@testing-library/react vs @testing-library/vue vs @testing-library/svelte vs @testing-library/angular
Testing Libraries for Frontend Frameworks Comparison
3 Years
@testing-library/react@testing-library/vue@testing-library/svelte@testing-library/angularSimilar Packages:
What's Testing Libraries for Frontend Frameworks?

Testing libraries for frontend frameworks provide utilities to facilitate the testing of UI components in a way that resembles how users interact with them. These libraries promote best practices in testing by encouraging developers to write tests that focus on user behavior rather than implementation details. They help ensure that applications are robust and maintainable by providing a framework for writing unit and integration tests that can catch regressions and bugs early in the development process.

Package Weekly Downloads Trend
Github Stars Ranking
Stat Detail
Package
Downloads
Stars
Size
Issues
Publish
License
@testing-library/react16,198,834
19,389342 kB675 months agoMIT
@testing-library/vue453,347
1,11130.5 kB32a year agoMIT
@testing-library/svelte199,979
64748.5 kB64 months agoMIT
@testing-library/angular138,302
760209 kB10a month agoMIT
Feature Comparison: @testing-library/react vs @testing-library/vue vs @testing-library/svelte vs @testing-library/angular

User-Centric Testing

  • @testing-library/react:

    It emphasizes testing components as users would interact with them, using queries that reflect user behavior, such as finding elements by their text or label, which leads to more meaningful tests.

  • @testing-library/vue:

    It promotes user-centric testing by providing tools to query Vue components in a way that aligns with how users interact with the application, ensuring that tests are focused on user experience.

  • @testing-library/svelte:

    This library supports user-centric testing by allowing developers to write tests that simulate user interactions with Svelte components, ensuring that the components behave correctly in response to user actions.

  • @testing-library/angular:

    This library encourages tests that focus on how users interact with Angular components, promoting the use of queries that resemble how users find elements in the UI, such as by text content or role.

Integration with Frameworks

  • @testing-library/react:

    Works seamlessly with React's testing ecosystem, including Jest, enabling you to write tests that take advantage of React's component lifecycle and state management.

  • @testing-library/vue:

    Integrates with Vue's testing utilities, allowing you to utilize Vue's reactivity and lifecycle methods in your tests, making it easier to test complex Vue components.

  • @testing-library/svelte:

    Designed specifically for Svelte, it integrates with Svelte's reactive features, making it straightforward to test Svelte components without additional boilerplate.

  • @testing-library/angular:

    Integrates well with Angular's testing utilities, allowing you to leverage Angular's lifecycle hooks and testing features, making it easier to set up and tear down tests.

Simplicity and Ease of Use

  • @testing-library/react:

    Offers a straightforward API that is easy to learn and use, making it accessible for developers of all skill levels while promoting best practices in testing.

  • @testing-library/vue:

    Delivers a simple and intuitive API that allows developers to write tests quickly and efficiently, focusing on user interactions rather than implementation specifics.

  • @testing-library/svelte:

    Features a minimalistic API that aligns with Svelte's design philosophy, making it easy to write tests without unnecessary complexity.

  • @testing-library/angular:

    Provides a simple API that abstracts away complex testing setups, allowing developers to focus on writing meaningful tests without getting bogged down by implementation details.

Community and Ecosystem

  • @testing-library/react:

    Part of a larger ecosystem of testing libraries, it has a vast community that contributes to its development, ensuring it stays up-to-date with React's evolution.

  • @testing-library/vue:

    Supported by a growing community of Vue developers, it receives regular updates and improvements, ensuring compatibility with the latest Vue features.

  • @testing-library/svelte:

    Emerging community support as Svelte gains popularity, it is actively maintained and benefits from contributions that enhance its functionality.

  • @testing-library/angular:

    Backed by a strong community of Angular developers, it benefits from continuous updates and a wealth of resources, including documentation and examples.

Performance Considerations

  • @testing-library/react:

    Optimized for performance, it minimizes unnecessary re-renders during tests, allowing for fast feedback during the development process.

  • @testing-library/vue:

    Focuses on performance by utilizing Vue's reactivity system effectively, ensuring that tests are both fast and reliable.

  • @testing-library/svelte:

    Built with performance in mind, it leverages Svelte's compile-time optimizations to ensure tests execute efficiently without compromising on accuracy.

  • @testing-library/angular:

    Designed to minimize performance overhead during tests, it efficiently manages Angular's change detection and lifecycle, ensuring tests run quickly and reliably.

How to Choose: @testing-library/react vs @testing-library/vue vs @testing-library/svelte vs @testing-library/angular
  • @testing-library/react:

    Select this package for React applications. It is designed to work with React's component model and encourages testing from the user's perspective, making it ideal for ensuring that your components behave as expected in real-world scenarios.

  • @testing-library/vue:

    Use this package for Vue.js applications. It offers utilities that work well with Vue's reactivity system, enabling you to test Vue components in a way that mimics user behavior and interactions.

  • @testing-library/svelte:

    Opt for this package if you are developing with Svelte. It provides a simple API that aligns with Svelte's reactive paradigm, allowing you to test components effectively while maintaining Svelte's performance and simplicity.

  • @testing-library/angular:

    Choose this package if you are working with Angular applications. It integrates seamlessly with Angular's testing framework and provides utilities that leverage Angular's features, making it easier to test components, directives, and services in a way that reflects user interactions.

README for @testing-library/react

React Testing Library

goat

Simple and complete React DOM testing utilities that encourage good testing practices.


Read The Docs | Edit the docs



Build Status Code Coverage version downloads MIT License All Contributors PRs Welcome Code of Conduct Discord

Watch on GitHub Star on GitHub Tweet

Table of Contents

The problem

You want to write maintainable tests for your React components. As a part of this goal, you want your tests to avoid including implementation details of your components and rather focus on making your tests give you the confidence for which they are intended. As part of this, you want your testbase to be maintainable in the long run so refactors of your components (changes to implementation but not functionality) don't break your tests and slow you and your team down.

The solution

The React Testing Library is a very lightweight solution for testing React components. It provides light utility functions on top of react-dom and react-dom/test-utils, in a way that encourages better testing practices. Its primary guiding principle is:

The more your tests resemble the way your software is used, the more confidence they can give you.

Installation

This module is distributed via npm which is bundled with node and should be installed as one of your project's devDependencies.
Starting from RTL version 16, you'll also need to install @testing-library/dom:

npm install --save-dev @testing-library/react @testing-library/dom

or

for installation via yarn

yarn add --dev @testing-library/react @testing-library/dom

This library has peerDependencies listings for react, react-dom and starting from RTL version 16 also @testing-library/dom.

React Testing Library versions 13+ require React v18. If your project uses an older version of React, be sure to install version 12:

npm install --save-dev @testing-library/react@12


yarn add --dev @testing-library/react@12

You may also be interested in installing @testing-library/jest-dom so you can use the custom jest matchers.

Docs

Suppressing unnecessary warnings on React DOM 16.8

There is a known compatibility issue with React DOM 16.8 where you will see the following warning:

Warning: An update to ComponentName inside a test was not wrapped in act(...).

If you cannot upgrade to React DOM 16.9, you may suppress the warnings by adding the following snippet to your test configuration (learn more):

// this is just a little hack to silence a warning that we'll get until we
// upgrade to 16.9. See also: https://github.com/facebook/react/pull/14853
const originalError = console.error
beforeAll(() => {
  console.error = (...args) => {
    if (/Warning.*not wrapped in act/.test(args[0])) {
      return
    }
    originalError.call(console, ...args)
  }
})

afterAll(() => {
  console.error = originalError
})

Examples

Basic Example

// hidden-message.js
import * as React from 'react'

// NOTE: React Testing Library works well with React Hooks and classes.
// Your tests will be the same regardless of how you write your components.
function HiddenMessage({children}) {
  const [showMessage, setShowMessage] = React.useState(false)
  return (
    <div>
      <label htmlFor="toggle">Show Message</label>
      <input
        id="toggle"
        type="checkbox"
        onChange={e => setShowMessage(e.target.checked)}
        checked={showMessage}
      />
      {showMessage ? children : null}
    </div>
  )
}

export default HiddenMessage
// __tests__/hidden-message.js
// these imports are something you'd normally configure Jest to import for you
// automatically. Learn more in the setup docs: https://testing-library.com/docs/react-testing-library/setup#cleanup
import '@testing-library/jest-dom'
// NOTE: jest-dom adds handy assertions to Jest and is recommended, but not required

import * as React from 'react'
import {render, fireEvent, screen} from '@testing-library/react'
import HiddenMessage from '../hidden-message'

test('shows the children when the checkbox is checked', () => {
  const testMessage = 'Test Message'
  render(<HiddenMessage>{testMessage}</HiddenMessage>)

  // query* functions will return the element or null if it cannot be found
  // get* functions will return the element or throw an error if it cannot be found
  expect(screen.queryByText(testMessage)).toBeNull()

  // the queries can accept a regex to make your selectors more resilient to content tweaks and changes.
  fireEvent.click(screen.getByLabelText(/show/i))

  // .toBeInTheDocument() is an assertion that comes from jest-dom
  // otherwise you could use .toBeDefined()
  expect(screen.getByText(testMessage)).toBeInTheDocument()
})

Complex Example

// login.js
import * as React from 'react'

function Login() {
  const [state, setState] = React.useReducer((s, a) => ({...s, ...a}), {
    resolved: false,
    loading: false,
    error: null,
  })

  function handleSubmit(event) {
    event.preventDefault()
    const {usernameInput, passwordInput} = event.target.elements

    setState({loading: true, resolved: false, error: null})

    window
      .fetch('/api/login', {
        method: 'POST',
        headers: {'Content-Type': 'application/json'},
        body: JSON.stringify({
          username: usernameInput.value,
          password: passwordInput.value,
        }),
      })
      .then(r => r.json().then(data => (r.ok ? data : Promise.reject(data))))
      .then(
        user => {
          setState({loading: false, resolved: true, error: null})
          window.localStorage.setItem('token', user.token)
        },
        error => {
          setState({loading: false, resolved: false, error: error.message})
        },
      )
  }

  return (
    <div>
      <form onSubmit={handleSubmit}>
        <div>
          <label htmlFor="usernameInput">Username</label>
          <input id="usernameInput" />
        </div>
        <div>
          <label htmlFor="passwordInput">Password</label>
          <input id="passwordInput" type="password" />
        </div>
        <button type="submit">Submit{state.loading ? '...' : null}</button>
      </form>
      {state.error ? <div role="alert">{state.error}</div> : null}
      {state.resolved ? (
        <div role="alert">Congrats! You're signed in!</div>
      ) : null}
    </div>
  )
}

export default Login
// __tests__/login.js
// again, these first two imports are something you'd normally handle in
// your testing framework configuration rather than importing them in every file.
import '@testing-library/jest-dom'
import * as React from 'react'
// import API mocking utilities from Mock Service Worker.
import {rest} from 'msw'
import {setupServer} from 'msw/node'
// import testing utilities
import {render, fireEvent, screen} from '@testing-library/react'
import Login from '../login'

const fakeUserResponse = {token: 'fake_user_token'}
const server = setupServer(
  rest.post('/api/login', (req, res, ctx) => {
    return res(ctx.json(fakeUserResponse))
  }),
)

beforeAll(() => server.listen())
afterEach(() => {
  server.resetHandlers()
  window.localStorage.removeItem('token')
})
afterAll(() => server.close())

test('allows the user to login successfully', async () => {
  render(<Login />)

  // fill out the form
  fireEvent.change(screen.getByLabelText(/username/i), {
    target: {value: 'chuck'},
  })
  fireEvent.change(screen.getByLabelText(/password/i), {
    target: {value: 'norris'},
  })

  fireEvent.click(screen.getByText(/submit/i))

  // just like a manual tester, we'll instruct our test to wait for the alert
  // to show up before continuing with our assertions.
  const alert = await screen.findByRole('alert')

  // .toHaveTextContent() comes from jest-dom's assertions
  // otherwise you could use expect(alert.textContent).toMatch(/congrats/i)
  // but jest-dom will give you better error messages which is why it's recommended
  expect(alert).toHaveTextContent(/congrats/i)
  expect(window.localStorage.getItem('token')).toEqual(fakeUserResponse.token)
})

test('handles server exceptions', async () => {
  // mock the server error response for this test suite only.
  server.use(
    rest.post('/api/login', (req, res, ctx) => {
      return res(ctx.status(500), ctx.json({message: 'Internal server error'}))
    }),
  )

  render(<Login />)

  // fill out the form
  fireEvent.change(screen.getByLabelText(/username/i), {
    target: {value: 'chuck'},
  })
  fireEvent.change(screen.getByLabelText(/password/i), {
    target: {value: 'norris'},
  })

  fireEvent.click(screen.getByText(/submit/i))

  // wait for the error message
  const alert = await screen.findByRole('alert')

  expect(alert).toHaveTextContent(/internal server error/i)
  expect(window.localStorage.getItem('token')).toBeNull()
})

We recommend using Mock Service Worker library to declaratively mock API communication in your tests instead of stubbing window.fetch, or relying on third-party adapters.

More Examples

We're in the process of moving examples to the docs site

You'll find runnable examples of testing with different libraries in the react-testing-library-examples codesandbox. Some included are:

Hooks

If you are interested in testing a custom hook, check out React Hooks Testing Library.

NOTE: it is not recommended to test single-use custom hooks in isolation from the components where it's being used. It's better to test the component that's using the hook rather than the hook itself. The React Hooks Testing Library is intended to be used for reusable hooks/libraries.

Guiding Principles

The more your tests resemble the way your software is used, the more confidence they can give you.

We try to only expose methods and utilities that encourage you to write tests that closely resemble how your React components are used.

Utilities are included in this project based on the following guiding principles:

  1. If it relates to rendering components, it deals with DOM nodes rather than component instances, nor should it encourage dealing with component instances.
  2. It should be generally useful for testing individual React components or full React applications. While this library is focused on react-dom, utilities could be included even if they don't directly relate to react-dom.
  3. Utility implementations and APIs should be simple and flexible.

Most importantly, we want React Testing Library to be pretty light-weight, simple, and easy to understand.

Docs

Read The Docs | Edit the docs

Issues

Looking to contribute? Look for the Good First Issue label.

🐛 Bugs

Please file an issue for bugs, missing documentation, or unexpected behavior.

See Bugs

💡 Feature Requests

Please file an issue to suggest new features. Vote on feature requests by adding a 👍. This helps maintainers prioritize what to work on.

See Feature Requests

❓ Questions

For questions related to using the library, please visit a support community instead of filing an issue on GitHub.

Contributors

Thanks goes to these people (emoji key):

Kent C. Dodds
Kent C. Dodds

💻 📖 🚇 ⚠️
Ryan Castner
Ryan Castner

📖
Daniel Sandiego
Daniel Sandiego

💻
Paweł Mikołajczyk
Paweł Mikołajczyk

💻
Alejandro Ñáñez Ortiz
Alejandro Ñáñez Ortiz

📖
Matt Parrish
Matt Parrish

🐛 💻 📖 ⚠️
Justin Hall
Justin Hall

📦
Anto Aravinth
Anto Aravinth

💻 ⚠️ 📖
Jonah Moses
Jonah Moses

📖
Łukasz Gandecki
Łukasz Gandecki

💻 ⚠️ 📖
Ivan Babak
Ivan Babak

🐛 🤔
Jesse Day
Jesse Day

💻
Ernesto García
Ernesto García

💬 💻 📖
Josef Maxx Blake
Josef Maxx Blake

💻 📖 ⚠️
Michal Baranowski
Michal Baranowski

📝
Arthur Puthin
Arthur Puthin

📖
Thomas Chia
Thomas Chia

💻 📖
Thiago Galvani
Thiago Galvani

📖
Christian
Christian

⚠️
Alex Krolick
Alex Krolick

💬 📖 💡 🤔
Johann Hubert Sonntagbauer
Johann Hubert Sonntagbauer

💻 📖 ⚠️
Maddi Joyce
Maddi Joyce

💻
Ryan Vice
Ryan Vice

📖
Ian Wilson
Ian Wilson

📝
Daniel
Daniel

🐛 💻
Giorgio Polvara
Giorgio Polvara

🐛 🤔
John Gozde
John Gozde

💻
Sam Horton
Sam Horton

📖 💡 🤔
Richard Kotze (mobile)
Richard Kotze (mobile)

📖
Brahian E. Soto Mercedes
Brahian E. Soto Mercedes

📖
Benoit de La Forest
Benoit de La Forest

📖
Salah
Salah

💻 ⚠️
Adam Gordon
Adam Gordon

🐛 💻
Matija Marohnić
Matija Marohnić

📖
Justice Mba
Justice Mba

📖
Mark Pollmann
Mark Pollmann

📖
Ehtesham Kafeel
Ehtesham Kafeel

💻 📖
Julio Pavón
Julio Pavón

💻
Duncan L
Duncan L

📖 💡
Tiago Almeida
Tiago Almeida

📖
Robert Smith
Robert Smith

🐛
Zach Green
Zach Green

📖
dadamssg
dadamssg

📖
Yazan Aabed
Yazan Aabed

📝
Tim
Tim

🐛 💻 📖 ⚠️
Divyanshu Maithani
Divyanshu Maithani

📹
Deepak Grover
Deepak Grover

📹
Eyal Cohen
Eyal Cohen

📖
Peter Makowski
Peter Makowski

📖
Michiel Nuyts
Michiel Nuyts

📖
Joe Ng'ethe
Joe Ng'ethe

💻 📖
Kate
Kate

📖
Sean
Sean

📖
James Long
James Long

🤔 📦
Herb Hagely
Herb Hagely

💡
Alex Wendte
Alex Wendte

💡
Monica Powell
Monica Powell

📖
Vitaly Sivkov
Vitaly Sivkov

💻
Weyert de Boer
Weyert de Boer

🤔 👀 🎨
EstebanMarin
EstebanMarin

📖
Victor Martins
Victor Martins

📖
Royston Shufflebotham
Royston Shufflebotham

🐛 📖 💡
chrbala
chrbala

💻
Donavon West
Donavon West

💻 📖 🤔 ⚠️
Richard Maisano
Richard Maisano

💻
Marco Biedermann
Marco Biedermann

💻 🚧 ⚠️
Alex Zherdev
Alex Zherdev

🐛 💻
André Matulionis dos Santos
André Matulionis dos Santos

💻 💡 ⚠️
Daniel K.
Daniel K.

🐛 💻 🤔 ⚠️ 👀
mohamedmagdy17593
mohamedmagdy17593

💻
Loren ☺️
Loren ☺️

📖
MarkFalconbridge
MarkFalconbridge

🐛 💻
Vinicius
Vinicius

📖 💡
Peter Schyma
Peter Schyma

💻
Ian Schmitz
Ian Schmitz

📖
Joel Marcotte
Joel Marcotte

🐛 ⚠️ 💻
Alejandro Dustet
Alejandro Dustet

🐛
Brandon Carroll
Brandon Carroll

📖
Lucas Machado
Lucas Machado

📖
Pascal Duez
Pascal Duez

📦
Minh Nguyen
Minh Nguyen

💻
LiaoJimmy
LiaoJimmy

📖
Sunil Pai
Sunil Pai

💻 ⚠️
Dan Abramov
Dan Abramov

👀
Christian Murphy
Christian Murphy

🚇
Ivakhnenko Dmitry
Ivakhnenko Dmitry

💻
James George
James George

📖
João Fernandes
João Fernandes

📖
Alejandro Perea
Alejandro Perea

👀
Nick McCurdy
Nick McCurdy

👀 💬 🚇
Sebastian Silbermann
Sebastian Silbermann

👀
Adrià Fontcuberta
Adrià Fontcuberta

👀 📖
John Reilly
John Reilly

👀
Michaël De Boey
Michaël De Boey

👀 💻
Tim Yates
Tim Yates

👀
Brian Donovan
Brian Donovan

💻
Noam Gabriel Jacobson
Noam Gabriel Jacobson

📖
Ronald van der Kooij
Ronald van der Kooij

⚠️ 💻
Aayush Rajvanshi
Aayush Rajvanshi

📖
Ely Alamillo
Ely Alamillo

💻 ⚠️
Daniel Afonso
Daniel Afonso

💻 ⚠️
Laurens Bosscher
Laurens Bosscher

💻
Sakito Mukai
Sakito Mukai

📖
Türker Teke
Türker Teke

📖
Zach Brogan
Zach Brogan

💻 ⚠️
Ryota Murakami
Ryota Murakami

📖
Michael Hottman
Michael Hottman

🤔
Steven Fitzpatrick
Steven Fitzpatrick

🐛
Juan Je García
Juan Je García

📖
Championrunner
Championrunner

📖
Sam Tsai
Sam Tsai

💻 ⚠️ 📖
Christian Rackerseder
Christian Rackerseder

💻
Andrei Picus
Andrei Picus

🐛 👀
Artem Zakharchenko
Artem Zakharchenko

📖
Michael
Michael

📖
Braden Lee
Braden Lee

📖
Kamran Ayub
Kamran Ayub

💻 ⚠️
Matan Borenkraout
Matan Borenkraout

💻
Ryan Bigg
Ryan Bigg

🚧
Anton Halim
Anton Halim

📖
Artem Malko
Artem Malko

💻
Gerrit Alex
Gerrit Alex

💻
Karthick Raja
Karthick Raja

💻
Abdelrahman Ashraf
Abdelrahman Ashraf

💻
Lidor Avitan
Lidor Avitan

📖
Jordan Harband
Jordan Harband

👀 🤔
Marco Moretti
Marco Moretti

💻
sanchit121
sanchit121

🐛 💻
Solufa
Solufa

🐛 💻
Ari Perkkiö
Ari Perkkiö

⚠️
Johannes Ewald
Johannes Ewald

💻
Angus J. Pope
Angus J. Pope

📖
Dominik Lesch
Dominik Lesch

📖
Marcos Gómez
Marcos Gómez

📖
Akash Shyam
Akash Shyam

🐛
Fabian Meumertzheim
Fabian Meumertzheim

💻 🐛
Sebastian Malton
Sebastian Malton

🐛 💻
Martin Böttcher
Martin Böttcher

💻
Dominik Dorfmeister
Dominik Dorfmeister

💻
Stephen Sauceda
Stephen Sauceda

📖
Colin Diesh
Colin Diesh

📖
Yusuke Iinuma
Yusuke Iinuma

💻
Jeff Way
Jeff Way

💻
Bernardo Belchior
Bernardo Belchior

💻 📖

This project follows the all-contributors specification. Contributions of any kind welcome!

LICENSE

MIT