import-fresh vs esm vs requirejs
JavaScript Module Loaders Comparison
Search packages..
1 Year
import-freshesmrequirejs
What's JavaScript Module Loaders?

JavaScript module loaders are tools that facilitate the loading and management of JavaScript modules in a web application. They allow developers to use modular programming techniques, enabling better organization, reusability, and maintainability of code. Each of these packages serves a unique purpose in the ecosystem of module loading, catering to different needs and scenarios in web development.

Package Weekly Downloads Trend
Github Stars Ranking
Stat Detail
Package
Downloads
Stars
Size
Issues
Publish
License
import-fresh61,560,6642844.69 kB82 months agoMIT
esm3,386,4945,269-866 years agoMIT
requirejs1,651,0442,5711.28 MB1429 months agoMIT
Feature Comparison: import-fresh vs esm vs requirejs

Module Syntax Support

  • import-fresh:

    'import-fresh' does not alter the module syntax but focuses on dynamically importing modules. It works with any module format, including CommonJS and ES modules, but is specifically designed to ensure the latest version of a module is loaded each time it is imported.

  • esm:

    The 'esm' package allows you to use the native ES module syntax in Node.js, enabling 'import' and 'export' statements. This aligns with the modern JavaScript standard and facilitates a cleaner, more intuitive way to manage dependencies compared to CommonJS.

  • requirejs:

    'requirejs' supports AMD module syntax, which is designed for asynchronous loading of JavaScript modules. This allows developers to define modules and their dependencies in a way that optimizes loading times and improves performance in web applications.

Dynamic Loading

  • import-fresh:

    'import-fresh' excels in dynamic loading by ensuring that the latest version of a module is fetched every time it is imported. This is particularly useful in development environments where modules may change frequently, allowing for instant updates without needing to restart the application.

  • esm:

    While 'esm' supports dynamic imports using the 'import()' function, its primary focus is on static module loading. It does not provide additional dynamic loading features beyond what ES modules offer natively.

  • requirejs:

    'requirejs' is built around the concept of asynchronous loading, allowing developers to load modules dynamically based on dependencies. This can significantly improve application performance by loading only the necessary modules when required.

Use Case Scenarios

  • import-fresh:

    Ideal for development tools and environments where modules are frequently updated. It is particularly useful for hot-reloading scenarios in development servers, ensuring that changes are reflected immediately without manual intervention.

  • esm:

    Best suited for modern JavaScript applications that require compatibility with both Node.js and browsers. It is ideal for projects that leverage ES6 features and aim for a consistent module system across environments.

  • requirejs:

    Most beneficial for legacy projects that utilize AMD style modules or when building applications that need to load scripts asynchronously in a browser. It is a good choice for projects that require fine-grained control over module loading.

Performance

  • import-fresh:

    While 'import-fresh' may introduce some overhead due to its dynamic loading nature, it ensures that the latest code is always executed, which can be more beneficial in development scenarios than in production performance.

  • esm:

    Using 'esm' can lead to improved performance in Node.js applications by allowing for tree-shaking and dead code elimination during the build process, as ES modules are statically analyzable.

  • requirejs:

    'requirejs' optimizes loading times by allowing asynchronous module loading, which can enhance performance in web applications by reducing initial load times and improving resource management.

Community and Ecosystem

  • import-fresh:

    Although 'import-fresh' is more niche, it is appreciated in specific development contexts, particularly among developers who prioritize hot-reloading and dynamic module management.

  • esm:

    The 'esm' package is widely adopted in the modern JavaScript community, aligning with the direction of the JavaScript language itself. It benefits from a growing ecosystem of tools and libraries that support ES modules.

  • requirejs:

    'requirejs' has a long-standing presence in the JavaScript community, especially in projects that have historically used AMD. It has a stable user base but may not be as actively developed as newer solutions.

How to Choose: import-fresh vs esm vs requirejs
  • import-fresh:

    Select 'import-fresh' when you need to import modules dynamically and ensure that you always get the latest version of the module, especially useful in development scenarios where modules may change frequently. It is particularly beneficial for hot-reloading in development tools.

  • esm:

    Choose 'esm' if you want to enable ES module syntax in Node.js environments, allowing you to use modern JavaScript features like 'import' and 'export' seamlessly. It's ideal for projects that aim for compatibility with both Node.js and browser environments.

  • requirejs:

    Opt for 'requirejs' if you are working with AMD (Asynchronous Module Definition) style modules and need a robust solution for managing dependencies in a browser environment. It is suitable for legacy projects or when you want to load scripts asynchronously.

Similar Npm Packages to esm

esm is a package that enables ECMAScript module (ESM) support in Node.js applications. It allows developers to use the modern JavaScript module syntax (import and export) in environments that may not fully support it natively. This is particularly useful for projects that aim to leverage the latest JavaScript features while maintaining compatibility with older versions of Node.js. By using esm, developers can write cleaner and more modular code, making it easier to manage dependencies and improve overall code organization.

While esm provides a robust solution for module loading, there are alternatives that cater to different use cases:

  • import-fresh is a utility that allows you to import a module fresh, bypassing the Node.js module cache. This can be particularly useful in testing scenarios where you want to ensure that you are working with the latest version of a module, especially if it has been modified during runtime. import-fresh is lightweight and straightforward, making it a great choice for developers who need to refresh module imports without the overhead of a complete module system.
  • requirejs is a JavaScript file and module loader that implements the Asynchronous Module Definition (AMD) API. It is designed to load modules asynchronously, which can improve performance in web applications by reducing the initial load time. While requirejs is primarily used in browser environments, it can also be utilized in Node.js applications. If you are working on a project that requires asynchronous module loading and you prefer the AMD pattern, requirejs is a solid alternative to consider.

To see how esm compares with import-fresh and requirejs, check out the comparison: Comparing esm vs import-fresh vs requirejs.

README for import-fresh

import-fresh

Import a module while bypassing the cache

Useful for testing purposes when you need to freshly import a module.

ESM

For ESM, you can use this snippet:

const importFresh = moduleName => import(`${moduleName}?${Date.now()}`);

const {default: foo} = await importFresh('foo');

This snippet causes a memory leak, so only use it for short-lived tests.

Install

npm install import-fresh

Usage

// foo.js
let i = 0;
module.exports = () => ++i;

const importFresh = require('import-fresh');

require('./foo')();
//=> 1

require('./foo')();
//=> 2

importFresh('./foo')();
//=> 1

importFresh('./foo')();
//=> 1

Related

npm-compare.com is an independent website designed to help developers choose the most suitable npm packages. We are not affiliated with npm, Inc or npmjs.com, the official website for the npm registry. Please note that npm is a registered trademark of npm, Inc. For more details, please refer to our Terms & Privacy.