Platform Support
- electron-builder:
electron-builder
supports packaging applications for multiple platforms, including Windows, macOS, and Linux. It provides a cross-platform solution, making it versatile for developers targeting multiple operating systems. - electron-packager:
electron-packager
is a cross-platform packaging tool that supports creating builds for Windows, macOS, and Linux. It allows developers to package their applications for multiple platforms from a single codebase. - electron-installer-debian:
electron-installer-debian
is specialized in creating.deb
packages for Debian-based systems. It is tailored for Linux packaging and does not support other operating systems. - @electron-forge/maker-deb:
@electron-forge/maker-deb
is focused on creating.deb
packages for Debian-based Linux distributions, such as Ubuntu. It is designed for Linux packaging and does not support Windows or macOS packaging.
Configuration Complexity
- electron-builder:
electron-builder
provides extensive configuration options, allowing for detailed customization of the packaging process. While it may have a steeper learning curve due to its complexity, it offers flexibility for large and complex projects. - electron-packager:
electron-packager
is known for its simplicity and ease of use. It requires minimal configuration to package applications, making it a great choice for quick and straightforward packaging tasks. - electron-installer-debian:
electron-installer-debian
allows for detailed configuration of Debian package properties, but it requires more manual setup compared to other tools. It is best suited for developers who need to customize the packaging process significantly. - @electron-forge/maker-deb:
@electron-forge/maker-deb
offers a simple configuration model that integrates with Electron Forge, making it easy to use for projects already set up with Forge. It requires minimal configuration to get started.
Auto-Update Support
- electron-builder:
electron-builder
has robust support for auto-updates, including integration with services like GitHub Releases and S3. It provides a complete solution for implementing automatic updates in Electron applications. - electron-packager:
electron-packager
does not provide auto-update support out of the box. Developers need to implement their own update mechanism or use a separate library. - electron-installer-debian:
electron-installer-debian
does not include auto-update functionality. It focuses on package creation rather than update management. - @electron-forge/maker-deb:
@electron-forge/maker-deb
does not provide built-in auto-update support. Developers need to implement their own update mechanism if required.
Code Signing
- electron-builder:
electron-builder
supports code signing for Windows and macOS applications. It provides built-in support for signing executables, which is essential for distributing applications on these platforms. - electron-packager:
electron-packager
does not handle code signing automatically. Developers need to implement code signing as part of their build process using external tools. - electron-installer-debian:
electron-installer-debian
does not provide code signing capabilities. Signing must be done manually or through external tools after the package is created. - @electron-forge/maker-deb:
@electron-forge/maker-deb
does not handle code signing for Debian packages. Developers need to sign their packages manually after creation if required.
Ease of Use: Code Examples
- electron-builder:
Package an Electron app with
electron-builder
electron-builder --linux
- electron-packager:
Package an Electron app with
electron-packager
electron-packager . MyApp --platform=win32 --arch=x64
- electron-installer-debian:
Create a Debian installer with
electron-installer-debian
node create-debian-installer.js
- @electron-forge/maker-deb:
Create a
.deb
package with@electron-forge/maker-deb
electron-forge make --platform=linux --arch=amd64