react-modal vs react-modal-video vs react-responsive-modal
React Modal Libraries Comparison
Search packages..
1 Year
react-modalreact-modal-videoreact-responsive-modalSimilar Packages:
What's React Modal Libraries?

These libraries provide modal components for React applications, allowing developers to create interactive overlays that can display content, forms, or videos. They enhance user experience by providing a way to present information without navigating away from the current page. Each library has its unique features, design principles, and use cases, catering to different needs in modal implementation.

Package Weekly Downloads Trend
Github Stars Ranking
Stat Detail
Package
Downloads
Stars
Size
Issues
Publish
License
react-modal1,727,5017,397188 kB2002 months agoMIT
react-modal-video84,97818394.3 kB299 months agoMIT
react-responsive-modal49,480-170 kB-2 years agoMIT
Feature Comparison: react-modal vs react-modal-video vs react-responsive-modal

Customization

  • react-modal:

    react-modal offers extensive customization options, allowing developers to control every aspect of the modal's appearance and behavior. You can customize styles using CSS, manage animations, and even control the modal's lifecycle events, making it suitable for complex UI requirements.

  • react-modal-video:

    react-modal-video provides a straightforward API for displaying videos, but its customization options are more limited compared to react-modal. It focuses on video playback features, such as autoplay, loop, and controls, which can be easily configured but does not offer extensive styling options.

  • react-responsive-modal:

    react-responsive-modal emphasizes ease of use with a set of predefined styles and responsive behavior. While it allows some customization, it is primarily designed to be used out-of-the-box, making it less flexible than react-modal but more convenient for quick implementations.

Accessibility

  • react-modal:

    react-modal is built with accessibility in mind, adhering to ARIA standards to ensure that modals are usable by all users, including those using assistive technologies. It provides features like focus management and keyboard navigation, making it a strong choice for accessibility-focused applications.

  • react-modal-video:

    react-modal-video has basic accessibility features but may not be as comprehensive as react-modal. It provides essential keyboard navigation and focus management for video playback, but developers may need to implement additional accessibility features themselves.

  • react-responsive-modal:

    react-responsive-modal also includes accessibility features, ensuring that modals are navigable via keyboard and compatible with screen readers. It aims to provide a user-friendly experience for all users, though it may not be as robust as react-modal in this regard.

Responsive Design

  • react-modal:

    react-modal does not inherently provide responsive design features. Developers need to implement their own responsive styles to ensure the modal behaves well on different screen sizes, which can add complexity to the implementation.

  • react-modal-video:

    react-modal-video is designed to be responsive by default, automatically adjusting the modal size based on the viewport. This makes it an excellent choice for applications that need to display videos in a mobile-friendly manner without additional effort.

  • react-responsive-modal:

    react-responsive-modal is specifically designed for responsiveness, ensuring that modals adapt to various screen sizes and orientations. It provides a smooth user experience across devices, making it a preferred choice for mobile-first applications.

Ease of Use

  • react-modal:

    react-modal has a steeper learning curve due to its extensive customization options and flexibility. Developers may need to invest time in understanding its API and how to implement various features effectively, which can be a barrier for beginners.

  • react-modal-video:

    react-modal-video is very easy to use, with a simple API that allows developers to quickly implement video modals with minimal configuration. This makes it an excellent choice for projects that need to integrate video playback without extensive setup.

  • react-responsive-modal:

    react-responsive-modal is designed for quick and easy implementation, with a straightforward API and sensible defaults. It is user-friendly and allows developers to get modals up and running with minimal effort, making it ideal for rapid development.

Use Cases

  • react-modal:

    react-modal is versatile and can be used for various purposes, such as displaying forms, alerts, or any custom content. Its flexibility makes it suitable for applications that require complex modal interactions and detailed content presentation.

  • react-modal-video:

    react-modal-video is specifically tailored for video content, making it the best choice for applications that need to showcase videos, such as tutorials, advertisements, or media galleries. It simplifies the process of integrating video playback into modals.

  • react-responsive-modal:

    react-responsive-modal is ideal for applications that prioritize mobile responsiveness and user experience. It can be used for displaying notifications, forms, or any content that benefits from being presented in a modal format, especially in mobile environments.

How to Choose: react-modal vs react-modal-video vs react-responsive-modal
  • react-modal:

    Choose react-modal if you need a highly customizable modal component that integrates well with accessibility features and offers a wide range of options for styling and behavior. It is suitable for applications that require detailed control over modal presentation and interaction.

  • react-modal-video:

    Choose react-modal-video if your primary requirement is to display videos in a modal format. This library is specifically designed for video playback, providing a simple and effective way to implement video modals with minimal configuration.

  • react-responsive-modal:

    Choose react-responsive-modal if you need a responsive modal solution that works seamlessly across devices. It is ideal for applications that prioritize mobile responsiveness and user-friendly design, with built-in support for various modal types.

Similar Npm Packages to react-modal

react-modal is a popular library for creating accessible and customizable modal dialogs in React applications. It provides a straightforward way to manage modal visibility and behavior while ensuring compliance with accessibility standards. With its simple API, developers can easily integrate modals into their applications, enhancing user experience by presenting information or actions in a focused manner. While react-modal is a robust solution for modal management, there are alternatives that offer different approaches and features. Here are a few alternatives:

  • react-modal-hook is a lightweight library that builds on top of react-modal by providing a custom hook for managing modal state. This hook simplifies the process of opening and closing modals, allowing developers to easily integrate modals into their functional components without needing to manage state manually. If you prefer a hook-based approach and want to streamline modal management in your application, react-modal-hook is an excellent choice.
  • react-modal-promise is another alternative that focuses on handling modal dialogs with promises. It allows developers to create modals that can resolve or reject promises, making it easier to handle user interactions and decisions within the modal. This can be particularly useful for scenarios where you need to confirm actions or gather input from users before proceeding. If your application requires modals that interact with promises, react-modal-promise provides a clean and efficient solution.

To see how react-modal compares with react-modal-hook and react-modal-promise, check out the comparison: Comparing react-modal vs react-modal-hook vs react-modal-promise.

Similar Npm Packages to react-responsive-modal

react-responsive-modal is a flexible and customizable modal component for React applications. It allows developers to create responsive modals that can adapt to various screen sizes, making it a great choice for modern web applications. With features like animations, accessibility support, and easy integration, react-responsive-modal provides a straightforward way to implement modals in your projects.

While react-responsive-modal is a solid choice, there are other libraries that offer similar modal functionalities. Here are a few alternatives:

  • react-modal is a widely used modal library for React applications. It provides a simple and accessible way to create modals with a focus on usability and performance. react-modal is highly customizable and allows developers to control the modal's behavior and styling easily. If you need a reliable and straightforward modal solution with good accessibility features, react-modal is an excellent option.
  • react-modal-video is a specialized modal library designed specifically for displaying videos in a modal format. It supports various video sources, including YouTube and Vimeo, and provides a sleek and user-friendly interface for video playback. If your application requires a modal specifically for video content, react-modal-video is tailored for that purpose and offers a seamless experience for users.

To see how react-responsive-modal compares with react-modal and react-modal-video, check out the comparison: Comparing react-modal vs react-modal-video vs react-responsive-modal.

README for react-modal

react-modal

Accessible modal dialog component for React.JS

Build Status Coverage Status gzip size Join the chat at https://gitter.im/react-modal/Lobby

Table of Contents

Installation

To install, you can use npm or yarn:

$ npm install --save react-modal
$ yarn add react-modal

To install react-modal in React CDN app:

  • Add this CDN script tag after React CDN scripts and before your JS files (for example from cdnjs):

       <script src="https://cdnjs.cloudflare.com/ajax/libs/react-modal/3.14.3/react-modal.min.js"
   integrity="sha512-MY2jfK3DBnVzdS2V8MXo5lRtr0mNRroUI9hoLVv2/yL3vrJTam3VzASuKQ96fLEpyYIT4a8o7YgtUs5lPjiLVQ=="
   crossorigin="anonymous"
   referrerpolicy="no-referrer"></script>

  • Use <ReactModal> tag inside your React CDN app.

API documentation

The primary documentation for react-modal is the reference book, which describes the API and gives examples of its usage.

Examples

Here is a simple example of react-modal being used in an app with some custom styles and focusable input elements within the modal content:

import React from 'react';
import ReactDOM from 'react-dom';
import Modal from 'react-modal';

const customStyles = {
  content: {
    top: '50%',
    left: '50%',
    right: 'auto',
    bottom: 'auto',
    marginRight: '-50%',
    transform: 'translate(-50%, -50%)',
  },
};

// Make sure to bind modal to your appElement (https://reactcommunity.org/react-modal/accessibility/)
Modal.setAppElement('#yourAppElement');

function App() {
  let subtitle;
  const [modalIsOpen, setIsOpen] = React.useState(false);

  function openModal() {
    setIsOpen(true);
  }

  function afterOpenModal() {
    // references are now sync'd and can be accessed.
    subtitle.style.color = '#f00';
  }

  function closeModal() {
    setIsOpen(false);
  }

  return (
    <div>
      <button onClick={openModal}>Open Modal</button>
      <Modal
        isOpen={modalIsOpen}
        onAfterOpen={afterOpenModal}
        onRequestClose={closeModal}
        style={customStyles}
        contentLabel="Example Modal"
      >
        <h2 ref={(_subtitle) => (subtitle = _subtitle)}>Hello</h2>
        <button onClick={closeModal}>close</button>
        <div>I am a modal</div>
        <form>
          <input />
          <button>tab navigation</button>
          <button>stays</button>
          <button>inside</button>
          <button>the modal</button>
        </form>
      </Modal>
    </div>
  );
}

ReactDOM.render(<App />, appElement);

You can find more examples in the examples directory, which you can run in a local development server using npm start or yarn run start.

Demos

There are several demos hosted on CodePen which demonstrate various features of react-modal:

npm-compare.com is an independent website designed to help developers choose the most suitable npm packages. We are not affiliated with npm, Inc or npmjs.com, the official website for the npm registry. Please note that npm is a registered trademark of npm, Inc. For more details, please refer to our Terms & Privacy.