heapdump vs v8-profiler-next vs memwatch-next
Node.js Memory Profiling Tools Comparison
1 Year
heapdumpv8-profiler-nextmemwatch-next
What's Node.js Memory Profiling Tools?

These libraries are designed to help developers analyze and manage memory usage in Node.js applications. They provide tools for detecting memory leaks, profiling memory usage, and understanding how memory is allocated and freed in the application. By using these tools, developers can optimize their applications for better performance and resource management, ensuring that they run efficiently without consuming excessive memory.

Package Weekly Downloads Trend
Github Stars Ranking
Stat Detail
Package
Downloads
Stars
Size
Issues
Publish
License
heapdump100,1432,519-76 years agoISC
v8-profiler-next54,59322892.6 kB4a year agoMIT
memwatch-next3,332780-329 years ago-
Feature Comparison: heapdump vs v8-profiler-next vs memwatch-next

Memory Leak Detection

  • heapdump:

    heapdump allows you to take heap snapshots that can be analyzed to identify memory leaks. By comparing snapshots taken at different times, you can see which objects are not being garbage collected and understand the root cause of memory leaks.

  • v8-profiler-next:

    v8-profiler-next does not focus specifically on memory leaks but can help identify memory issues through its profiling capabilities. It allows you to analyze memory usage patterns and identify functions that may contribute to excessive memory consumption.

  • memwatch-next:

    memwatch-next automatically detects memory leaks by monitoring the memory usage of your application. It provides events that notify you when a potential leak is detected, allowing you to take action before it becomes a significant issue.

Profiling Capabilities

  • heapdump:

    heapdump provides detailed heap snapshots that can be analyzed using tools like Chrome DevTools. This allows for in-depth analysis of memory allocation and object retention, helping developers pinpoint memory issues effectively.

  • v8-profiler-next:

    v8-profiler-next offers extensive profiling features, including CPU profiling and heap snapshots. It allows developers to analyze both CPU and memory usage, providing a holistic view of application performance.

  • memwatch-next:

    memwatch-next offers basic profiling capabilities by monitoring memory usage over time and alerting developers to potential leaks. However, it does not provide detailed snapshots or analysis tools like heapdump does.

Ease of Use

  • heapdump:

    heapdump is straightforward to use, requiring only a few lines of code to trigger heap snapshots. However, analyzing the snapshots requires familiarity with tools like Chrome DevTools, which may have a learning curve for some developers.

  • v8-profiler-next:

    v8-profiler-next may require more setup and understanding of profiling concepts, but it offers powerful features for those willing to invest the time. It is best suited for developers who need in-depth performance analysis.

  • memwatch-next:

    memwatch-next is designed for ease of use, providing automatic leak detection with minimal setup. Developers can quickly integrate it into their applications and start receiving notifications about memory issues without extensive configuration.

Integration and Compatibility

  • heapdump:

    heapdump is compatible with various Node.js versions and can be easily integrated into existing applications. It works well with other profiling tools and libraries, making it a flexible choice for developers.

  • v8-profiler-next:

    v8-profiler-next is built specifically for the V8 engine and is compatible with Node.js applications. It integrates well with other profiling tools but may require additional setup for optimal use.

  • memwatch-next:

    memwatch-next is also compatible with multiple Node.js versions and can be integrated into applications with minimal effort. However, it may not work seamlessly with all environments, especially those with strict memory management policies.

Performance Impact

  • heapdump:

    Using heapdump can introduce some performance overhead, especially when taking heap snapshots, as it pauses the V8 engine. However, this impact is generally acceptable for debugging purposes and can be minimized by taking snapshots during low-traffic periods.

  • v8-profiler-next:

    v8-profiler-next can introduce noticeable overhead during profiling sessions, especially when capturing detailed snapshots. Developers should use it judiciously in production environments and consider profiling during off-peak hours.

  • memwatch-next:

    memwatch-next has a low performance impact as it continuously monitors memory usage without requiring manual intervention. However, the overhead may increase if memory usage spikes frequently, as it needs to track and report these events.

How to Choose: heapdump vs v8-profiler-next vs memwatch-next
  • heapdump:

    Choose heapdump if you need to capture and analyze heap snapshots to identify memory leaks and understand memory allocation patterns in your application. It is particularly useful for detailed analysis of memory usage at specific points in time.

  • v8-profiler-next:

    Opt for v8-profiler-next if you require a comprehensive profiling solution that not only tracks memory usage but also provides CPU profiling capabilities. This package is suitable for performance tuning and understanding the overall behavior of your Node.js application.

  • memwatch-next:

    Select memwatch-next if you want a lightweight solution that automatically detects memory leaks and provides notifications when memory usage exceeds certain thresholds. It is ideal for applications where you want to monitor memory usage continuously without manually triggering snapshots.

README for heapdump

node-heapdump

Make a dump of the V8 heap for later inspection.

Install

npm install heapdump

Or, if you are running node.js v0.6 or v0.8:

npm install heapdump@0.1.0

Build

node-gyp configure build

Usage

Load the add-on in your application:

var heapdump = require('heapdump');

The module exports a single writeSnapshot([filename], [callback]) function that writes out a snapshot. filename defaults to heapdump-<sec>.<usec>.heapsnapshot when omitted.

heapdump.writeSnapshot('/var/local/' + Date.now() + '.heapsnapshot');

The function also takes an optional callback function which is called upon completion of the heap dump.

heapdump.writeSnapshot(function(err, filename) {
  console.log('dump written to', filename);
});

The snapshot is written synchronously to disk. When the JS heap is large, it may introduce a noticeable "hitch".

On UNIX platforms, you can force a snapshot by sending the node.js process a SIGUSR2 signal:

$ kill -USR2 <pid>

The SIGUSR2 signal handler is enabled by default but you can disable it by setting NODE_HEAPDUMP_OPTIONS=nosignal in the environment:

$ env NODE_HEAPDUMP_OPTIONS=nosignal node script.js

Inspecting the snapshot

Open Google Chrome and press F12 to open the developer toolbar.

Go to the Memory tab, right-click in the tab pane and select Load profile....

Select the dump file and click Open. You can now inspect the heap snapshot at your leisure. Some snapshots may take a long time to load, on the order of minutes or even hours.

Note that Chrome will refuse to load the file unless it has the .heapsnapshot extension.

Caveats

On UNIX systems, the rule of thumb for creating a heap snapshot is that it requires memory twice the size of the heap at the time of the snapshot. If you end up with empty or truncated snapshot files, check the output of dmesg; you may have had a run-in with the system's OOM killer or a resource limit enforcing policy, like ulimit -u (max user processes) or ulimit -v (max virtual memory size).