sudo-prompt vs sudo
Node.js Packages for Elevated Permissions Comparison
1 Year
sudo-promptsudo
What's Node.js Packages for Elevated Permissions?

Both 'sudo' and 'sudo-prompt' are Node.js packages that facilitate the execution of commands with elevated permissions, typically required for administrative tasks. 'sudo' allows for direct command execution with superuser privileges, while 'sudo-prompt' provides a user-friendly interface to prompt users for their password in a secure manner, enabling commands to run with elevated permissions without exposing sensitive information directly in the code.

Package Weekly Downloads Trend
Github Stars Ranking
Stat Detail
Package
Downloads
Stars
Size
Issues
Publish
License
sudo-prompt2,938,623487-285 years agoMIT
sudo23,81026-413 years ago-
Feature Comparison: sudo-prompt vs sudo

Command Execution

  • sudo-prompt:

    The 'sudo-prompt' package does not execute commands directly but instead prompts the user for their password to grant elevated permissions. It then allows you to run commands with those permissions, providing a more secure and user-friendly way to handle administrative tasks.

  • sudo:

    The 'sudo' package allows you to execute shell commands as a superuser directly from your Node.js application. It provides a simple API to run commands with elevated privileges, making it suitable for scripts that require administrative access to system resources.

User Interaction

  • sudo-prompt:

    'sudo-prompt' enhances user experience by providing a graphical prompt for password entry, ensuring that users can easily authenticate when elevated permissions are needed. This is particularly useful in desktop applications where user interaction is expected.

  • sudo:

    'sudo' operates without user interaction, meaning it requires the user to have appropriate permissions set up beforehand. This can lead to issues if the user does not have the necessary rights, as the command will fail without prompting for credentials.

Security

  • sudo-prompt:

    'sudo-prompt' improves security by isolating the password prompt from the application logic. It ensures that sensitive information is not hardcoded or exposed in the application, reducing the risk of credential leakage.

  • sudo:

    Using 'sudo' requires careful consideration of security implications, as executing commands with superuser privileges can expose the system to risks if not properly managed. Developers must ensure that only trusted commands are executed to prevent potential security vulnerabilities.

Platform Compatibility

  • sudo-prompt:

    'sudo-prompt' is designed to work across multiple platforms, including macOS and Windows. It adapts to the operating system's native authentication mechanisms, making it versatile for cross-platform applications.

  • sudo:

    The 'sudo' package is primarily designed for Unix-like operating systems where the sudo command is available. It may not function as intended on Windows systems, limiting its applicability across different environments.

Error Handling

  • sudo-prompt:

    'sudo-prompt' provides built-in error handling that captures authentication failures and command execution errors, allowing developers to handle user feedback more gracefully. This can enhance user experience by providing clear messages when issues arise.

  • sudo:

    Error handling in 'sudo' is straightforward; it returns an error if the command fails due to permission issues or other execution problems. Developers need to implement their own error handling logic to manage these scenarios effectively.

How to Choose: sudo-prompt vs sudo
  • sudo-prompt:

    Choose 'sudo-prompt' if you want to provide a more user-friendly experience by prompting users for their password in a secure dialog. This is ideal for applications that require user interaction for permission elevation, making it suitable for desktop applications.

  • sudo:

    Choose 'sudo' if you need to execute shell commands directly with superuser privileges and are comfortable managing permissions and security implications. It is straightforward for command execution but requires careful handling of user permissions.

README for sudo-prompt

sudo-prompt

Run a non-graphical terminal command using sudo, prompting the user with a graphical OS dialog if necessary. Useful for background Node.js applications or native Electron apps that need sudo.

Cross-Platform

sudo-prompt provides a native OS dialog prompt on macOS, Linux and Windows.

macOS

Linux

Windows

Installation

sudo-prompt has no external dependencies and does not require any native bindings.

npm install sudo-prompt

Usage

Note: Your command should not start with the sudo prefix.

var sudo = require('sudo-prompt');
var options = {
  name: 'Electron',
  icns: '/Applications/Electron.app/Contents/Resources/Electron.icns', // (optional)
};
sudo.exec('echo hello', options,
  function(error, stdout, stderr) {
    if (error) throw error;
    console.log('stdout: ' + stdout);
  }
);

sudo-prompt will use process.title as options.name if options.name is not provided. options.name must be alphanumeric only (spaces are supported) and at most 70 characters.

sudo-prompt will preserve the current working directory on all platforms. Environment variables can be set explicitly using options.env.

sudo-prompt.exec() is different to child-process.exec() in that no child process is returned (due to platform and permissions constraints).

Behavior

On macOS, sudo-prompt should behave just like the sudo command in the shell. If your command does not work with the sudo command in the shell (perhaps because it uses > redirection to a restricted file), then it may not work with sudo-prompt. However, it is still possible to use sudo-prompt to get a privileged shell, see this closed issue for more information.

On Linux, sudo-prompt will use either pkexec or kdesudo to show the password prompt and run your command. Where possible, sudo-prompt will try and get these to mimic sudo. Depending on which binary is used, and due to the limitations of some binaries, the name of your program or the command itself may be displayed to your user. sudo-prompt will not use gksudo since gksudo does not support concurrent prompts. Passing options.icns is currently not supported by sudo-prompt on Linux. Patches are welcome to add support for icons based on polkit.

On Windows, sudo-prompt will elevate your command using User Account Control (UAC). Passing options.name or options.icns is currently not supported by sudo-prompt on Windows.

Non-graphical terminal commands only

Just as you should never use sudo to launch any graphical applications, you should never use sudo-prompt to launch any graphical applications. Doing so could cause files in your home directory to become owned by root. sudo-prompt is explicitly designed to launch non-graphical terminal commands. For more information, read this post.

Concurrency

On systems where the user has opted to have tty-tickets enabled (most systems), each call to exec() will result in a separate password prompt. Where tty-tickets are disabled, subsequent calls to exec() will still require a password prompt, even where the user's sudo timestamp file remains valid, due to edge cases with sudo itself, see this discussion for more information.

You should never rely on sudo-prompt to execute your calls in order. If you need to enforce ordering of calls, then you should explicitly order your calls in your application. Where your commands are short-lived, you should always queue your calls to exec() to make sure your user is not overloaded with password prompts.

Invalidating the timestamp

On macOS and Linux, you can invalidate the user's sudo timestamp file to force the prompt to appear by running the following command in your terminal:

$ sudo -k