natural-compare vs compare-versions vs string-natural-compare vs natural-orderby
Version Comparison and Sorting Libraries Comparison
1 Year
natural-comparecompare-versionsstring-natural-comparenatural-orderbySimilar Packages:
What's Version Comparison and Sorting Libraries?

These libraries provide functionalities for comparing and sorting strings, particularly useful for version numbers and natural language sorting. They help developers manage and manipulate version strings or lists of items in a way that respects natural ordering, making it easier to handle user inputs and data in applications where versioning or natural sorting is critical.

Package Weekly Downloads Trend
Github Stars Ranking
Stat Detail
Package
Downloads
Stars
Size
Issues
Publish
License
natural-compare41,301,744110-09 years agoMIT
compare-versions5,563,81161355.5 kB58 months agoMIT
string-natural-compare4,426,72849-15 years agoMIT
natural-orderby1,822,6055872.5 kB164 months agoMIT
Feature Comparison: natural-compare vs compare-versions vs string-natural-compare vs natural-orderby

Comparison Methodology

  • natural-compare:

    natural-compare implements a natural sorting algorithm that compares strings in a way that aligns with human intuition. It treats numeric substrings as integers, allowing for correct ordering of strings like 'file2', 'file10', and 'file1'.

  • compare-versions:

    compare-versions uses a strict semantic versioning approach, allowing for accurate comparisons of version strings formatted as 'major.minor.patch'. It handles edge cases like pre-release versions and build metadata, ensuring precise results for versioning tasks.

  • string-natural-compare:

    string-natural-compare provides a simple comparison function that respects natural ordering principles. It is designed for quick comparisons without the overhead of sorting, making it efficient for scenarios where only pairwise comparisons are needed.

  • natural-orderby:

    natural-orderby builds on the principles of natural-compare but focuses on sorting arrays. It allows developers to specify sort keys and provides a more flexible API for sorting complex data structures, enhancing usability in data manipulation tasks.

Performance

  • natural-compare:

    natural-compare is efficient for sorting and comparing strings, but performance may vary with larger datasets. It is designed for general use and balances performance with the complexity of the comparison logic.

  • compare-versions:

    This library is optimized for performance in version comparison scenarios, making it suitable for applications that frequently check or validate version strings. Its lightweight nature ensures minimal impact on application performance.

  • string-natural-compare:

    string-natural-compare is lightweight and fast, making it ideal for applications that require quick comparisons without the need for sorting. Its performance is consistent across various string lengths.

  • natural-orderby:

    natural-orderby is optimized for sorting large arrays, leveraging the natural-compare algorithm to ensure efficient sorting. It is suitable for applications that require frequent sorting of data collections.

Use Cases

  • natural-compare:

    Best suited for applications that display lists of items to users, such as file explorers or search results, where natural ordering enhances readability and usability.

  • compare-versions:

    Ideal for applications that manage software versions, such as package managers or version control systems, where precise version comparison is crucial for functionality and user experience.

  • string-natural-compare:

    Useful in scenarios where quick comparisons are needed, such as validating user inputs or filtering options in forms, where performance and simplicity are key.

  • natural-orderby:

    Perfect for data-heavy applications that require sorting of complex datasets, such as e-commerce platforms or content management systems, where user experience relies on intuitive data presentation.

Extensibility

  • natural-compare:

    natural-compare can be extended for custom comparison logic, allowing developers to modify its behavior for specific use cases, enhancing its flexibility in various applications.

  • compare-versions:

    This library is focused and does not offer extensibility features, as it is designed specifically for version comparison without additional functionalities.

  • string-natural-compare:

    string-natural-compare is straightforward and does not offer extensibility options, focusing solely on natural string comparison.

  • natural-orderby:

    natural-orderby provides options for custom sorting functions, enabling developers to tailor the sorting behavior to fit specific requirements, making it highly extensible for complex data scenarios.

Learning Curve

  • natural-compare:

    natural-compare is user-friendly, with clear documentation that allows developers to understand and implement natural string comparisons with minimal effort.

  • compare-versions:

    The library has a low learning curve, making it easy for developers to implement version comparisons quickly without extensive documentation or setup.

  • string-natural-compare:

    This package is very easy to learn and implement, making it suitable for developers at all levels who need quick and efficient string comparisons.

  • natural-orderby:

    natural-orderby may require a bit more understanding due to its sorting capabilities, but it is still accessible for developers familiar with JavaScript array methods.

How to Choose: natural-compare vs compare-versions vs string-natural-compare vs natural-orderby
  • natural-compare:

    Select natural-compare for a more general-purpose string comparison that respects natural ordering. This package is particularly useful when sorting strings that contain numbers, as it compares them in a way that humans would expect, making it suitable for user-facing applications where readability is important.

  • compare-versions:

    Choose compare-versions if you need a straightforward solution specifically for comparing semantic version strings. It is lightweight and focused solely on version comparison, making it ideal for applications that require precise version checks without additional overhead.

  • string-natural-compare:

    Use string-natural-compare if you require a simple and efficient way to compare strings in a natural order without the need for additional sorting capabilities. This package is lightweight and easy to integrate, making it suitable for quick comparisons in various contexts.

  • natural-orderby:

    Opt for natural-orderby when you need to sort arrays of strings or objects based on a natural order. This package extends natural-compare by providing a more comprehensive sorting mechanism, allowing for complex sorting scenarios, which is beneficial in data-heavy applications.

README for natural-compare
@version    1.4.0
@date       2015-10-26
@stability  3 - Stable

Natural Compare – Build Coverage

Compare strings containing a mix of letters and numbers in the way a human being would in sort order. This is described as a "natural ordering".

Standard sorting:   Natural order sorting:
    img1.png            img1.png
    img10.png           img2.png
    img12.png           img10.png
    img2.png            img12.png

String.naturalCompare returns a number indicating whether a reference string comes before or after or is the same as the given string in sort order. Use it with builtin sort() function.

Installation

  • In browser
<script src=min.natural-compare.js></script>
  • In node.js: npm install natural-compare-lite
require("natural-compare-lite")

Usage

// Simple case sensitive example
var a = ["z1.doc", "z10.doc", "z17.doc", "z2.doc", "z23.doc", "z3.doc"];
a.sort(String.naturalCompare);
// ["z1.doc", "z2.doc", "z3.doc", "z10.doc", "z17.doc", "z23.doc"]

// Use wrapper function for case insensitivity
a.sort(function(a, b){
  return String.naturalCompare(a.toLowerCase(), b.toLowerCase());
})

// In most cases we want to sort an array of objects
var a = [ {"street":"350 5th Ave", "room":"A-1021"}
        , {"street":"350 5th Ave", "room":"A-21046-b"} ];

// sort by street, then by room
a.sort(function(a, b){
  return String.naturalCompare(a.street, b.street) || String.naturalCompare(a.room, b.room);
})

// When text transformation is needed (eg toLowerCase()),
// it is best for performance to keep
// transformed key in that object.
// There are no need to do text transformation
// on each comparision when sorting.
var a = [ {"make":"Audi", "model":"A6"}
        , {"make":"Kia",  "model":"Rio"} ];

// sort by make, then by model
a.map(function(car){
  car.sort_key = (car.make + " " + car.model).toLowerCase();
})
a.sort(function(a, b){
  return String.naturalCompare(a.sort_key, b.sort_key);
})
  • Works well with dates in ISO format eg "Rev 2012-07-26.doc".

Custom alphabet

It is possible to configure a custom alphabet to achieve a desired order.

// Estonian alphabet
String.alphabet = "ABDEFGHIJKLMNOPRSŠZŽTUVÕÄÖÜXYabdefghijklmnoprsšzžtuvõäöüxy"
["t", "z", "x", "õ"].sort(String.naturalCompare)
// ["z", "t", "õ", "x"]

// Russian alphabet
String.alphabet = "АБВГДЕЁЖЗИЙКЛМНОПРСТУФХЦЧШЩЪЫЬЭЮЯабвгдеёжзийклмнопрстуфхцчшщъыьэюя"
["Ё", "А", "Б"].sort(String.naturalCompare)
// ["А", "Б", "Ё"]

External links

  • [GitHub repo][https://github.com/litejs/natural-compare-lite]
  • jsperf test

Licence

Copyright (c) 2012-2015 Lauri Rooden <lauri@rooden.ee>
The MIT License