form-data vs busboy vs formidable vs multer vs express-fileupload
File Upload Middleware for Node.js Comparison
1 Year
form-databusboyformidablemulterexpress-fileuploadSimilar Packages:
What's File Upload Middleware for Node.js?

These npm packages are designed to handle file uploads in Node.js applications. They provide various functionalities for parsing incoming multipart/form-data requests, which is essential for handling file uploads from clients. Each package has its own strengths and weaknesses, making them suitable for different scenarios based on project requirements, performance needs, and ease of use. Understanding these differences is crucial for selecting the right package for your application.

Package Weekly Downloads Trend
Github Stars Ranking
Stat Detail
Package
Downloads
Stars
Size
Issues
Publish
License
form-data87,695,5742,30131.8 kB1343 days agoMIT
busboy15,667,4842,897124 kB35--
formidable11,301,3977,096203 kB514 months agoMIT
multer6,466,98111,70427.6 kB269-MIT
express-fileupload440,2061,540116 kB217 months agoMIT
Feature Comparison: form-data vs busboy vs formidable vs multer vs express-fileupload

Ease of Use

  • form-data:

    Form-data is primarily used for sending files to external services rather than handling uploads, so it does not provide an easy interface for incoming file uploads.

  • busboy:

    Busboy is a low-level streaming parser that requires more setup and understanding of streams. It may not be the best choice for beginners or those looking for a quick implementation.

  • formidable:

    Formidable offers a straightforward API for handling file uploads, but it may require a bit more configuration compared to express-fileupload.

  • multer:

    Multer is easy to set up and integrates seamlessly with Express.js, providing a user-friendly experience for handling file uploads.

  • express-fileupload:

    Express-fileupload is designed for simplicity and ease of use, making it ideal for developers who want to quickly implement file uploads without extensive configuration.

Performance

  • form-data:

    Form-data is not used for handling incoming uploads, so performance considerations are more relevant when sending files to external services.

  • busboy:

    Busboy is highly performant due to its streaming nature, allowing for efficient handling of large files without consuming excessive memory.

  • formidable:

    Formidable performs well for moderate file sizes but can become slower with very large files due to its processing model.

  • multer:

    Multer is efficient for handling file uploads, especially when configured with disk storage, but may require optimization for very large files.

  • express-fileupload:

    Express-fileupload is suitable for small to medium files, but may not perform as well as Busboy for larger uploads due to its in-memory processing.

File Size Limitations

  • form-data:

    Form-data does not impose file size limits as it is used for sending files, not receiving them.

  • busboy:

    Busboy allows you to set file size limits easily, making it suitable for applications that need to enforce strict upload limits.

  • formidable:

    Formidable allows you to set file size limits and provides feedback on upload progress, making it a good choice for applications that need to manage large uploads.

  • multer:

    Multer allows you to set file size limits and provides options for handling errors when limits are exceeded.

  • express-fileupload:

    Express-fileupload also supports file size limits, but it may not be as flexible as Busboy in terms of configuration.

Streaming Support

  • form-data:

    Form-data is designed for constructing requests, not for streaming uploads, so it lacks this feature.

  • busboy:

    Busboy excels in streaming file uploads, allowing files to be processed as they are received, which is ideal for large files.

  • formidable:

    Formidable supports streaming uploads, allowing for efficient processing of files as they are received, similar to Busboy.

  • multer:

    Multer does not support streaming in the same way as Busboy, as it buffers files in memory or on disk before processing.

  • express-fileupload:

    Express-fileupload does not support streaming; it buffers the entire file in memory before processing, which may lead to performance issues with large files.

Integration with Express

  • form-data:

    Form-data is not designed for Express integration, as it is used for sending requests rather than handling them.

  • busboy:

    Busboy can be integrated with Express, but it requires more manual setup compared to other packages.

  • formidable:

    Formidable can be integrated with Express, but it requires additional setup compared to express-fileupload.

  • multer:

    Multer is built for Express and provides a straightforward middleware approach, making it very easy to use in Express applications.

  • express-fileupload:

    Express-fileupload is specifically designed for Express, making it the easiest to integrate with minimal configuration.

How to Choose: form-data vs busboy vs formidable vs multer vs express-fileupload
  • form-data:

    Use form-data if you need to construct and send multipart/form-data requests from Node.js. It is particularly useful for scenarios where you need to upload files to an external API or service, rather than handling incoming uploads.

  • busboy:

    Choose Busboy if you need a lightweight and efficient solution for handling file uploads with a focus on performance. It streams the files directly to the filesystem or memory, which is ideal for applications that require high throughput and low memory usage.

  • formidable:

    Opt for Formidable if you require robust parsing capabilities and support for file uploads. It handles file uploads well and provides a rich set of features, including progress events and file size limits, making it suitable for more complex applications.

  • multer:

    Choose Multer if you are looking for a middleware that integrates directly with Express.js and provides a simple way to handle file uploads. It offers various storage options and is particularly useful for applications that need to manage uploaded files efficiently.

  • express-fileupload:

    Select express-fileupload for a simple and easy-to-use middleware that integrates seamlessly with Express.js. It is suitable for small to medium-sized applications where ease of setup and use is prioritized over advanced features.

README for form-data

Form-Data NPM Module Join the chat at https://gitter.im/form-data/form-data

A library to create readable "multipart/form-data" streams. Can be used to submit forms and file uploads to other web applications.

The API of this library is inspired by the XMLHttpRequest-2 FormData Interface.

Linux Build MacOS Build Windows Build

Coverage Status Dependency Status

Install

npm install --save form-data

Usage

In this example we are constructing a form with 3 fields that contain a string, a buffer and a file stream.

var FormData = require('form-data');
var fs = require('fs');

var form = new FormData();
form.append('my_field', 'my value');
form.append('my_buffer', new Buffer(10));
form.append('my_file', fs.createReadStream('/foo/bar.jpg'));

Also you can use http-response stream:

var FormData = require('form-data');
var http = require('http');

var form = new FormData();

http.request('http://nodejs.org/images/logo.png', function(response) {
  form.append('my_field', 'my value');
  form.append('my_buffer', new Buffer(10));
  form.append('my_logo', response);
});

Or @mikeal's request stream:

var FormData = require('form-data');
var request = require('request');

var form = new FormData();

form.append('my_field', 'my value');
form.append('my_buffer', new Buffer(10));
form.append('my_logo', request('http://nodejs.org/images/logo.png'));

In order to submit this form to a web application, call submit(url, [callback]) method:

form.submit('http://example.org/', function(err, res) {
  // res – response object (http.IncomingMessage)  //
  res.resume();
});

For more advanced request manipulations submit() method returns http.ClientRequest object, or you can choose from one of the alternative submission methods.

Custom options

You can provide custom options, such as maxDataSize:

var FormData = require('form-data');

var form = new FormData({ maxDataSize: 20971520 });
form.append('my_field', 'my value');
form.append('my_buffer', /* something big */);

List of available options could be found in combined-stream

Alternative submission methods

You can use node's http client interface:

var http = require('http');

var request = http.request({
  method: 'post',
  host: 'example.org',
  path: '/upload',
  headers: form.getHeaders()
});

form.pipe(request);

request.on('response', function(res) {
  console.log(res.statusCode);
});

Or if you would prefer the 'Content-Length' header to be set for you:

form.submit('example.org/upload', function(err, res) {
  console.log(res.statusCode);
});

To use custom headers and pre-known length in parts:

var CRLF = '\r\n';
var form = new FormData();

var options = {
  header: CRLF + '--' + form.getBoundary() + CRLF + 'X-Custom-Header: 123' + CRLF + CRLF,
  knownLength: 1
};

form.append('my_buffer', buffer, options);

form.submit('http://example.com/', function(err, res) {
  if (err) throw err;
  console.log('Done');
});

Form-Data can recognize and fetch all the required information from common types of streams (fs.readStream, http.response and mikeal's request), for some other types of streams you'd need to provide "file"-related information manually:

someModule.stream(function(err, stdout, stderr) {
  if (err) throw err;

  var form = new FormData();

  form.append('file', stdout, {
    filename: 'unicycle.jpg', // ... or:
    filepath: 'photos/toys/unicycle.jpg',
    contentType: 'image/jpeg',
    knownLength: 19806
  });

  form.submit('http://example.com/', function(err, res) {
    if (err) throw err;
    console.log('Done');
  });
});

The filepath property overrides filename and may contain a relative path. This is typically used when uploading multiple files from a directory.

For edge cases, like POST request to URL with query string or to pass HTTP auth credentials, object can be passed to form.submit() as first parameter:

form.submit({
  host: 'example.com',
  path: '/probably.php?extra=params',
  auth: 'username:password'
}, function(err, res) {
  console.log(res.statusCode);
});

In case you need to also send custom HTTP headers with the POST request, you can use the headers key in first parameter of form.submit():

form.submit({
  host: 'example.com',
  path: '/surelynot.php',
  headers: {'x-test-header': 'test-header-value'}
}, function(err, res) {
  console.log(res.statusCode);
});

Methods

Void append( String field, Mixed value [, Mixed options] )

Append data to the form. You can submit about any format (string, integer, boolean, buffer, etc.). However, Arrays are not supported and need to be turned into strings by the user.

var form = new FormData();
form.append( 'my_string', 'my value' );
form.append( 'my_integer', 1 );
form.append( 'my_boolean', true );
form.append( 'my_buffer', new Buffer(10) );
form.append( 'my_array_as_json', JSON.stringify( ['bird','cute'] ) )

You may provide a string for options, or an object.

// Set filename by providing a string for options
form.append( 'my_file', fs.createReadStream('/foo/bar.jpg'), 'bar.jpg' );

// provide an object.
form.append( 'my_file', fs.createReadStream('/foo/bar.jpg'), {filename: 'bar.jpg', contentType: 'image/jpeg', knownLength: 19806} );

Headers getHeaders( [Headers userHeaders] )

This method adds the correct content-type header to the provided array of userHeaders.

String getBoundary()

Return the boundary of the formData. By default, the boundary consists of 26 - followed by 24 numbers for example:

--------------------------515890814546601021194782

Void setBoundary(String boundary)

Set the boundary string, overriding the default behavior described above.

Note: The boundary must be unique and may not appear in the data.

Buffer getBuffer()

Return the full formdata request package, as a Buffer. You can insert this Buffer in e.g. Axios to send multipart data.

var form = new FormData();
form.append( 'my_buffer', Buffer.from([0x4a,0x42,0x20,0x52,0x6f,0x63,0x6b,0x73]) );
form.append( 'my_file', fs.readFileSync('/foo/bar.jpg') );

axios.post( 'https://example.com/path/to/api',
            form.getBuffer(),
            form.getHeaders()
          )

Note: Because the output is of type Buffer, you can only append types that are accepted by Buffer: string, Buffer, ArrayBuffer, Array, or Array-like Object. A ReadStream for example will result in an error.

Integer getLengthSync()

Same as getLength but synchronous.

Note: getLengthSync doesn't calculate streams length.

Integer getLength( function callback )

Returns the Content-Length async. The callback is used to handle errors and continue once the length has been calculated

this.getLength(function(err, length) {
  if (err) {
    this._error(err);
    return;
  }

  // add content length
  request.setHeader('Content-Length', length);

  ...
}.bind(this));

Boolean hasKnownLength()

Checks if the length of added values is known.

Request submit( params, function callback )

Submit the form to a web application.

var form = new FormData();
form.append( 'my_string', 'Hello World' );

form.submit( 'http://example.com/', function(err, res) {
  // res – response object (http.IncomingMessage)  //
  res.resume();
} );

String toString()

Returns the form data as a string. Don't use this if you are sending files or buffers, use getBuffer() instead.

Integration with other libraries

Request

Form submission using request:

var formData = {
  my_field: 'my_value',
  my_file: fs.createReadStream(__dirname + '/unicycle.jpg'),
};

request.post({url:'http://service.com/upload', formData: formData}, function(err, httpResponse, body) {
  if (err) {
    return console.error('upload failed:', err);
  }
  console.log('Upload successful!  Server responded with:', body);
});

For more details see request readme.

node-fetch

You can also submit a form using node-fetch:

var form = new FormData();

form.append('a', 1);

fetch('http://example.com', { method: 'POST', body: form })
    .then(function(res) {
        return res.json();
    }).then(function(json) {
        console.log(json);
    });

axios

In Node.js you can post a file using axios:

const form = new FormData();
const stream = fs.createReadStream(PATH_TO_FILE);

form.append('image', stream);

// In Node.js environment you need to set boundary in the header field 'Content-Type' by calling method `getHeaders`
const formHeaders = form.getHeaders();

axios.post('http://example.com', form, {
  headers: {
    ...formHeaders,
  },
})
.then(response => response)
.catch(error => error)

Notes

  • getLengthSync() method DOESN'T calculate length for streams, use knownLength options as workaround.
  • getLength(cb) will send an error as first parameter of callback if stream length cannot be calculated (e.g. send in custom streams w/o using knownLength).
  • submit will not add content-length if form length is unknown or not calculable.
  • Starting version 2.x FormData has dropped support for node@0.10.x.
  • Starting version 3.x FormData has dropped support for node@4.x.

License

Form-Data is released under the MIT license.