fs-extra vs fs vs fs-extra-promise
File System Libraries in Node.js Comparison
1 Year
fs-extrafsfs-extra-promiseSimilar Packages:
What's File System Libraries in Node.js?

File system libraries in Node.js provide essential functionalities for interacting with the file system, allowing developers to read, write, and manipulate files and directories. These libraries are crucial for backend development, enabling tasks such as file uploads, data storage, and configuration management. Each library offers unique features and capabilities, catering to different needs in file handling, making it important to choose the right one based on project requirements.

NPM Package Downloads Trend
Github Stars Ranking
Stat Detail
Package
Downloads
Stars
Size
Issues
Publish
License
fs-extra45,155,4029,49754.9 kB16a year agoMIT
fs1,092,529158-48 years agoISC
fs-extra-promise4,86143-78 years agoMIT
Feature Comparison: fs-extra vs fs vs fs-extra-promise

Functionality

  • fs-extra:

    'fs-extra' extends the 'fs' module by adding extra methods like 'copy', 'move', 'remove', and 'mkdirs', which simplify complex file operations. It also provides promise-based versions of its methods for easier asynchronous programming.

  • fs:

    The 'fs' module provides essential file system operations such as reading, writing, appending, and deleting files. It supports both synchronous and asynchronous methods, giving developers flexibility in handling file operations based on their needs.

  • fs-extra-promise:

    'fs-extra-promise' wraps 'fs-extra' methods in Promises, allowing for a more modern approach to asynchronous programming. This library is particularly useful for developers who prefer using async/await for cleaner code.

Error Handling

  • fs-extra:

    'fs-extra' improves error handling by providing more descriptive error messages and additional methods that simplify common tasks, reducing the chances of errors during file operations.

  • fs:

    Error handling in 'fs' is done through callbacks, which can lead to callback hell in complex applications. Developers must manually handle errors in each callback, making the code harder to read and maintain.

  • fs-extra-promise:

    'fs-extra-promise' leverages Promises for error handling, allowing developers to use try/catch blocks with async/await syntax. This results in cleaner and more manageable error handling in asynchronous code.

Performance

  • fs-extra:

    'fs-extra' maintains performance while adding extra features, but developers should be cautious with its additional functionalities as they may introduce overhead compared to the native 'fs' methods.

  • fs:

    The 'fs' module is optimized for performance in basic file operations, but its synchronous methods can block the event loop, potentially leading to performance bottlenecks in high-load applications.

  • fs-extra-promise:

    'fs-extra-promise' offers similar performance to 'fs-extra' while providing the benefits of Promises. However, the performance may vary based on how Promises are handled in the application.

Ease of Use

  • fs-extra:

    'fs-extra' simplifies file operations with a more intuitive API and additional methods, making it easier for developers to perform common tasks without writing extensive code.

  • fs:

    The 'fs' module is straightforward for basic file operations, but its callback-based API can become cumbersome for complex tasks, requiring more boilerplate code.

  • fs-extra-promise:

    'fs-extra-promise' enhances ease of use by allowing developers to write asynchronous code in a more readable manner using async/await, reducing the complexity associated with callback-based code.

Community and Support

  • fs-extra:

    'fs-extra' has a strong community and is widely used, offering good documentation and support for its extended functionalities, making it a popular choice among developers.

  • fs:

    As a core Node.js module, 'fs' has extensive documentation and community support, making it reliable for basic file operations.

  • fs-extra-promise:

    'fs-extra-promise' benefits from the popularity of 'fs-extra' and has a growing user base, but it may have less community support compared to the core 'fs' module.

How to Choose: fs-extra vs fs vs fs-extra-promise
  • fs-extra:

    Choose 'fs-extra' if you require additional functionalities beyond the standard 'fs' module, such as recursive directory creation, file copying, and more robust error handling. It is ideal for projects that need enhanced file system capabilities without the complexity of a full-fledged library.

  • fs:

    Choose 'fs' if you need a lightweight, built-in solution for basic file operations without any additional dependencies. It is suitable for simple file handling tasks and is part of Node.js core modules.

  • fs-extra-promise:

    Choose 'fs-extra-promise' if you prefer using Promises for asynchronous file operations, allowing for cleaner and more manageable asynchronous code. This is beneficial for modern JavaScript applications that utilize async/await syntax.

README for fs-extra

Node.js: fs-extra

fs-extra adds file system methods that aren't included in the native fs module and adds promise support to the fs methods. It also uses graceful-fs to prevent EMFILE errors. It should be a drop in replacement for fs.

npm Package License build status downloads per month JavaScript Style Guide

Why?

I got tired of including mkdirp, rimraf, and ncp in most of my projects.

Installation

npm install fs-extra

Usage

CommonJS

fs-extra is a drop in replacement for native fs. All methods in fs are attached to fs-extra. All fs methods return promises if the callback isn't passed.

You don't ever need to include the original fs module again:

const fs = require('fs') // this is no longer necessary

you can now do this:

const fs = require('fs-extra')

or if you prefer to make it clear that you're using fs-extra and not fs, you may want to name your fs variable fse like so:

const fse = require('fs-extra')

you can also keep both, but it's redundant:

const fs = require('fs')
const fse = require('fs-extra')

ESM

There is also an fs-extra/esm import, that supports both default and named exports. However, note that fs methods are not included in fs-extra/esm; you still need to import fs and/or fs/promises seperately:

import { readFileSync } from 'fs'
import { readFile } from 'fs/promises'
import { outputFile, outputFileSync } from 'fs-extra/esm'

Default exports are supported:

import fs from 'fs'
import fse from 'fs-extra/esm'
// fse.readFileSync is not a function; must use fs.readFileSync

but you probably want to just use regular fs-extra instead of fs-extra/esm for default exports:

import fs from 'fs-extra'
// both fs and fs-extra methods are defined

Sync vs Async vs Async/Await

Most methods are async by default. All async methods will return a promise if the callback isn't passed.

Sync methods on the other hand will throw if an error occurs.

Also Async/Await will throw an error if one occurs.

Example:

const fs = require('fs-extra')

// Async with promises:
fs.copy('/tmp/myfile', '/tmp/mynewfile')
  .then(() => console.log('success!'))
  .catch(err => console.error(err))

// Async with callbacks:
fs.copy('/tmp/myfile', '/tmp/mynewfile', err => {
  if (err) return console.error(err)
  console.log('success!')
})

// Sync:
try {
  fs.copySync('/tmp/myfile', '/tmp/mynewfile')
  console.log('success!')
} catch (err) {
  console.error(err)
}

// Async/Await:
async function copyFiles () {
  try {
    await fs.copy('/tmp/myfile', '/tmp/mynewfile')
    console.log('success!')
  } catch (err) {
    console.error(err)
  }
}

copyFiles()

Methods

Async

Sync

NOTE: You can still use the native Node.js methods. They are promisified and copied over to fs-extra. See notes on fs.read(), fs.write(), & fs.writev()

What happened to walk() and walkSync()?

They were removed from fs-extra in v2.0.0. If you need the functionality, walk and walkSync are available as separate packages, klaw and klaw-sync.

Third Party

CLI

fse-cli allows you to run fs-extra from a console or from npm scripts.

TypeScript

If you like TypeScript, you can use fs-extra with it: https://github.com/DefinitelyTyped/DefinitelyTyped/tree/master/types/fs-extra

File / Directory Watching

If you want to watch for changes to files or directories, then you should use chokidar.

Obtain Filesystem (Devices, Partitions) Information

fs-filesystem allows you to read the state of the filesystem of the host on which it is run. It returns information about both the devices and the partitions (volumes) of the system.

Misc.

Hacking on fs-extra

Wanna hack on fs-extra? Great! Your help is needed! fs-extra is one of the most depended upon Node.js packages. This project uses JavaScript Standard Style - if the name or style choices bother you, you're gonna have to get over it :) If standard is good enough for npm, it's good enough for fs-extra.

js-standard-style

What's needed?

  • First, take a look at existing issues. Those are probably going to be where the priority lies.
  • More tests for edge cases. Specifically on different platforms. There can never be enough tests.
  • Improve test coverage.

Note: If you make any big changes, you should definitely file an issue for discussion first.

Running the Test Suite

fs-extra contains hundreds of tests.

  • npm run lint: runs the linter (standard)
  • npm run unit: runs the unit tests
  • npm run unit-esm: runs tests for fs-extra/esm exports
  • npm test: runs the linter and all tests

When running unit tests, set the environment variable CROSS_DEVICE_PATH to the absolute path of an empty directory on another device (like a thumb drive) to enable cross-device move tests.

Windows

If you run the tests on the Windows and receive a lot of symbolic link EPERM permission errors, it's because on Windows you need elevated privilege to create symbolic links. You can add this to your Windows's account by following the instructions here: http://superuser.com/questions/104845/permission-to-make-symbolic-links-in-windows-7 However, I didn't have much luck doing this.

Since I develop on Mac OS X, I use VMWare Fusion for Windows testing. I create a shared folder that I map to a drive on Windows. I open the Node.js command prompt and run as Administrator. I then map the network drive running the following command:

net use z: "\\vmware-host\Shared Folders"

I can then navigate to my fs-extra directory and run the tests.

Naming

I put a lot of thought into the naming of these functions. Inspired by @coolaj86's request. So he deserves much of the credit for raising the issue. See discussion(s) here:

  • https://github.com/jprichardson/node-fs-extra/issues/2
  • https://github.com/flatiron/utile/issues/11
  • https://github.com/ryanmcgrath/wrench-js/issues/29
  • https://github.com/substack/node-mkdirp/issues/17

First, I believe that in as many cases as possible, the Node.js naming schemes should be chosen. However, there are problems with the Node.js own naming schemes.

For example, fs.readFile() and fs.readdir(): the F is capitalized in File and the d is not capitalized in dir. Perhaps a bit pedantic, but they should still be consistent. Also, Node.js has chosen a lot of POSIX naming schemes, which I believe is great. See: fs.mkdir(), fs.rmdir(), fs.chown(), etc.

We have a dilemma though. How do you consistently name methods that perform the following POSIX commands: cp, cp -r, mkdir -p, and rm -rf?

My perspective: when in doubt, err on the side of simplicity. A directory is just a hierarchical grouping of directories and files. Consider that for a moment. So when you want to copy it or remove it, in most cases you'll want to copy or remove all of its contents. When you want to create a directory, if the directory that it's suppose to be contained in does not exist, then in most cases you'll want to create that too.

So, if you want to remove a file or a directory regardless of whether it has contents, just call fs.remove(path). If you want to copy a file or a directory whether it has contents, just call fs.copy(source, destination). If you want to create a directory regardless of whether its parent directories exist, just call fs.mkdirs(path) or fs.mkdirp(path).

Credit

fs-extra wouldn't be possible without using the modules from the following authors:

License

Licensed under MIT

Copyright (c) 2011-2017 JP Richardson