yeoman-generator vs plop vs hygen vs create-react-app vs scaffdog vs sapper
Web Development Scaffolding Tools Comparison
1 Year
yeoman-generatorplophygencreate-react-appscaffdogsapperSimilar Packages:
What's Web Development Scaffolding Tools?

Scaffolding tools in web development help automate the setup and generation of project structures, components, and templates, allowing developers to focus on writing code rather than configuring their environments. These tools streamline the development process by providing reusable templates and reducing boilerplate code, which enhances productivity and consistency across projects. Each tool has its unique features and use cases, catering to different aspects of the development workflow.

Package Weekly Downloads Trend
Github Stars Ranking
Stat Detail
Package
Downloads
Stars
Size
Issues
Publish
License
yeoman-generator1,013,1741,231138 kB53 months agoBSD-2-Clause
plop796,2357,30286.4 kB75a year agoMIT
hygen252,4655,742137 kB103-MIT
create-react-app215,199103,11639.3 kB2,29518 days agoMIT
scaffdog51,83172260.3 kB316 months agoMIT
sapper37,3096,982536 kB259-MIT
Feature Comparison: yeoman-generator vs plop vs hygen vs create-react-app vs scaffdog vs sapper

Customization

  • yeoman-generator:

    Yeoman Generator supports extensive customization through its generator ecosystem, allowing developers to create complex scaffolding solutions. It's particularly useful for larger projects that require a high degree of flexibility.

  • plop:

    Plop offers a straightforward way to customize templates and prompts, making it easy to generate files with specific configurations. It's designed for simplicity, allowing developers to quickly adapt templates as needed.

  • hygen:

    Hygen excels in customization, allowing developers to create their own templates and generators tailored to specific needs. This flexibility is ideal for teams that want to enforce coding standards and reuse components across projects.

  • create-react-app:

    Create React App provides limited customization options out of the box, focusing on convention over configuration. However, you can eject the configuration if you need more control, but this comes with the cost of losing the simplicity of the tool.

  • scaffdog:

    Scaffdog allows for interactive customization through prompts, enabling users to tailor the scaffolding process to their needs. This makes it user-friendly for those who want to guide their setup process interactively.

  • sapper:

    Sapper is less about customization and more about providing a complete framework for Svelte applications. While it offers some configuration options, it's primarily focused on delivering a cohesive development experience with built-in features.

Learning Curve

  • yeoman-generator:

    Yeoman Generator can have a steep learning curve due to its extensive features and the need to understand its generator architecture. However, it provides comprehensive documentation to aid learning.

  • plop:

    Plop is easy to learn, especially for developers familiar with templating. Its straightforward syntax and minimal setup make it accessible for quick adoption.

  • hygen:

    Hygen has a moderate learning curve, especially for those unfamiliar with code generation concepts. However, once understood, it becomes a powerful tool for maintaining consistency in codebases.

  • create-react-app:

    Create React App has a gentle learning curve, making it accessible for beginners who want to start building React applications quickly without deep knowledge of build tools.

  • scaffdog:

    Scaffdog is user-friendly and designed to be intuitive, making it easy for developers to create interactive templates without extensive setup or configuration.

  • sapper:

    Sapper has a steeper learning curve due to its integration with Svelte and the concepts of server-side rendering and routing. Developers may need to familiarize themselves with Svelte first.

Community Support

  • yeoman-generator:

    Yeoman Generator has a large and active community, with many generators available for various frameworks and libraries. This extensive ecosystem provides a wealth of resources and support.

  • plop:

    Plop has a supportive community with a decent amount of resources available, including documentation and examples to help new users get started.

  • hygen:

    Hygen has a growing community, though smaller than some other tools. It has good documentation and examples, but fewer resources compared to more established tools.

  • create-react-app:

    Create React App benefits from strong community support, being one of the most popular tools for React development. There are numerous resources, tutorials, and community contributions available.

  • scaffdog:

    Scaffdog is relatively new and has a smaller community. However, it has good documentation and is gaining traction among developers looking for interactive scaffolding solutions.

  • sapper:

    Sapper is backed by the Svelte community, which is rapidly growing. While resources are increasing, they may not be as abundant as those for more established frameworks like React or Angular.

Integration

  • yeoman-generator:

    Yeoman Generator supports a wide range of frameworks and libraries, making it a flexible choice for any project. Its extensive generator ecosystem allows for easy integration into various workflows.

  • plop:

    Plop is framework-agnostic and can be used in any JavaScript project. Its simplicity allows for easy integration into existing workflows without significant overhead.

  • hygen:

    Hygen can be integrated into any project, regardless of the framework, making it versatile for various development environments. It works well with existing codebases and enhances productivity.

  • create-react-app:

    Create React App integrates seamlessly with React and provides a solid foundation for building single-page applications. It abstracts away complex configurations, allowing developers to focus on coding.

  • scaffdog:

    Scaffdog can be integrated into existing projects to enhance the scaffolding process with interactive templates. It works well alongside other tools and frameworks.

  • sapper:

    Sapper is specifically designed for Svelte applications, providing built-in features like routing and server-side rendering. It integrates tightly with Svelte, making it a natural choice for Svelte developers.

Performance

  • yeoman-generator:

    Yeoman Generator is designed to be efficient, but the performance can vary based on the complexity of the generators used. Overall, it aims to minimize overhead while providing powerful scaffolding capabilities.

  • plop:

    Plop is also lightweight and designed for speed, enabling rapid file generation without affecting the overall performance of the project.

  • hygen:

    Hygen is lightweight and does not significantly impact project performance. It generates code quickly, allowing developers to maintain high productivity without overhead.

  • create-react-app:

    Create React App is optimized for performance out of the box, utilizing modern JavaScript features and build optimizations to ensure fast loading times and efficient development.

  • scaffdog:

    Scaffdog's performance is efficient for generating templates, but the impact on overall project performance is minimal as it primarily focuses on scaffolding.

  • sapper:

    Sapper provides excellent performance with server-side rendering, reducing load times and improving SEO. It is optimized for building fast applications with Svelte.

How to Choose: yeoman-generator vs plop vs hygen vs create-react-app vs scaffdog vs sapper
  • yeoman-generator:

    Select Yeoman Generator if you need a robust scaffolding tool that supports a wide range of generators for various frameworks and libraries. It's ideal for larger projects where you want to leverage community-generated templates and maintain a consistent project structure.

  • plop:

    Opt for Plop if you want a simple and lightweight solution for generating files and components based on predefined templates. It's suitable for projects where you need to create repetitive structures without the overhead of a full scaffolding tool.

  • hygen:

    Select Hygen if you need a highly customizable code generator that allows you to define your own templates and scripts. It's best for teams looking to enforce coding standards and maintain consistency across their codebase through custom scaffolding.

  • create-react-app:

    Choose Create React App if you want a quick setup for a new React project without having to configure build tools. It's ideal for beginners and small to medium-sized applications where you want to get started quickly with a standard configuration.

  • scaffdog:

    Choose Scaffdog if you want a tool that allows you to create project scaffolding with a focus on interactive templates. It's useful for projects where you want to guide users through the setup process with prompts and options.

  • sapper:

    Use Sapper if you're building a Svelte application and need a framework that offers server-side rendering and routing out of the box. It's perfect for developers looking for a full-featured solution that integrates seamlessly with Svelte.

README for yeoman-generator

Generator npm Build Status Coverage Status Gitter

Rails-inspired generator system that provides scaffolding for your apps

Getting Started

If you're interested in writing your own Yeoman generator we recommend reading the official getting started guide. The guide covers all the basics you need to get started.

A generator can be as complex as you want it to be. It can simply copy a bunch of boilerplate files, or it can be more advanced asking the user's preferences to scaffold a tailor made project. This decision is up to you.

The fastest way to get started is to use generator-generator, a Yeoman generator to generate a Yeoman generator.

After reading the getting started guide, you might want to read the code source or visit our API documentation for a list of all methods available.

API documentation for v4.x.

Debugging

See the debugging guide.

Contributing

We love contributors! See our contribution guideline to get started.

Sponsors

Love Yeoman work and community? Help us keep it alive by donating funds to cover project expenses!
[Become a sponsor]

License

BSD license Copyright (c) Google