path-to-regexp vs query-string vs url-template vs uri-template
URL and Query String Manipulation Libraries Comparison
1 Year
path-to-regexpquery-stringurl-templateuri-templateSimilar Packages:
What's URL and Query String Manipulation Libraries?

These libraries serve different purposes in handling URLs and query strings in web applications. They provide utilities for parsing, formatting, and manipulating URLs and query parameters, which are essential for building dynamic web applications that rely on routing and data transmission through URLs. Each library has its own strengths and use cases, catering to various needs in web development.

Package Weekly Downloads Trend
Github Stars Ranking
Stat Detail
Package
Downloads
Stars
Size
Issues
Publish
License
path-to-regexp69,315,7548,38255.2 kB77 months agoMIT
query-string12,849,1746,84051.5 kB297 days agoMIT
url-template4,226,4841847.99 kB1a year agoBSD-3-Clause
uri-template112,29042-14 years agoMIT
Feature Comparison: path-to-regexp vs query-string vs url-template vs uri-template

Parsing and Stringifying

  • path-to-regexp:

    path-to-regexp does not handle query strings directly; it focuses on converting paths into regular expressions for route matching. It is primarily used for extracting parameters from the URL path itself.

  • query-string:

    query-string excels at parsing and stringifying query strings. It can convert a query string into an object and vice versa, making it easy to manipulate URL parameters. It also supports nested objects and arrays, providing flexibility in handling complex query strings.

  • url-template:

    url-template allows for parsing and expanding URL templates, enabling dynamic URL generation by substituting variables in the template with actual values. It is particularly useful for constructing URLs with placeholders.

  • uri-template:

    uri-template provides functionality to parse URI templates and expand them with variable values. It allows for the creation of dynamic URIs based on templates, but it does not handle query strings directly.

Use Cases

  • path-to-regexp:

    path-to-regexp is best suited for web frameworks that require route matching, such as Express.js. It is used to define dynamic routes and extract parameters from the URL, making it essential for server-side routing.

  • query-string:

    query-string is ideal for client-side applications that need to handle query parameters. It is commonly used in single-page applications (SPAs) to manage state and navigation through URL parameters.

  • url-template:

    url-template is particularly beneficial for APIs that need to generate URLs dynamically based on templates. It simplifies the process of creating URLs with variable parts, making it easier to work with RESTful services.

  • uri-template:

    uri-template is useful in scenarios where you need to generate URLs based on templates, such as in RESTful APIs. It allows for easy construction of URLs that require variable substitution.

Complexity and Learning Curve

  • path-to-regexp:

    path-to-regexp has a moderate learning curve, especially for developers familiar with regular expressions. Understanding how to define routes and extract parameters requires some knowledge of regex patterns.

  • query-string:

    query-string is straightforward and easy to learn, making it accessible for developers of all skill levels. Its API is simple, focusing on parsing and stringifying query strings without complex configurations.

  • url-template:

    url-template is relatively easy to use, but developers should understand the concept of URL templates and how to define placeholders for variable substitution.

  • uri-template:

    uri-template has a moderate complexity due to its adherence to the URI Template specification. Developers may need to familiarize themselves with the syntax and rules for defining templates.

Performance

  • path-to-regexp:

    path-to-regexp is optimized for performance in route matching, as it compiles paths into regular expressions. This allows for efficient matching of incoming requests against defined routes.

  • query-string:

    query-string is lightweight and performs well for parsing and stringifying query strings. It is designed for speed and efficiency, making it suitable for high-performance applications that handle numerous URL parameters.

  • url-template:

    url-template is efficient for generating URLs from templates, but performance can vary based on the complexity of the template and the number of substitutions required.

  • uri-template:

    uri-template performs well for expanding templates, but its performance depends on the complexity of the templates and the number of variables being substituted. It is generally efficient for generating URIs.

Extensibility

  • path-to-regexp:

    path-to-regexp is extensible in the sense that developers can build upon its regex capabilities to create custom route matching logic, but it does not provide built-in extensibility features.

  • query-string:

    query-string is designed to be simple and does not have built-in extensibility features. However, its straightforward API allows developers to easily integrate it into their applications without much overhead.

  • url-template:

    url-template can be extended by creating custom templates or integrating with other libraries, but it primarily focuses on the core functionality of URL generation.

  • uri-template:

    uri-template is based on a standard and can be extended by implementing additional features or custom parsing logic, but it requires a deeper understanding of the URI Template specification.

How to Choose: path-to-regexp vs query-string vs url-template vs uri-template
  • path-to-regexp:

    Choose path-to-regexp if you need to convert paths into regular expressions for route matching, especially in frameworks like Express.js. It is ideal for defining dynamic routes and extracting parameters from URLs.

  • query-string:

    Select query-string when you need a simple and efficient way to parse and stringify query strings. It is particularly useful for handling URL parameters in web applications and supports nested objects and arrays.

  • url-template:

    Opt for url-template when you need to work with URL templates that allow for variable substitution. This is useful for generating URLs from templates with placeholders, especially in RESTful APIs.

  • uri-template:

    Use uri-template if you require a standard way to define and expand URIs based on templates. This is beneficial for APIs that need to generate URLs dynamically based on variable parameters.

README for path-to-regexp

Path-to-RegExp

Turn a path string such as /user/:name into a regular expression.

NPM version NPM downloads Build status Build coverage License

Installation

npm install path-to-regexp --save

Usage

const {
  match,
  pathToRegexp,
  compile,
  parse,
  stringify,
} = require("path-to-regexp");

Parameters

Parameters match arbitrary strings in a path by matching up to the end of the segment, or up to any proceeding tokens. They are defined by prefixing a colon to the parameter name (:foo). Parameter names can use any valid JavaScript identifier, or be double quoted to use other characters (:"param-name").

const fn = match("/:foo/:bar");

fn("/test/route");
//=> { path: '/test/route', params: { foo: 'test', bar: 'route' } }

Wildcard

Wildcard parameters match one or more characters across multiple segments. They are defined the same way as regular parameters, but are prefixed with an asterisk (*foo).

const fn = match("/*splat");

fn("/bar/baz");
//=> { path: '/bar/baz', params: { splat: [ 'bar', 'baz' ] } }

Optional

Braces can be used to define parts of the path that are optional.

const fn = match("/users{/:id}/delete");

fn("/users/delete");
//=> { path: '/users/delete', params: {} }

fn("/users/123/delete");
//=> { path: '/users/123/delete', params: { id: '123' } }

Match

The match function returns a function for matching strings against a path:

  • path String or array of strings.
  • options (optional) (Extends pathToRegexp options)
    • decode Function for decoding strings to params, or false to disable all processing. (default: decodeURIComponent)
const fn = match("/foo/:bar");

Please note: path-to-regexp is intended for ordered data (e.g. paths, hosts). It can not handle arbitrarily ordered data (e.g. query strings, URL fragments, JSON, etc).

PathToRegexp

The pathToRegexp function returns a regular expression for matching strings against paths. It

  • path String or array of strings.
  • options (optional) (See parse for more options)
    • sensitive Regexp will be case sensitive. (default: false)
    • end Validate the match reaches the end of the string. (default: true)
    • delimiter The default delimiter for segments, e.g. [^/] for :named parameters. (default: '/')
    • trailing Allows optional trailing delimiter to match. (default: true)
const { regexp, keys } = pathToRegexp("/foo/:bar");

Compile ("Reverse" Path-To-RegExp)

The compile function will return a function for transforming parameters into a valid path:

  • path A string.
  • options (See parse for more options)
    • delimiter The default delimiter for segments, e.g. [^/] for :named parameters. (default: '/')
    • encode Function for encoding input strings for output into the path, or false to disable entirely. (default: encodeURIComponent)
const toPath = compile("/user/:id");

toPath({ id: "name" }); //=> "/user/name"
toPath({ id: "café" }); //=> "/user/caf%C3%A9"

const toPathRepeated = compile("/*segment");

toPathRepeated({ segment: ["foo"] }); //=> "/foo"
toPathRepeated({ segment: ["a", "b", "c"] }); //=> "/a/b/c"

// When disabling `encode`, you need to make sure inputs are encoded correctly. No arrays are accepted.
const toPathRaw = compile("/user/:id", { encode: false });

toPathRaw({ id: "%3A%2F" }); //=> "/user/%3A%2F"

Stringify

Transform TokenData (a sequence of tokens) back into a Path-to-RegExp string.

  • data A TokenData instance
const data = new TokenData([
  { type: "text", value: "/" },
  { type: "param", name: "foo" },
]);

const path = stringify(data); //=> "/:foo"

Developers

  • If you are rewriting paths with match and compile, consider using encode: false and decode: false to keep raw paths passed around.
  • To ensure matches work on paths containing characters usually encoded, such as emoji, consider using encodeurl for encodePath.

Parse

The parse function accepts a string and returns TokenData, the set of tokens and other metadata parsed from the input string. TokenData is can used with match and compile.

  • path A string.
  • options (optional)
    • encodePath A function for encoding input strings. (default: x => x, recommended: encodeurl)

Tokens

TokenData is a sequence of tokens, currently of types text, parameter, wildcard, or group.

Custom path

In some applications, you may not be able to use the path-to-regexp syntax, but still want to use this library for match and compile. For example:

import { TokenData, match } from "path-to-regexp";

const tokens = [
  { type: "text", value: "/" },
  { type: "parameter", name: "foo" },
];
const path = new TokenData(tokens);
const fn = match(path);

fn("/test"); //=> { path: '/test', index: 0, params: { foo: 'test' } }

Errors

An effort has been made to ensure ambiguous paths from previous releases throw an error. This means you might be seeing an error when things worked before.

Unexpected ? or +

In past releases, ?, *, and + were used to denote optional or repeating parameters. As an alternative, try these:

  • For optional (?), use an empty segment in a group such as /:file{.:ext}.
  • For repeating (+), only wildcard matching is supported, such as /*path.
  • For optional repeating (*), use a group and a wildcard parameter such as /files{/*path}.

Unexpected (, ), [, ], etc.

Previous versions of Path-to-RegExp used these for RegExp features. This version no longer supports them so they've been reserved to avoid ambiguity. To use these characters literally, escape them with a backslash, e.g. "\\(".

Missing parameter name

Parameter names must be provided after : or *, and they must be a valid JavaScript identifier. If you want an parameter name that isn't a JavaScript identifier, such as starting with a number, you can wrap the name in quotes like :"my-name".

Unterminated quote

Parameter names can be wrapped in double quote characters, and this error means you forgot to close the quote character.

Express <= 4.x

Path-To-RegExp breaks compatibility with Express <= 4.x in the following ways:

  • The wildcard * must have a name, matching the behavior of parameters :.
  • The optional character ? is no longer supported, use braces instead: /:file{.:ext}.
  • Regexp characters are not supported.
  • Some characters have been reserved to avoid confusion during upgrade (()[]?+!).
  • Parameter names now support valid JavaScript identifiers, or quoted like :"this".

License

MIT