rounds=25: ~1 hour/hash
rounds=31: 2-3 days/hash

A Note on Timing Attacks

Because it's come up multiple times in this project and other bcrypt projects, it needs to be said. The bcrypt library is not susceptible to timing attacks. From codahale/bcrypt-ruby#42:

One of the desired properties of a cryptographic hash function is preimage attack resistance, which means there is no shortcut for generating a message which, when hashed, produces a specific digest.

A great thread on this, in much more detail can be found @ codahale/bcrypt-ruby#43

If you're unfamiliar with timing attacks and want to learn more you can find a great writeup @ A Lesson In Timing Attacks

However, timing attacks are real. And the comparison function is not time safe. That means that it may exit the function early in the comparison process. Timing attacks happen because of the above. We don't need to be careful that an attacker will learn anything, and our comparison function provides a comparison of hashes. It is a utility to the overall purpose of the library. If you end up using it for something else, we cannot guarantee the security of the comparator. Keep that in mind as you use the library.

Hash Info

The characters that comprise the resultant hash are ./ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZabcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz0123456789$.

Resultant hashes will be 60 characters long and they will include the salt among other parameters, as follows:

$[algorithm]$[cost]$[salt][hash]

  • 2 chars hash algorithm identifier prefix. "$2a$" or "$2b$" indicates BCrypt
  • Cost-factor (n). Represents the exponent used to determine how many iterations 2^n
  • 16-byte (128-bit) salt, base64 encoded to 22 characters
  • 24-byte (192-bit) hash, base64 encoded to 31 characters

Example:

$2b$10$nOUIs5kJ7naTuTFkBy1veuK0kSxUFXfuaOKdOKf9xYT0KKIGSJwFa
 |  |  |                     |
 |  |  |                     hash-value = K0kSxUFXfuaOKdOKf9xYT0KKIGSJwFa
 |  |  |
 |  |  salt = nOUIs5kJ7naTuTFkBy1veu
 |  |
 |  cost-factor => 10 = 2^10 rounds
 |
 hash-algorithm identifier => 2b = BCrypt

Testing

If you create a pull request, tests better pass :)

npm install
npm test

Credits

The code for this comes from a few sources:

Contributors

License

Unless stated elsewhere, file headers or otherwise, the license as stated in the LICENSE file.