Which is Better React Visibility Detection Libraries?
react-intersection-observer vs react-visibility-sensor vs react-in-viewport
1 Year
react-intersection-observerreact-visibility-sensorreact-in-viewportSimilar Packages:
What's React Visibility Detection Libraries?

These libraries are designed to help developers determine when a component is visible within the viewport or a specific container. This functionality is crucial for optimizing performance, lazy loading images, triggering animations, and improving user experience by only rendering elements when they are in view. Each library offers different approaches and features to handle visibility detection effectively.

NPM Package Downloads Trend
Github Stars Ranking
Stat Detail
Package
Downloads
Stars
Size
Issues
Publish
License
react-intersection-observer1,825,0185,037129 kB1a month agoMIT
react-visibility-sensor210,6212,322-835 years agoMIT
react-in-viewport33,780350110 kB321 days agoMIT
Feature Comparison: react-intersection-observer vs react-visibility-sensor vs react-in-viewport

API Design

  • react-intersection-observer: Utilizes the native Intersection Observer API, providing a hook-based approach that allows for more granular control over visibility detection. This design promotes a more modern React development style, encouraging the use of hooks for state management and side effects.
  • react-visibility-sensor: Offers a component-based API that allows you to wrap any component and receive visibility updates through props. It provides a more traditional approach that may be easier for developers familiar with class-based components.
  • react-in-viewport: This library provides a higher-order component (HOC) that wraps around your components, making it easy to integrate visibility detection into existing components. It offers a simple API with props to manage visibility states, making it user-friendly for quick implementations.

Performance

  • react-intersection-observer: Highly optimized for performance as it leverages the browser's native Intersection Observer API, which is designed to efficiently manage visibility changes without triggering excessive reflows and repaints, making it suitable for performance-critical applications.
  • react-visibility-sensor: Performance can vary based on how many components are being monitored simultaneously, as it uses scroll event listeners. It may not be as performant as 'react-intersection-observer' for applications with many visibility checks.
  • react-in-viewport: While efficient for most use cases, it may not be as optimized as 'react-intersection-observer' since it relies on scroll event listeners, which can lead to performance issues in complex applications with many components being monitored.

Use Cases

  • react-intersection-observer: Perfect for applications that need precise control over visibility detection, such as infinite scrolling, lazy loading of large lists, or triggering animations based on the visibility of elements in a more performance-sensitive manner.
  • react-visibility-sensor: Great for scenarios where you need to track visibility percentage or require detailed callbacks for visibility changes, such as analytics tracking or conditional rendering based on visibility metrics.
  • react-in-viewport: Best suited for applications that require basic visibility detection without complex requirements. Ideal for lazy loading images or triggering animations when components enter the viewport.

Learning Curve

  • react-intersection-observer: Requires a basic understanding of hooks and the Intersection Observer API, which may present a slight learning curve for beginners but is generally straightforward for those familiar with modern React patterns.
  • react-visibility-sensor: Relatively easy to use, especially for those accustomed to component-based design in React. The API is intuitive, but understanding the implications of visibility metrics may require additional learning.
  • react-in-viewport: Easy to learn and implement, especially for developers who are new to React. The HOC pattern is straightforward and requires minimal setup, making it accessible for quick projects.

Community and Support

  • react-intersection-observer: Benefits from a strong community and is actively maintained, providing good documentation and examples. Its reliance on the native Intersection Observer API also means it is aligned with modern web standards.
  • react-visibility-sensor: Has a decent community and support, but may not be as actively maintained as 'react-intersection-observer'. Documentation is available, but users might find fewer resources compared to more popular libraries.
  • react-in-viewport: Has a moderate community and support, with sufficient documentation and examples available. However, it may not be as widely adopted as some other libraries, which could affect long-term support.
How to Choose: react-intersection-observer vs react-visibility-sensor vs react-in-viewport
  • react-intersection-observer: Opt for 'react-intersection-observer' if you prefer a more modern and flexible API that leverages the Intersection Observer API. This package is suitable for performance-sensitive applications, as it minimizes reflows and repaints by using a more efficient approach to detect visibility changes.
  • react-visibility-sensor: Select 'react-visibility-sensor' if you require a more comprehensive solution that includes additional features like visibility percentage and callbacks for visibility changes. This library is great for scenarios where you need detailed visibility metrics and want to trigger specific actions based on the visibility state.
  • react-in-viewport: Choose 'react-in-viewport' if you need a simple and straightforward solution that provides a higher-order component (HOC) for visibility detection. It's ideal for projects where you want to quickly implement viewport detection without extensive configuration.
README for react-intersection-observer

react-intersection-observer

Version Badge GZipped size Test License Downloads

React implementation of the Intersection Observer API to tell you when an element enters or leaves the viewport. Contains both a Hooks, render props and plain children implementation.

Features

  • 🪝 Hooks or Component API - With useInView it's easier than ever to monitor elements
  • ⚡️ Optimized performance - Reuses Intersection Observer instances where possible
  • ⚙️ Matches native API - Intuitive to use
  • 🛠 Written in TypeScript - It'll fit right into your existing TypeScript project
  • 🧪 Ready to test - Mocks the Intersection Observer for easy testing with Jest or Vitest
  • 🌳 Tree-shakeable - Only include the parts you use
  • 💥 Tiny bundle - Around ~1.15kB for useInView and ~1.6kB for <InView>

Open in StackBlitz

Installation

Install the package with your package manager of choice:

npm install react-intersection-observer --save

Usage

useInView hook

// Use object destructuring, so you don't need to remember the exact order
const { ref, inView, entry } = useInView(options);

// Or array destructuring, making it easy to customize the field names
const [ref, inView, entry] = useInView(options);

The useInView hook makes it easy to monitor the inView state of your components. Call the useInView hook with the (optional) options you need. It will return an array containing a ref, the inView status and the current entry. Assign the ref to the DOM element you want to monitor, and the hook will report the status.

import React from "react";
import { useInView } from "react-intersection-observer";

const Component = () => {
  const { ref, inView, entry } = useInView({
    /* Optional options */
    threshold: 0,
  });

  return (
    <div ref={ref}>
      <h2>{`Header inside viewport ${inView}.`}</h2>
    </div>
  );
};

Render props

To use the <InView> component, you pass it a function. It will be called whenever the state changes, with the new value of inView. In addition to the inView prop, children also receive a ref that should be set on the containing DOM element. This is the element that the Intersection Observer will monitor.

If you need it, you can also access the IntersectionObserverEntry on entry, giving you access to all the details about the current intersection state.

import { InView } from "react-intersection-observer";

const Component = () => (
  <InView>
    {({ inView, ref, entry }) => (
      <div ref={ref}>
        <h2>{`Header inside viewport ${inView}.`}</h2>
      </div>
    )}
  </InView>
);

export default Component;

Plain children

You can pass any element to the <InView />, and it will handle creating the wrapping DOM element. Add a handler to the onChange method, and control the state in your own component. Any extra props you add to <InView> will be passed to the HTML element, allowing you set the className, style, etc.

import { InView } from "react-intersection-observer";

const Component = () => (
  <InView as="div" onChange={(inView, entry) => console.log("Inview:", inView)}>
    <h2>Plain children are always rendered. Use onChange to monitor state.</h2>
  </InView>
);

export default Component;

[!NOTE] When rendering a plain child, make sure you keep your HTML output semantic. Change the as to match the context, and add a className to style the <InView />. The component does not support Ref Forwarding, so if you need a ref to the HTML element, use the Render Props version instead.

API

Options

Provide these as the options argument in the useInView hook or as props on the <InView /> component.

| Name | Type | Default | Description | | ---------------------- | ------------------------- | ----------- | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | | root | Element | document | The Intersection Observer interface's read-only root property identifies the Element or Document whose bounds are treated as the bounding box of the viewport for the element which is the observer's target. If the root is null, then the bounds of the actual document viewport are used. | | rootMargin | string | '0px' | Margin around the root. Can have values similar to the CSS margin property, e.g. "10px 20px 30px 40px" (top, right, bottom, left). Also supports percentages, to check if an element intersects with the center of the viewport for example "-50% 0% -50% 0%". | | threshold | number or number[] | 0 | Number between 0 and 1 indicating the percentage that should be visible before triggering. Can also be an array of numbers, to create multiple trigger points. | | onChange | (inView, entry) => void | undefined | Call this function whenever the in view state changes. It will receive the inView boolean, alongside the current IntersectionObserverEntry. | | trackVisibility 🧪 | boolean | false | A boolean indicating whether this Intersection Observer will track visibility changes on the target. | | delay 🧪 | number | undefined | A number indicating the minimum delay in milliseconds between notifications from this observer for a given target. This must be set to at least 100 if trackVisibility is true. | | skip | boolean | false | Skip creating the IntersectionObserver. You can use this to enable and disable the observer as needed. If skip is set while inView, the current state will still be kept. | | triggerOnce | boolean | false | Only trigger the observer once. | | initialInView | boolean | false | Set the initial value of the inView boolean. This can be used if you expect the element to be in the viewport to start with, and you want to trigger something when it leaves. | | fallbackInView | boolean | undefined | If the IntersectionObserver API isn't available in the client, the default behavior is to throw an Error. You can set a specific fallback behavior, and the inView value will be set to this instead of failing. To set a global default, you can set it with the defaultFallbackInView() |

InView Props

The <InView /> component also accepts the following props:

| Name | Type | Default | Description | | ------------ | ---------------------------------------------------- | ----------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | | as | IntrinsicElement | 'div' | Render the wrapping element as this element. Defaults to div. If you want to use a custom component, please use the useInView hook or a render prop instead to manage the reference explictly. | | children | ({ref, inView, entry}) => ReactNode or ReactNode | undefined | Children expects a function that receives an object containing the inView boolean and a ref that should be assigned to the element root. Alternatively pass a plain child, to have the <InView /> deal with the wrapping element. You will also get the IntersectionObserverEntry as entry, giving you more details. |

Intersection Observer v2 🧪

The new v2 implementation of IntersectionObserver extends the original API, so you can track if the element is covered by another element or has filters applied to it. Useful for blocking clickjacking attempts or tracking ad exposure.

To use it, you'll need to add the new trackVisibility and delay options. When you get the entry back, you can then monitor if isVisible is true.

const TrackVisible = () => {
  const { ref, entry } = useInView({ trackVisibility: true, delay: 100 });
  return <div ref={ref}>{entry?.isVisible}</div>;
};

This is still a very new addition, so check caniuse for current browser support. If trackVisibility has been set, and the current browser doesn't support it, a fallback has been added to always report isVisible as true.

It's not added to the TypeScript lib.d.ts file yet, so you will also have to extend the IntersectionObserverEntry with the isVisible boolean.

Recipes

The IntersectionObserver itself is just a simple but powerful tool. Here's a few ideas for how you can use it.

FAQ

How can I assign multiple refs to a component?

You can wrap multiple ref assignments in a single useCallback:

import React, { useRef, useCallback } from "react";
import { useInView } from "react-intersection-observer";

function Component(props) {
  const ref = useRef();
  const { ref: inViewRef, inView } = useInView();

  // Use `useCallback` so we don't recreate the function on each render
  const setRefs = useCallback(
    (node) => {
      // Ref's from useRef needs to have the node assigned to `current`
      ref.current = node;
      // Callback refs, like the one from `useInView`, is a function that takes the node as an argument
      inViewRef(node);
    },
    [inViewRef],
  );

  return <div ref={setRefs}>Shared ref is visible: {inView}</div>;
}

rootMargin isn't working as expected

When using rootMargin, the margin gets added to the current root - If your application is running inside a <iframe>, or you have defined a custom root this will not be the current viewport.

You can read more about this on these links:

Testing

In order to write meaningful tests, the IntersectionObserver needs to be mocked. You can use the included react-intersection-observer/test-utils to help with this. It mocks the IntersectionObserver, and includes a few methods to assist with faking the inView state. When setting the isIntersecting value you can pass either a boolean value or a threshold between 0 and 1. It will emulate the real IntersectionObserver, allowing you to validate that your components are behaving as expected.

| Method | Description | | --------------------------------------------- | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | | mockAllIsIntersecting(isIntersecting) | Set isIntersecting on all current Intersection Observer instances. The value of isIntersecting should be either a boolean or a threshold between 0 and 1. | | mockIsIntersecting(element, isIntersecting) | Set isIntersecting for the Intersection Observer of a specific element. The value of isIntersecting should be either a boolean or a threshold between 0 and 1. | | intersectionMockInstance(element) | Call the intersectionMockInstance method with an element, to get the (mocked) IntersectionObserver instance. You can use this to spy on the observe andunobserve methods. | | setupIntersectionMocking(mockFn) | Mock the IntersectionObserver, so we can interact with them in tests - Should be called in beforeEach. (Done automatically in Jest environment) | | resetIntersectionMocking() | Reset the mocks on IntersectionObserver - Should be called in afterEach. (Done automatically in Jest environment) |

Testing Libraries

This library comes with built-in support for writing tests in both Jest and Vitest

Jest

Testing with Jest should work out of the box. Just import the react-intersection-observer/test-utils in your test files, and you can use the mocking methods.

Vitest

If you're running Vitest with globals, then it'll automatically mock the IntersectionObserver, just like running with Jest. Otherwise, you'll need to manually setup/reset the mocking in either the individual tests, or a setup file.

import { vi, beforeEach, afterEach } from "vitest";
import {
  setupIntersectionMocking,
  resetIntersectionMocking,
} from "react-intersection-observer/test-utils";

beforeEach(() => {
  setupIntersectionMocking(vi.fn);
});

afterEach(() => {
  resetIntersectionMocking();
});

You only need to do this if the test environment does not support beforeEach globally, alongside either jest.fn or vi.fn.

Other Testing Libraries

See the instructions for Vitest. You should be able to use a similar setup/reset code, adapted to the testing library you are using. Failing that, copy the code from test-utils.ts, and make your own version.

Fallback Behavior

You can create a Jest setup file that leverages the unsupported fallback option. In this case, you can override the IntersectionObserver in test files were you actively import react-intersection-observer/test-utils.

test-setup.js

import { defaultFallbackInView } from "react-intersection-observer";

defaultFallbackInView(true); // or `false` - whichever consistent behavior makes the most sense for your use case.

Alternatively, you can mock the Intersection Observer in all tests with a global setup file. Add react-intersection-observer/test-utils to setupFilesAfterEnv in the Jest config, or setupFiles in Vitest.

module.exports = {
  setupFilesAfterEnv: ["react-intersection-observer/test-utils"],
};

Test Example

import React from "react";
import { screen, render } from "@testing-library/react";
import { useInView } from "react-intersection-observer";
import {
  mockAllIsIntersecting,
  mockIsIntersecting,
  intersectionMockInstance,
} from "react-intersection-observer/test-utils";

const HookComponent = ({ options }) => {
  const { ref, inView } = useInView(options);
  return (
    <div ref={ref} data-testid="wrapper">
      {inView.toString()}
    </div>
  );
};

test("should create a hook inView", () => {
  render(<HookComponent />);

  // This causes all (existing) IntersectionObservers to be set as intersecting
  mockAllIsIntersecting(true);
  screen.getByText("true");
});

test("should create a hook inView with threshold", () => {
  render(<HookComponent options={{ threshold: 0.3 }} />);

  mockAllIsIntersecting(0.1);
  screen.getByText("false");

  // Once the threshold has been passed, it will trigger inView.
  mockAllIsIntersecting(0.3);
  screen.getByText("true");
});

test("should mock intersecing on specific hook", () => {
  render(<HookComponent />);
  const wrapper = screen.getByTestId("wrapper");

  // Set the intersection state on the wrapper.
  mockIsIntersecting(wrapper, 0.5);
  screen.getByText("true");
});

test("should create a hook and call observe", () => {
  const { getByTestId } = render(<HookComponent />);
  const wrapper = getByTestId("wrapper");
  // Access the `IntersectionObserver` instance for the wrapper Element.
  const instance = intersectionMockInstance(wrapper);

  expect(instance.observe).toHaveBeenCalledWith(wrapper);
});

Intersection Observer

Intersection Observer is the API used to determine if an element is inside the viewport or not. Browser support is excellent - With Safari adding support in 12.1, all major browsers now support Intersection Observers natively. Add the polyfill, so it doesn't break on older versions of iOS and IE11.

Unsupported fallback

If the client doesn't have support for the IntersectionObserver, then the default behavior is to throw an error. This will crash the React application, unless you capture it with an Error Boundary.

If you prefer, you can set a fallback inView value to use if the IntersectionObserver doesn't exist. This will make react-intersection-observer fail gracefully, but you must ensure your application can correctly handle all your observers firing either true or false at the same time.

You can set the fallback globally:

import { defaultFallbackInView } from "react-intersection-observer";

defaultFallbackInView(true); // or 'false'

You can also define the fallback locally on useInView or <InView> as an option. This will override the global fallback value.

import React from "react";
import { useInView } from "react-intersection-observer";

const Component = () => {
  const { ref, inView, entry } = useInView({
    fallbackInView: true,
  });

  return (
    <div ref={ref}>
      <h2>{`Header inside viewport ${inView}.`}</h2>
    </div>
  );
};

Polyfill

You can import the polyfill directly or use a service like https://cdnjs.cloudflare.com/polyfill to add it when needed.

yarn add intersection-observer

Then import it in your app:

import "intersection-observer";

If you are using Webpack (or similar) you could use dynamic imports, to load the Polyfill only if needed. A basic implementation could look something like this:

/**
 * Do feature detection, to figure out which polyfills needs to be imported.
 **/
async function loadPolyfills() {
  if (typeof window.IntersectionObserver === "undefined") {
    await import("intersection-observer");
  }
}

Low level API

You can access the observe method, that react-intersection-observer uses internally to create and destroy IntersectionObserver instances. This allows you to handle more advanced use cases, where you need full control over when and how observers are created.

import { observe } from "react-intersection-observer";

const destroy = observe(element, callback, options);

| Name | Type | Required | Description | | ------------ | -------------------------- | -------- | ---------------------------------------------------------- | | element | Element | true | DOM element to observe | | callback | ObserverInstanceCallback | true | The callback function that Intersection Observer will call | | options | IntersectionObserverInit | false | The options for the Intersection Observer |

The observe method returns an unobserve function, that you must call in order to destroy the observer again.

[!IMPORTANT] You most likely won't need this, but it can be useful if you need to handle IntersectionObservers outside React, or need full control over how instances are created.