Which is Better CSS Minification Libraries?
csso vs clean-css vs cssnano vs postcss-clean
1 Year
cssoclean-csscssnanopostcss-cleanSimilar Packages:
What's CSS Minification Libraries?

CSS minification libraries are tools used in web development to reduce the size of CSS files by removing unnecessary characters, such as whitespace, comments, and formatting. This process improves load times and overall performance of web applications by decreasing the amount of data that needs to be transferred over the network. Each of these libraries offers unique features and optimizations, catering to different use cases and preferences in the development workflow.

NPM Package Downloads Trend
Github Stars Ranking
Stat Detail
Package
Downloads
Stars
Size
Issues
Publish
License
csso14,661,4273,752606 kB98-MIT
clean-css14,481,6064,162493 kB3110 months agoMIT
cssnano10,699,1394,7647.33 kB95a month agoMIT
postcss-clean12,49241-124 years agoMIT
Feature Comparison: csso vs clean-css vs cssnano vs postcss-clean

Optimization Techniques

  • csso: csso focuses on restructuring CSS to achieve maximum compression. It analyzes the CSS structure and applies techniques like merging adjacent rules, removing redundant properties, and optimizing selector specificity to minimize file size effectively.
  • clean-css: clean-css employs a variety of optimization techniques, including merging rules, removing duplicate selectors, and optimizing CSS properties. It allows for advanced configuration options to customize the minification process, making it suitable for complex stylesheets.
  • cssnano: cssnano uses a series of PostCSS plugins to apply optimizations such as removing unused CSS, merging media queries, and optimizing background images. Its modular approach allows developers to enable or disable specific optimizations based on project needs.
  • postcss-clean: postcss-clean provides a straightforward approach to CSS minification by removing whitespace, comments, and unnecessary characters. It is less aggressive than other tools but integrates well with other PostCSS plugins for a streamlined workflow.

Integration

  • csso: csso can be integrated into build processes using tools like Gulp, Grunt, or Webpack. It provides a command-line interface as well as an API, making it versatile for different project setups and automation workflows.
  • clean-css: clean-css can be used as a standalone tool or integrated into build systems like Gulp and Webpack. Its flexibility allows developers to easily incorporate it into various workflows without significant changes to their existing setup.
  • cssnano: cssnano is designed to work seamlessly with PostCSS, making it an excellent choice for projects that already utilize PostCSS for processing CSS. It can be easily configured within a PostCSS setup, allowing for a cohesive development experience.
  • postcss-clean: postcss-clean is a PostCSS plugin, which means it integrates directly into any PostCSS pipeline. This makes it easy to use alongside other PostCSS plugins, allowing for a flexible and modular approach to CSS processing.

Performance

  • csso: csso excels in performance due to its focus on restructuring CSS for optimal size reduction. It can significantly reduce file sizes while maintaining the integrity of the styles, making it a strong choice for performance-focused projects.
  • clean-css: clean-css is known for its speed and efficiency, providing fast minification even for large CSS files. Its performance is enhanced by the ability to customize the minification process, allowing developers to balance speed and optimization based on project requirements.
  • cssnano: cssnano's performance is largely dependent on the PostCSS ecosystem. While it offers a wide range of optimizations, the overall speed can vary based on the number of plugins used in conjunction with cssnano. However, it is generally efficient for most workflows.
  • postcss-clean: postcss-clean is lightweight and performs well for basic minification tasks. While it may not offer the advanced optimizations of other tools, its simplicity ensures quick processing times, especially for smaller stylesheets.

Ease of Use

  • csso: csso is designed to be easy to use, with a simple API and command-line options. Its focus on restructuring CSS may require some understanding of CSS properties, but overall, it is approachable for developers looking to optimize their stylesheets.
  • clean-css: clean-css provides a straightforward API and command-line interface, making it easy to use for developers of all skill levels. Its extensive documentation and configuration options allow for both novice and experienced users to effectively utilize its features.
  • cssnano: cssnano's integration with PostCSS makes it user-friendly for those familiar with the PostCSS ecosystem. Its configuration is simple, and it provides a clear way to manage optimizations, making it accessible for developers.
  • postcss-clean: postcss-clean is very easy to implement within a PostCSS setup, requiring minimal configuration. Its simplicity makes it a great choice for developers looking for a no-fuss minification solution.

Community and Support

  • csso: csso has a dedicated user base and is regularly updated, providing users with ongoing support and improvements. Its documentation is clear, helping developers understand how to leverage its features effectively.
  • clean-css: clean-css has a strong community and is actively maintained, ensuring that users have access to support and updates. Its popularity in the industry means that many resources and examples are available for developers to learn from.
  • cssnano: cssnano benefits from being part of the PostCSS ecosystem, which has a vibrant community. This ensures that users can find plenty of support, plugins, and documentation to assist with their development needs.
  • postcss-clean: postcss-clean, being a part of the PostCSS ecosystem, enjoys community support and regular updates. Its integration with other PostCSS plugins means that users can find a wealth of resources and examples to guide their usage.
How to Choose: csso vs clean-css vs cssnano vs postcss-clean
  • csso: Opt for csso if you are looking for a minifier that emphasizes restructuring CSS for better performance. It is suitable for projects where the focus is on achieving the smallest possible file size through advanced optimization techniques, including merging and restructuring rules.
  • clean-css: Choose clean-css if you need a fast and efficient minification tool that offers a wide range of optimization options. It is particularly useful for projects where you want granular control over the minification process and the ability to customize the output.
  • cssnano: Select cssnano if you are using PostCSS in your workflow and want a comprehensive solution that integrates seamlessly with other PostCSS plugins. It is ideal for projects that require a modular approach to CSS processing and want to leverage the power of PostCSS's ecosystem.
  • postcss-clean: Consider postcss-clean if you are already using PostCSS and need a simple, straightforward minification solution. It is best for projects that prioritize ease of use and integration with existing PostCSS setups without additional complexity.
README for csso

NPM version Build Status Coverage Status NPM Downloads Twitter

CSSO (CSS Optimizer) is a CSS minifier. It performs three sort of transformations: cleaning (removing redundants), compression (replacement for the shorter forms) and restructuring (merge of declarations, rules and so on). As a result an output CSS becomes much smaller in size.

Install

npm install csso

Usage

import { minify } from 'csso';
// CommonJS is also supported
// const { minify } = require('csso');

const minifiedCss = minify('.test { color: #ff0000; }').css;

console.log(minifiedCss);
// .test{color:red}

Bundles are also available for use in a browser:

  • dist/csso.js – minified IIFE with csso as global
<script src="node_modules/csso/dist/csso.js"></script>
<script>
  csso.minify('.example { color: green }');
</script>
  • dist/csso.esm.js – minified ES module
<script type="module">
  import { minify } from 'node_modules/csso/dist/csso.esm.js'

  minify('.example { color: green }');
</script>

One of CDN services like unpkg or jsDelivr can be used. By default (for short path) a ESM version is exposing. For IIFE version a full path to a bundle should be specified:

<!-- ESM -->
<script type="module">
  import * as csstree from 'https://cdn.jsdelivr.net/npm/csso';
  import * as csstree from 'https://unpkg.com/csso';
</script>

<!-- IIFE with an export to global -->
<script src="https://cdn.jsdelivr.net/npm/csso/dist/csso.js"></script>
<script src="https://unpkg.com/csso/dist/csso.js"></script>

CSSO is based on CSSTree to parse CSS into AST, AST traversal and to generate AST back to CSS. All CSSTree API is available behind syntax field extended with compress() method. You may minify CSS step by step:

import { syntax } from 'csso';

const ast = syntax.parse('.test { color: #ff0000; }');
const compressedAst = syntax.compress(ast).ast;
const minifiedCss = syntax.generate(compressedAst);

console.log(minifiedCss);
// .test{color:red}

Also syntax can be imported using csso/syntax entry point:

import { parse, compress, generate } from 'csso/syntax';

const ast = parse('.test { color: #ff0000; }');
const compressedAst = compress(ast).ast;
const minifiedCss = generate(compressedAst);

console.log(minifiedCss);
// .test{color:red}

Warning: CSSO doesn't guarantee API behind a syntax field as well as AST format. Both might be changed with changes in CSSTree. If you rely heavily on syntax API, a better option might be to use CSSTree directly.

Related projects

API

minify(source[, options])

Minify source CSS passed as String.

const result = csso.minify('.test { color: #ff0000; }', {
    restructure: false,   // don't change CSS structure, i.e. don't merge declarations, rulesets etc
    debug: true           // show additional debug information:
                          // true or number from 1 to 3 (greater number - more details)
});

console.log(result.css);
// > .test{color:red}

Returns an object with properties:

Options:

  • sourceMap

    Type: Boolean
    Default: false

    Generate a source map when true.

  • filename

    Type: String
    Default: '<unknown>'

    Filename of input CSS, uses for source map generation.

  • debug

    Type: Boolean
    Default: false

    Output debug information to stderr.

  • beforeCompress

    Type: function(ast, options) or Array<function(ast, options)> or null
    Default: null

    Called right after parse is run.

  • afterCompress

    Type: function(compressResult, options) or Array<function(compressResult, options)> or null
    Default: null

    Called right after syntax.compress() is run.

  • Other options are the same as for syntax.compress() function.

minifyBlock(source[, options])

The same as minify() but for list of declarations. Usually it's a style attribute value.

const result = csso.minifyBlock('color: rgba(255, 0, 0, 1); color: #ff0000');

console.log(result.css);
// > color:red

syntax.compress(ast[, options])

Does the main task – compress an AST. This is CSSO's extension in CSSTree syntax API.

NOTE: syntax.compress() performs AST compression by transforming input AST by default (since AST cloning is expensive and needed in rare cases). Use clone option with truthy value in case you want to keep input AST untouched.

Returns an object with properties:

  • ast Object – resulting AST

Options:

  • restructure

    Type: Boolean
    Default: true

    Disable or enable a structure optimisations.

  • forceMediaMerge

    Type: Boolean
    Default: false

    Enables merging of @media rules with the same media query by splitted by other rules. The optimisation is unsafe in general, but should work fine in most cases. Use it on your own risk.

  • clone

    Type: Boolean
    Default: false

    Transform a copy of input AST if true. Useful in case of AST reuse.

  • comments

    Type: String or Boolean
    Default: true

    Specify what comments to leave:

    • 'exclamation' or true – leave all exclamation comments (i.e. /*! .. */)
    • 'first-exclamation' – remove every comment except first one
    • false – remove all comments
  • usage

    Type: Object or null
    Default: null

    Usage data for advanced optimisations (see Usage data for details)

  • logger

    Type: Function or null
    Default: null

    Function to track every step of transformation.

Source maps

To get a source map set true for sourceMap option. Additianaly filename option can be passed to specify source file. When sourceMap option is true, map field of result object will contain a SourceMapGenerator instance. This object can be mixed with another source map or translated to string.

const csso = require('csso');
const css = fs.readFileSync('path/to/my.css', 'utf8');
const result = csso.minify(css, {
  filename: 'path/to/my.css', // will be added to source map as reference to source file
  sourceMap: true             // generate source map
});

console.log(result);
// { css: '...minified...', map: SourceMapGenerator {} }

console.log(result.map.toString());
// '{ .. source map content .. }'

Example of generating source map with respect of source map from input CSS:

import { SourceMapConsumer } from 'source-map';
import * as csso from 'csso';

const inputFile = 'path/to/my.css';
const input = fs.readFileSync(inputFile, 'utf8');
const inputMap = input.match(/\/\*# sourceMappingURL=(\S+)\s*\*\/\s*$/);
const output = csso.minify(input, {
  filename: inputFile,
  sourceMap: true
});

// apply input source map to output
if (inputMap) {
  output.map.applySourceMap(
    new SourceMapConsumer(inputMap[1]),
    inputFile
  )
}

// result CSS with source map
console.log(
  output.css +
  '/*# sourceMappingURL=data:application/json;base64,' +
  Buffer.from(output.map.toString()).toString('base64') +
  ' */'
);

Usage data

CSSO can use data about how CSS is used in a markup for better compression. File with this data (JSON) can be set using usage option. Usage data may contain following sections:

  • blacklist – a set of black lists (see Black list filtering)
  • tags – white list of tags
  • ids – white list of ids
  • classes – white list of classes
  • scopes – groups of classes which never used with classes from other groups on the same element

All sections are optional. Value of tags, ids and classes should be an array of a string, value of scopes should be an array of arrays of strings. Other values are ignoring.

White list filtering

tags, ids and classes are using on clean stage to filter selectors that contain something not in the lists. Selectors are filtering only by those kind of simple selector which white list is specified. For example, if only tags list is specified then type selectors are checking, and if all type selectors in selector present in list or selector has no any type selector it isn't filter.

ids and classes are case sensitive, tags – is not.

Input CSS:

* { color: green; }
ul, ol, li { color: blue; }
UL.foo, span.bar { color: red; }

Usage data:

{
    "tags": ["ul", "LI"]
}

Resulting CSS:

*{color:green}ul,li{color:blue}ul.foo{color:red}

Filtering performs for nested selectors too. :not() pseudos content is ignoring since the result of matching is unpredictable. Example for the same usage data as above:

:nth-child(2n of ul, ol) { color: red }
:nth-child(3n + 1 of img) { color: yellow }
:not(div, ol, ul) { color: green }
:has(:matches(ul, ol), ul, ol) { color: blue }

Turns into:

:nth-child(2n of ul){color:red}:not(div,ol,ul){color:green}:has(:matches(ul),ul){color:blue}

Black list filtering

Black list filtering performs the same as white list filtering, but filters things that mentioned in the lists. blacklist can contain the lists tags, ids and classes.

Black list has a higher priority, so when something mentioned in the white list and in the black list then white list occurrence is ignoring. The :not() pseudos content ignoring as well.

* { color: green; }
ul, ol, li { color: blue; }
UL.foo, li.bar { color: red; }

Usage data:

{
    "blacklist": {
        "tags": ["ul"]
    },
    "tags": ["ul", "LI"]
}

Resulting CSS:

*{color:green}li{color:blue}li.bar{color:red}

Scopes

Scopes is designed for CSS scope isolation solutions such as css-modules. Scopes are similar to namespaces and define lists of class names that exclusively used on some markup. This information allows the optimizer to move rules more agressive. Since it assumes selectors from different scopes don't match for the same element. This can improve rule merging.

Suppose we have a file:

.module1-foo { color: red; }
.module1-bar { font-size: 1.5em; background: yellow; }

.module2-baz { color: red; }
.module2-qux { font-size: 1.5em; background: yellow; width: 50px; }

It can be assumed that first two rules are never used with the second two on the same markup. But we can't say that for sure without a markup review. The optimizer doesn't know it either and will perform safe transformations only. The result will be the same as input but with no spaces and some semicolons:

.module1-foo{color:red}.module1-bar{font-size:1.5em;background:#ff0}.module2-baz{color:red}.module2-qux{font-size:1.5em;background:#ff0;width:50px}

With usage data CSSO can produce better output. If follow usage data is provided:

{
    "scopes": [
        ["module1-foo", "module1-bar"],
        ["module2-baz", "module2-qux"]
    ]
}

The result will be (29 bytes extra saving):

.module1-foo,.module2-baz{color:red}.module1-bar,.module2-qux{font-size:1.5em;background:#ff0}.module2-qux{width:50px}

If class name isn't mentioned in the scopes it belongs to default scope. scopes data doesn't affect classes whitelist. If class name mentioned in scopes but missed in classes (both sections are specified) it will be filtered.

Note that class name can't be set for several scopes. Also a selector can't have class names from different scopes. In both cases an exception will thrown.

Currently the optimizer doesn't care about changing order safety for out-of-bounds selectors (i.e. selectors that match to elements without class name, e.g. .scope div or .scope ~ :last-child). It assumes that scoped CSS modules doesn't relay on it's order. It may be fix in future if to be an issue.