owasp-password-strength-test vs password-validator vs zxcvbn
Password Strength Validation Libraries
owasp-password-strength-testpassword-validatorzxcvbnSimilar Packages:

Password Strength Validation Libraries

These libraries are designed to assess and validate the strength of passwords based on various criteria, helping developers enforce strong password policies in their applications. They provide different methodologies and algorithms for evaluating password strength, which can enhance security by encouraging users to create more robust passwords. Each library has unique features and approaches to password validation, catering to different use cases and developer preferences.

Npm Package Weekly Downloads Trend

3 Years

Github Stars Ranking

Stat Detail

Package
Downloads
Stars
Size
Issues
Publish
License
owasp-password-strength-test0247-1111 years agoMIT
password-validator028435.8 kB7-MIT
zxcvbn015,912-1429 years agoMIT

Feature Comparison: owasp-password-strength-test vs password-validator vs zxcvbn

Validation Methodology

  • owasp-password-strength-test:

    This library implements the OWASP Password Strength Validation guidelines, which assess passwords based on length, character variety, and common patterns. It provides a score and feedback on how to improve password strength, making it suitable for applications that need a standardized approach to password security.

  • password-validator:

    Password-validator allows developers to define custom validation rules such as minimum length, required characters, and disallowed patterns. This flexibility makes it easy to tailor password policies to specific application needs, providing a straightforward validation mechanism without strict adherence to external standards.

  • zxcvbn:

    Zxcvbn employs a sophisticated algorithm that analyzes passwords against a database of common passwords and patterns. It evaluates the strength based on entropy and provides feedback on how to create stronger passwords, making it ideal for applications that aim to educate users on password security.

User Feedback

  • owasp-password-strength-test:

    The library provides detailed feedback on password strength, including suggestions for improvement. This feature helps users understand why their password may be weak and encourages them to create stronger alternatives, enhancing user experience and security awareness.

  • password-validator:

    Password-validator can return specific error messages based on the defined rules, allowing developers to provide clear guidance to users on why their password did not meet the requirements. This direct feedback can improve user compliance with password policies.

  • zxcvbn:

    Zxcvbn offers insightful feedback on password strength, including suggestions for making passwords stronger. It helps users understand the risks associated with weak passwords and encourages better password practices, fostering a culture of security.

Customization

  • owasp-password-strength-test:

    While primarily focused on OWASP guidelines, this library allows some customization in terms of scoring thresholds and feedback messages. However, it may not be as flexible as other libraries for defining entirely unique password policies.

  • password-validator:

    Password-validator excels in customization, allowing developers to easily set their own rules for password creation. This makes it highly adaptable for various applications, enabling tailored security measures based on specific requirements.

  • zxcvbn:

    Zxcvbn is less customizable in terms of defining specific password rules but provides a robust analysis of password strength. It focuses on evaluating passwords against known patterns rather than allowing developers to set unique criteria.

Performance

  • owasp-password-strength-test:

    This library is efficient for real-time password validation, providing quick feedback without significant performance overhead. It is suitable for applications where immediate user feedback is essential during password creation.

  • password-validator:

    Password-validator is lightweight and performs well even with complex validation rules, making it suitable for applications with high user traffic where performance is critical during password entry.

  • zxcvbn:

    Zxcvbn is designed to handle password strength evaluation efficiently, though it may be slightly slower than simpler libraries due to its comprehensive analysis. It is best used in scenarios where detailed feedback is prioritized over raw speed.

Community and Support

  • owasp-password-strength-test:

    Being part of the OWASP foundation, this library benefits from a strong community and regular updates based on the latest security practices. It is well-documented, making it easier for developers to implement and maintain.

  • password-validator:

    Password-validator has a supportive community and is actively maintained, providing good documentation and examples. It is suitable for developers looking for a straightforward solution with community backing.

  • zxcvbn:

    Zxcvbn is widely used and has a large community, ensuring ongoing support and updates. Its documentation is comprehensive, making it accessible for developers who want to implement advanced password strength validation.

How to Choose: owasp-password-strength-test vs password-validator vs zxcvbn

  • owasp-password-strength-test:

    Choose owasp-password-strength-test if you need a library that adheres to OWASP guidelines for password strength and provides a comprehensive scoring system based on multiple factors. It is particularly useful for applications that require a standardized approach to password validation.

  • password-validator:

    Select password-validator if you want a simple and customizable solution that allows you to define your own password policies easily. It is ideal for projects where you need flexibility in setting specific rules for password creation without complex configurations.

  • zxcvbn:

    Opt for zxcvbn if you require a library that uses advanced algorithms to evaluate password strength based on real-world data and common password patterns. It provides a more nuanced understanding of password security and is suitable for applications that prioritize user education on password creation.

README for owasp-password-strength-test

OWASP Password Strength Test

owasp-password-strength-test is a password-strength tester based off of the OWASP Guidelines for enforcing secure passwords. It is lightweight, extensible, has no dependencies, and can be used on the server (nodejs) or in-browser.

owasp-password-strength-test is not an OWASP project - it is merely based off of OWASP research.

Build Status

Installing

Server-side (nodejs)

From the command line:

npm install owasp-password-strength-test

In-browser

Within your document:

<script src='owasp-password-strength-test.js'></script>

Features

This module is built upon the following beliefs:

  1. Passphrases are better than passwords.

  2. Passwords should be subject to stricter complexity requirements than passphrases.

Thus, the module:

  • provides for "required" and "optional" tests. In order to be considered "strong", a password must pass all required tests, as well as a configurable number of optional tests. This makes it possible to always enforce certain rules (like minimum password length), while giving users flexibility to honor only some of a pool of lower-priority rules.

  • encourages the use of passphrases over passwords. Passphrases (by default) are not subject to the same complexity requirements as a password. (Whereby, by default, a "passphrase" can be defined as "a password whose length is greater than or equal to 20 characters.")

  • can be arbitrarily extended as-needed with additional required and optional tests.

Usage

After you've included it into your project, using the module is straightforward:

Server-side

// require the module
var owasp = require('owasp-password-strength-test');

// invoke test() to test the strength of a password
var result = owasp.test('correct horse battery staple');

In-browser

// in the browser, including the script will make a
// `window.owaspPasswordStrengthTest` object availble.
var result = owaspPasswordStrengthTest.test('correct horse battery staple');

The returned value will take this shape when the password is valid:

{
  errors              : [],
  failedTests         : [],
  requiredTestErrors  : [],
  optionalTestErrors  : [],
  passedTests         : [ 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 ],
  isPassphrase        : false,
  strong              : true,
  optionalTestsPassed : 4
}

... and will take this shape when the password is invalid:

{
  errors: [
      'The password must be at least 10 characters long.',
      'The password must contain at least one uppercase letter.',
      'The password must contain at least one number.',
      'The password must contain at least one special character.'
    ],
    failedTests         : [ 0, 4, 5, 6 ],
    passedTests         : [ 1, 2, 3 ],
    requiredTestErrors  : [
      'The password must be at least 10 characters long.',
    ],
    optionalTestErrors  : [
      'The password must contain at least one uppercase letter.',
      'The password must contain at least one number.',
      'The password must contain at least one special character.'
    ],
    isPassphrase        : false,
    strong              : false,
    optionalTestsPassed : 1
}

Whereby:

  • errors is an array of strings of error messages associated with the failed tests.

  • failedTests enumerates which tests have failed, beginning from 0 with the first required test

  • passedTests enumerates which tests have succeeded, beginning from 0 with the first required test

  • requiredTestErrors is an array containing the error messages of required tests that have failed.

  • optionalTestErrors is an array containing the error messages of optional tests that have failed.

  • isPassphrase is a boolean indicating whether or not the password was considered to be a passphrase.

  • strong is a boolean indicating whether or not the user's password satisfied the strength requirements.

  • optionalTestsPassed is a number indicating how many of the optional tests were passed. In order for the password to be considered "strong", it (by default) must either be a passphrase, or must pass a number of optional tests that is equal to or greater than configs.minOptionalTestsToPass.

Configuring

The module may be configured as follows:

var owasp = require('owasp-password-strength-test');

// Pass a hash of settings to the `config` method. The settings shown here are
// the defaults.
owasp.config({
  allowPassphrases       : true,
  maxLength              : 128,
  minLength              : 10,
  minPhraseLength        : 20,
  minOptionalTestsToPass : 4,
});

Whereby:

  • allowPassphrases is a boolean that toggles the "passphrase" mechanism on and off. If set to false, the strength-checker will abandon the notion of "passphrases", and will subject all passwords to the same complexity requirements.

  • maxLength is a constraint on a password's maximum length.

  • minLength is a constraint on a password's minimum length.

  • minPhraseLength is the minimum length a password needs to achieve in order to be considered a "passphrase" (and thus exempted from the optional complexity tests by default).

  • minOptionalTestsToPass is the minimum number of optional tests that a password must pass in order to be considered "strong". By default (per the OWASP guidelines), four optional complexity tests are made, and a password must pass at least three of them in order to be considered "strong".

Extending

If you would like to filter passwords through additional tests beyond the default, you may simply push new tests onto the appropriate arrays within the module's test object:

var owasp = require('owasp-password-strength-test');

// push "required" tests onto `tests.required` array, and push "optional" tests
// onto the `tests.optional` array.
owasp.tests.required.push(function(password) {
  if (password === 'one two three four five') {
    return "That's the kind of thing an idiot would have on his luggage!";
  }
});

Test functions must resemble the following:

// accept the password as the single argument
function(password) {

  // the "if" conditional should evaluate to `true` if the password is bad
  if (thePasswordIsBad) {

    // On password failure, a string should be returned. It will be pushed
    // onto an array of errors associated with the password.
    return "This is the failure message associated with the test";
  }

  // if the password is OK, nothing should be returned
}

Testing

To run the module's test suite, cd into its directory and run npm test. You may first need to run npm install to install the required development dependencies. (These dependencies are not required in a production environment, and facilitate only unit testing.)

Contributing

If you would like to contribute code, please fork this repository, make your changes, and then submit a pull-request.