sax vs htmlparser2 vs xml2js vs cheerio
HTML and XML Parsing Libraries Comparison
1 Year
saxhtmlparser2xml2jscheerioSimilar Packages:
What's HTML and XML Parsing Libraries?

HTML and XML parsing libraries are essential tools in web development for extracting and manipulating data from web pages and structured documents. These libraries provide developers with the ability to parse, traverse, and manipulate HTML and XML content efficiently. They are particularly useful for web scraping, data extraction, and transforming documents into usable formats. Each library has its unique strengths and use cases, making it crucial to choose the right one based on project requirements.

Package Weekly Downloads Trend
Github Stars Ranking
Stat Detail
Package
Downloads
Stars
Size
Issues
Publish
License
sax37,702,2401,10156 kB999 months agoISC
htmlparser235,752,2634,532489 kB182 months agoMIT
xml2js22,914,7574,9153.44 MB2462 years agoMIT
cheerio9,953,05229,1201.25 MB387 months agoMIT
Feature Comparison: sax vs htmlparser2 vs xml2js vs cheerio

Parsing Methodology

  • sax:

    SAX (Simple API for XML) is an event-driven, streaming parser that reads XML documents sequentially. It does not build a tree structure, making it memory efficient and suitable for large XML files. It emits events for each element, allowing for immediate processing of data as it is encountered.

  • htmlparser2:

    htmlparser2 operates as a low-level parser that can handle both HTML and XML. It provides a streaming interface, allowing developers to process data as it is parsed, which is beneficial for handling large documents or when immediate processing is required.

  • xml2js:

    xml2js converts XML into JavaScript objects, allowing developers to work with XML data in a more natural way. It parses the entire XML document into an object structure, making it easy to access and manipulate data, but it may consume more memory compared to streaming parsers.

  • cheerio:

    Cheerio uses a jQuery-like syntax to manipulate the DOM, making it intuitive for developers familiar with jQuery. It loads HTML into memory and allows for easy traversal and manipulation, but it does not create a full DOM tree, which makes it faster for certain tasks.

Performance

  • sax:

    SAX is highly efficient for large XML files due to its streaming nature. It processes data on-the-fly, which minimizes memory usage and allows for handling very large documents without significant performance degradation.

  • htmlparser2:

    htmlparser2 is designed for high performance and can handle large documents efficiently. Its streaming capabilities allow it to parse data in chunks, reducing memory overhead and improving performance for large-scale parsing tasks.

  • xml2js:

    xml2js is less performant for large XML documents compared to streaming parsers because it loads the entire document into memory. However, it excels in scenarios where ease of use and quick access to data are more critical than raw performance.

  • cheerio:

    Cheerio is optimized for speed and is particularly efficient for parsing and manipulating small to medium-sized HTML documents. It is not as performant as lower-level parsers for large documents, but its ease of use often outweighs this drawback for many applications.

Error Handling

  • sax:

    SAX provides minimal error handling, as it is focused on streaming and efficiency. Developers need to implement their own error handling logic to manage parsing errors, which can be a drawback in some use cases.

  • htmlparser2:

    htmlparser2 is robust in handling malformed HTML and XML. It is designed to be forgiving, allowing developers to parse documents that do not conform to strict standards without crashing, making it suitable for web scraping.

  • xml2js:

    xml2js offers some error handling capabilities, but it may not be as forgiving as htmlparser2. It can throw errors when encountering unexpected XML structures, requiring developers to ensure their XML is well-formed.

  • cheerio:

    Cheerio does not perform extensive error handling for malformed HTML, as it is designed to be forgiving and can work with imperfect markup. However, it may not provide detailed error messages, which can make debugging more challenging in complex scenarios.

Use Cases

  • sax:

    SAX is perfect for applications that need to process large XML files or streams of XML data in a memory-efficient manner. It is commonly used in scenarios where real-time processing of XML data is required, such as in data feeds or APIs.

  • htmlparser2:

    htmlparser2 is a versatile parser that can be used for both HTML and XML parsing. It is suitable for applications that need to handle a variety of document types, especially when performance is a concern.

  • xml2js:

    xml2js is ideal for applications that frequently interact with XML data and require a straightforward way to convert XML into JavaScript objects. It is commonly used in scenarios where XML data needs to be integrated into JavaScript applications seamlessly.

  • cheerio:

    Cheerio is best suited for web scraping and server-side DOM manipulation tasks where developers want to leverage jQuery-like syntax. It is ideal for projects that require quick data extraction and manipulation from HTML documents.

Learning Curve

  • sax:

    SAX has a steeper learning curve as it requires understanding event-driven programming and managing state across events. This can be challenging for developers who are not accustomed to this paradigm.

  • htmlparser2:

    htmlparser2 has a moderate learning curve due to its low-level API and streaming nature. Developers may need to familiarize themselves with event-driven programming to use it effectively, which can be a barrier for beginners.

  • xml2js:

    xml2js is relatively easy to learn, especially for developers already familiar with JavaScript objects. Its straightforward API allows for quick integration and manipulation of XML data, making it accessible for most developers.

  • cheerio:

    Cheerio has a gentle learning curve, especially for developers familiar with jQuery. Its syntax and methods are intuitive, making it easy to pick up and use effectively for DOM manipulation tasks.

How to Choose: sax vs htmlparser2 vs xml2js vs cheerio
  • sax:

    Opt for sax if you need a streaming XML parser that is lightweight and efficient. It is perfect for processing large XML files in a memory-efficient manner, as it emits events as it parses the document, allowing for real-time processing without loading the entire document into memory.

  • htmlparser2:

    Select htmlparser2 when you require a fast, forgiving HTML and XML parser that can handle malformed markup. It is suitable for scenarios where performance is critical and you need to parse large documents efficiently without the overhead of a full DOM.

  • xml2js:

    Use xml2js when you need to convert XML data into JavaScript objects easily. It is particularly useful for applications that require seamless integration of XML data into JavaScript environments, allowing for straightforward manipulation and access to XML data.

  • cheerio:

    Choose Cheerio if you need a fast and flexible library for server-side jQuery-like manipulation of HTML documents. It is ideal for web scraping and allows you to use familiar jQuery syntax to traverse and manipulate the DOM.

README for sax

sax js

A sax-style parser for XML and HTML.

Designed with node in mind, but should work fine in the browser or other CommonJS implementations.

What This Is

  • A very simple tool to parse through an XML string.
  • A stepping stone to a streaming HTML parser.
  • A handy way to deal with RSS and other mostly-ok-but-kinda-broken XML docs.

What This Is (probably) Not

  • An HTML Parser - That's a fine goal, but this isn't it. It's just XML.
  • A DOM Builder - You can use it to build an object model out of XML, but it doesn't do that out of the box.
  • XSLT - No DOM = no querying.
  • 100% Compliant with (some other SAX implementation) - Most SAX implementations are in Java and do a lot more than this does.
  • An XML Validator - It does a little validation when in strict mode, but not much.
  • A Schema-Aware XSD Thing - Schemas are an exercise in fetishistic masochism.
  • A DTD-aware Thing - Fetching DTDs is a much bigger job.

Regarding <!DOCTYPEs and <!ENTITYs

The parser will handle the basic XML entities in text nodes and attribute values: &amp; &lt; &gt; &apos; &quot;. It's possible to define additional entities in XML by putting them in the DTD. This parser doesn't do anything with that. If you want to listen to the ondoctype event, and then fetch the doctypes, and read the entities and add them to parser.ENTITIES, then be my guest.

Unknown entities will fail in strict mode, and in loose mode, will pass through unmolested.

Usage

var sax = require("./lib/sax"),
  strict = true, // set to false for html-mode
  parser = sax.parser(strict);

parser.onerror = function (e) {
  // an error happened.
};
parser.ontext = function (t) {
  // got some text.  t is the string of text.
};
parser.onopentag = function (node) {
  // opened a tag.  node has "name" and "attributes"
};
parser.onattribute = function (attr) {
  // an attribute.  attr has "name" and "value"
};
parser.onend = function () {
  // parser stream is done, and ready to have more stuff written to it.
};

parser.write('<xml>Hello, <who name="world">world</who>!</xml>').close();

// stream usage
// takes the same options as the parser
var saxStream = require("sax").createStream(strict, options)
saxStream.on("error", function (e) {
  // unhandled errors will throw, since this is a proper node
  // event emitter.
  console.error("error!", e)
  // clear the error
  this._parser.error = null
  this._parser.resume()
})
saxStream.on("opentag", function (node) {
  // same object as above
})
// pipe is supported, and it's readable/writable
// same chunks coming in also go out.
fs.createReadStream("file.xml")
  .pipe(saxStream)
  .pipe(fs.createWriteStream("file-copy.xml"))

Arguments

Pass the following arguments to the parser function. All are optional.

strict - Boolean. Whether or not to be a jerk. Default: false.

opt - Object bag of settings regarding string formatting. All default to false.

Settings supported:

  • trim - Boolean. Whether or not to trim text and comment nodes.
  • normalize - Boolean. If true, then turn any whitespace into a single space.
  • lowercase - Boolean. If true, then lowercase tag names and attribute names in loose mode, rather than uppercasing them.
  • xmlns - Boolean. If true, then namespaces are supported.
  • position - Boolean. If false, then don't track line/col/position.
  • strictEntities - Boolean. If true, only parse predefined XML entities (&amp;, &apos;, &gt;, &lt;, and &quot;)
  • unquotedAttributeValues - Boolean. If true, then unquoted attribute values are allowed. Defaults to false when strict is true, true otherwise.

Methods

write - Write bytes onto the stream. You don't have to do this all at once. You can keep writing as much as you want.

close - Close the stream. Once closed, no more data may be written until it is done processing the buffer, which is signaled by the end event.

resume - To gracefully handle errors, assign a listener to the error event. Then, when the error is taken care of, you can call resume to continue parsing. Otherwise, the parser will not continue while in an error state.

Members

At all times, the parser object will have the following members:

line, column, position - Indications of the position in the XML document where the parser currently is looking.

startTagPosition - Indicates the position where the current tag starts.

closed - Boolean indicating whether or not the parser can be written to. If it's true, then wait for the ready event to write again.

strict - Boolean indicating whether or not the parser is a jerk.

opt - Any options passed into the constructor.

tag - The current tag being dealt with.

And a bunch of other stuff that you probably shouldn't touch.

Events

All events emit with a single argument. To listen to an event, assign a function to on<eventname>. Functions get executed in the this-context of the parser object. The list of supported events are also in the exported EVENTS array.

When using the stream interface, assign handlers using the EventEmitter on function in the normal fashion.

error - Indication that something bad happened. The error will be hanging out on parser.error, and must be deleted before parsing can continue. By listening to this event, you can keep an eye on that kind of stuff. Note: this happens much more in strict mode. Argument: instance of Error.

text - Text node. Argument: string of text.

doctype - The <!DOCTYPE declaration. Argument: doctype string.

processinginstruction - Stuff like <?xml foo="blerg" ?>. Argument: object with name and body members. Attributes are not parsed, as processing instructions have implementation dependent semantics.

sgmldeclaration - Random SGML declarations. Stuff like <!ENTITY p> would trigger this kind of event. This is a weird thing to support, so it might go away at some point. SAX isn't intended to be used to parse SGML, after all.

opentagstart - Emitted immediately when the tag name is available, but before any attributes are encountered. Argument: object with a name field and an empty attributes set. Note that this is the same object that will later be emitted in the opentag event.

opentag - An opening tag. Argument: object with name and attributes. In non-strict mode, tag names are uppercased, unless the lowercase option is set. If the xmlns option is set, then it will contain namespace binding information on the ns member, and will have a local, prefix, and uri member.

closetag - A closing tag. In loose mode, tags are auto-closed if their parent closes. In strict mode, well-formedness is enforced. Note that self-closing tags will have closeTag emitted immediately after openTag. Argument: tag name.

attribute - An attribute node. Argument: object with name and value. In non-strict mode, attribute names are uppercased, unless the lowercase option is set. If the xmlns option is set, it will also contains namespace information.

comment - A comment node. Argument: the string of the comment.

opencdata - The opening tag of a <![CDATA[ block.

cdata - The text of a <![CDATA[ block. Since <![CDATA[ blocks can get quite large, this event may fire multiple times for a single block, if it is broken up into multiple write()s. Argument: the string of random character data.

closecdata - The closing tag (]]>) of a <![CDATA[ block.

opennamespace - If the xmlns option is set, then this event will signal the start of a new namespace binding.

closenamespace - If the xmlns option is set, then this event will signal the end of a namespace binding.

end - Indication that the closed stream has ended.

ready - Indication that the stream has reset, and is ready to be written to.

noscript - In non-strict mode, <script> tags trigger a "script" event, and their contents are not checked for special xml characters. If you pass noscript: true, then this behavior is suppressed.

Reporting Problems

It's best to write a failing test if you find an issue. I will always accept pull requests with failing tests if they demonstrate intended behavior, but it is very hard to figure out what issue you're describing without a test. Writing a test is also the best way for you yourself to figure out if you really understand the issue you think you have with sax-js.