playwright vs puppeteer vs selenium-webdriver vs nightmare
Web 自动化测试库
playwrightpuppeteerselenium-webdrivernightmare类似的npm包:
Web 自动化测试库

Web 自动化测试库是用于模拟用户与网页交互的工具,帮助开发者进行端到端测试、爬虫和网页抓取。它们提供了丰富的 API 以便于控制浏览器行为,执行操作如点击、输入文本、导航等。这些库的主要目标是提高测试的效率和准确性,确保应用程序在不同环境下的表现一致。选择合适的库可以显著影响开发流程的效率和测试的可靠性。

npm下载趋势
3 年
GitHub Stars 排名
统计详情
npm包名称
下载量
Stars
大小
Issues
发布时间
License
playwright26,192,63280,3013.89 MB56823 天前Apache-2.0
puppeteer6,415,06293,08462.8 kB2949 小时前Apache-2.0
selenium-webdriver1,668,28833,78618.4 MB23112 天前Apache-2.0
nightmare10,09119,961-2037 年前MIT
功能对比: playwright vs puppeteer vs selenium-webdriver vs nightmare

浏览器支持

  • playwright:

    Playwright 支持多种浏览器,包括 Chromium、Firefox 和 WebKit,提供更广泛的测试覆盖,适合需要多浏览器支持的项目。

  • puppeteer:

    Puppeteer 专注于 Chromium,提供对 Chrome 和 Edge 的全面支持,适合需要深入控制这些浏览器的应用。

  • selenium-webdriver:

    Selenium WebDriver 支持几乎所有主流浏览器,包括 Chrome、Firefox、Safari 和 Edge,适合需要跨浏览器兼容性的项目。

  • nightmare:

    Nightmare 主要支持 Chromium,适合简单的自动化任务和网页抓取,但不支持 Firefox 或其他浏览器。

API 简洁性

  • playwright:

    Playwright 的 API 设计现代且强大,支持异步操作和自动等待,适合复杂的自动化需求。

  • puppeteer:

    Puppeteer 的 API 也相对简洁,提供了丰富的功能,适合需要复杂操作的开发者,但学习曲线稍陡。

  • selenium-webdriver:

    Selenium WebDriver 的 API 较为复杂,功能强大但需要更多的配置和学习,适合大型项目和专业开发者。

  • nightmare:

    Nightmare 提供了一个简单易用的 API,适合快速上手和小型项目,开发者可以快速编写自动化脚本。

性能

  • playwright:

    Playwright 通过并行处理和自动等待机制提供高性能,适合需要快速执行的测试。

  • puppeteer:

    Puppeteer 性能优越,特别是在处理复杂的网页操作时,能够快速响应。

  • selenium-webdriver:

    Selenium WebDriver 的性能依赖于具体的实现和配置,可能在某些情况下表现不如其他库。

  • nightmare:

    Nightmare 在处理简单任务时性能良好,但在复杂场景下可能会出现性能瓶颈。

社区支持

  • playwright:

    Playwright 拥有活跃的社区和频繁的更新,文档齐全,支持良好。

  • puppeteer:

    Puppeteer 拥有广泛的用户基础和活跃的社区,提供丰富的文档和示例。

  • selenium-webdriver:

    Selenium WebDriver 是最成熟的自动化测试工具之一,拥有庞大的社区支持和丰富的资源。

  • nightmare:

    Nightmare 的社区相对较小,更新频率较低,可能在遇到问题时缺乏支持。

学习曲线

  • playwright:

    Playwright 的学习曲线适中,提供了现代化的 API,适合有一定经验的开发者。

  • puppeteer:

    Puppeteer 的学习曲线稍陡,尤其是在处理复杂操作时,但提供了强大的功能。

  • selenium-webdriver:

    Selenium WebDriver 的学习曲线较陡,尤其是对于初学者来说,配置和使用可能需要更多时间。

  • nightmare:

    Nightmare 的学习曲线较平缓,适合初学者和快速原型开发。

如何选择: playwright vs puppeteer vs selenium-webdriver vs nightmare
  • playwright:

    选择 Playwright 如果你需要支持多种浏览器(包括 Chromium、Firefox 和 WebKit),并且需要强大的功能如自动等待、网络拦截和多页面处理。Playwright 适合需要高性能和灵活性的复杂应用。

  • puppeteer:

    选择 Puppeteer 如果你专注于 Chromium 浏览器的自动化,且需要强大的抓取和测试功能。Puppeteer 提供了丰富的 API,适合进行复杂的网页操作和性能测试。

  • selenium-webdriver:

    选择 Selenium WebDriver 如果你需要一个成熟且广泛支持的解决方案,能够与多种浏览器和编程语言兼容。它适合大型项目和需要跨浏览器测试的场景,但配置和学习曲线相对较高。

  • nightmare:

    选择 Nightmare 如果你需要一个简单易用的 API,适合快速原型开发和小型项目。它基于 Electron,适合进行快速的网页抓取和自动化任务,但在处理复杂场景时可能会受到限制。

playwright的README

🎭 Playwright

npm version Chromium version Firefox version WebKit version Join Discord

Documentation | API reference

Playwright is a framework for Web Testing and Automation. It allows testing Chromium, Firefox and WebKit with a single API. Playwright is built to enable cross-browser web automation that is ever-green, capable, reliable and fast.

LinuxmacOSWindows
Chromium 143.0.7499.4:white_check_mark::white_check_mark::white_check_mark:
WebKit 26.0:white_check_mark::white_check_mark::white_check_mark:
Firefox 144.0.2:white_check_mark::white_check_mark::white_check_mark:

Headless execution is supported for all browsers on all platforms. Check out system requirements for details.

Looking for Playwright for Python, .NET, or Java?

Installation

Playwright has its own test runner for end-to-end tests, we call it Playwright Test.

Using init command

The easiest way to get started with Playwright Test is to run the init command.

# Run from your project's root directory
npm init playwright@latest
# Or create a new project
npm init playwright@latest new-project

This will create a configuration file, optionally add examples, a GitHub Action workflow and a first test example.spec.ts. You can now jump directly to writing assertions section.

Manually

Add dependency and install browsers.

npm i -D @playwright/test
# install supported browsers
npx playwright install

You can optionally install only selected browsers, see install browsers for more details. Or you can install no browsers at all and use existing browser channels.

Capabilities

Resilient • No flaky tests

Auto-wait. Playwright waits for elements to be actionable prior to performing actions. It also has a rich set of introspection events. The combination of the two eliminates the need for artificial timeouts - a primary cause of flaky tests.

Web-first assertions. Playwright assertions are created specifically for the dynamic web. Checks are automatically retried until the necessary conditions are met.

Tracing. Configure test retry strategy, capture execution trace, videos and screenshots to eliminate flakes.

No trade-offs • No limits

Browsers run web content belonging to different origins in different processes. Playwright is aligned with the architecture of the modern browsers and runs tests out-of-process. This makes Playwright free of the typical in-process test runner limitations.

Multiple everything. Test scenarios that span multiple tabs, multiple origins and multiple users. Create scenarios with different contexts for different users and run them against your server, all in one test.

Trusted events. Hover elements, interact with dynamic controls and produce trusted events. Playwright uses real browser input pipeline indistinguishable from the real user.

Test frames, pierce Shadow DOM. Playwright selectors pierce shadow DOM and allow entering frames seamlessly.

Full isolation • Fast execution

Browser contexts. Playwright creates a browser context for each test. Browser context is equivalent to a brand new browser profile. This delivers full test isolation with zero overhead. Creating a new browser context only takes a handful of milliseconds.

Log in once. Save the authentication state of the context and reuse it in all the tests. This bypasses repetitive log-in operations in each test, yet delivers full isolation of independent tests.

Powerful Tooling

Codegen. Generate tests by recording your actions. Save them into any language.

Playwright inspector. Inspect page, generate selectors, step through the test execution, see click points and explore execution logs.

Trace Viewer. Capture all the information to investigate the test failure. Playwright trace contains test execution screencast, live DOM snapshots, action explorer, test source and many more.

Looking for Playwright for TypeScript, JavaScript, Python, .NET, or Java?

Examples

To learn how to run these Playwright Test examples, check out our getting started docs.

Page screenshot

This code snippet navigates to Playwright homepage and saves a screenshot.

import { test } from '@playwright/test';

test('Page Screenshot', async ({ page }) => {
  await page.goto('https://playwright.dev/');
  await page.screenshot({ path: `example.png` });
});

Mobile and geolocation

This snippet emulates Mobile Safari on a device at given geolocation, navigates to maps.google.com, performs the action and takes a screenshot.

import { test, devices } from '@playwright/test';

test.use({
  ...devices['iPhone 13 Pro'],
  locale: 'en-US',
  geolocation: { longitude: 12.492507, latitude: 41.889938 },
  permissions: ['geolocation'],
})

test('Mobile and geolocation', async ({ page }) => {
  await page.goto('https://maps.google.com');
  await page.getByText('Your location').click();
  await page.waitForRequest(/.*preview\/pwa/);
  await page.screenshot({ path: 'colosseum-iphone.png' });
});

Evaluate in browser context

This code snippet navigates to example.com, and executes a script in the page context.

import { test } from '@playwright/test';

test('Evaluate in browser context', async ({ page }) => {
  await page.goto('https://www.example.com/');
  const dimensions = await page.evaluate(() => {
    return {
      width: document.documentElement.clientWidth,
      height: document.documentElement.clientHeight,
      deviceScaleFactor: window.devicePixelRatio
    }
  });
  console.log(dimensions);
});

Intercept network requests

This code snippet sets up request routing for a page to log all network requests.

import { test } from '@playwright/test';

test('Intercept network requests', async ({ page }) => {
  // Log and continue all network requests
  await page.route('**', route => {
    console.log(route.request().url());
    route.continue();
  });
  await page.goto('http://todomvc.com');
});

Resources