cross-spawn vs execa vs spawn-sync
Process Management in Node.js Comparison
Search packages..
1 Year
cross-spawnexecaspawn-syncSimilar Packages:
What's Process Management in Node.js?

Process management libraries in Node.js provide tools for spawning and managing child processes from within a Node.js application. These libraries allow developers to execute external commands, scripts, or binaries, handle their input/output streams, and manage their execution in a non-blocking or synchronous manner. This is particularly useful for tasks like running shell commands, automating scripts, or integrating with other system-level processes. Each library offers different features and APIs to cater to various use cases, such as handling complex command execution, managing process lifecycles, and providing better error handling and performance.

Package Weekly Downloads Trend
Github Stars Ranking
Stat Detail
Package
Downloads
Stars
Size
Issues
Publish
License
cross-spawn97,455,7021,14416.1 kB266 months agoMIT
execa93,277,4537,149324 kB143 days agoMIT
spawn-sync1,076,42236-07 years agoMIT
Feature Comparison: cross-spawn vs execa vs spawn-sync

Cross-Platform Compatibility

  • cross-spawn:

    cross-spawn is designed to handle cross-platform compatibility issues when spawning child processes. It correctly handles the execution of commands on Windows, macOS, and Linux, ensuring that arguments are passed correctly regardless of the operating system.

  • execa:

    execa also provides good cross-platform compatibility, but it is built on top of the native child_process module, which means it inherits some of its quirks. However, execa offers a more modern API and better handles edge cases, making it a reliable choice for cross-platform applications.

  • spawn-sync:

    spawn-sync is a synchronous wrapper around the native child_process module. While it is cross-platform in nature, it does not provide any additional features or handling for cross-platform issues. It is best used in scenarios where platform-specific behavior is not a concern.

API Design

  • cross-spawn:

    cross-spawn provides a simple and straightforward API for spawning child processes. It focuses on simplicity and ease of use, making it easy to integrate into existing projects without a steep learning curve.

  • execa:

    execa offers a more modern and feature-rich API compared to the built-in child_process module. It supports promises and async/await, making it more suitable for modern JavaScript applications. The API is designed to be intuitive and easy to use, with additional features like execa.sync for synchronous execution.

  • spawn-sync:

    spawn-sync provides a minimalistic API for synchronously spawning child processes. It is straightforward and easy to use, but it lacks the advanced features and flexibility offered by the other libraries.

Error Handling

  • cross-spawn:

    cross-spawn provides basic error handling for child processes. It emits errors when the process fails to spawn or exits with a non-zero status code. However, it does not provide detailed error information or support for promise-based error handling.

  • execa:

    execa offers much better error handling compared to the other libraries. It throws an ExecaError for failed processes, which includes detailed information about the error, such as the exit code, stdout, and stderr. This makes it easier to handle errors and debug issues when working with child processes.

  • spawn-sync:

    spawn-sync provides basic error handling for synchronous process spawning. It throws an error if the process fails to spawn or exits with a non-zero status code, but it does not provide any additional error information or context.

Synchronous vs Asynchronous Execution

  • cross-spawn:

    cross-spawn is primarily designed for asynchronous process spawning. It uses callbacks to handle process output and errors, allowing the main thread to continue executing while the child process runs in the background.

  • execa:

    execa supports both asynchronous and synchronous execution of child processes. It provides a promise-based API for async execution and also offers a synchronous method (execa.sync) for cases where blocking the main thread is acceptable.

  • spawn-sync:

    spawn-sync is focused solely on synchronous execution. It blocks the main thread until the child process completes, making it suitable for scripts or applications where synchronous behavior is required.

Ease of Use: Code Examples

  • cross-spawn:

    Simple cross-platform process spawning with cross-spawn

    const spawn = require('cross-spawn');
const child = spawn('echo', ['Hello, World!']);

child.stdout.on('data', (data) => {
  console.log(`Output: ${data}`);
});

child.stderr.on('data', (data) => {
  console.error(`Error: ${data}`);
});

child.on('close', (code) => {
  console.log(`Child process exited with code ${code}`);
});
  • execa:

    Asynchronous process execution with execa

    const { execa } = require('execa');

(async () => {
  try {
    const { stdout } = await execa('echo', ['Hello from Execa!']);
    console.log(stdout);
  } catch (error) {
    console.error(`Error: ${error.message}`);
  }
})();
  • spawn-sync:

    Synchronous process execution with spawn-sync

    const spawnSync = require('spawn-sync');
const result = spawnSync('echo', ['Hello from Spawn-Sync!']);

console.log(result.stdout.toString());
if (result.error) {
  console.error(`Error: ${result.error.message}`);
}
How to Choose: cross-spawn vs execa vs spawn-sync
  • cross-spawn:

    Choose cross-spawn if you need a simple and reliable way to spawn child processes across different platforms, especially when dealing with cross-platform compatibility issues. It handles arguments and environment variables correctly, making it a good choice for most use cases.

  • execa:

    Choose execa if you need a feature-rich and modern alternative to the built-in child_process module. It offers a promise-based API, better error handling, and additional features like streaming, timeout support, and improved handling of subprocesses, making it ideal for more complex scenarios.

  • spawn-sync:

    Choose spawn-sync if you require a synchronous method for spawning child processes. This is useful for scripts or applications where blocking the main thread is acceptable, and you need to ensure that the child process completes before continuing execution.

Similar Npm Packages to execa

execa is a popular Node.js library that simplifies the process of executing shell commands and spawning child processes. It provides a promise-based API, making it easy to work with asynchronous operations while handling standard input, output, and error streams effectively. Execa is particularly useful for developers looking to run shell commands in a more manageable and reliable way compared to the built-in child_process module. However, there are several alternatives available that can also help with executing shell commands and managing child processes. Here are a few notable options:

  • child_process is a core Node.js module that allows you to spawn child processes and execute shell commands. While it is powerful and flexible, its API can be somewhat cumbersome, especially when dealing with asynchronous operations. Developers often find themselves writing additional boilerplate code to handle callbacks and manage streams, which can lead to less readable code. If you need a straightforward solution without adding external dependencies, the child_process module is a solid choice, but it may require more effort to use effectively.

  • cross-env is a utility that allows you to set environment variables across different operating systems in a consistent manner. While it is not a direct alternative to execa for executing commands, it is often used in conjunction with command execution libraries to ensure that environment variables are set correctly, especially when running scripts in a cross-platform environment. If your primary concern is managing environment variables while executing commands, cross-env is an excellent companion tool.

  • node-cmd is a simple Node.js library that provides a straightforward way to execute shell commands. It offers a clean API for running commands and handling their output, making it easier to work with than the native child_process module. However, it lacks some of the advanced features and flexibility that execa provides, such as promise support and better error handling. If you need a lightweight solution for executing commands without the additional features of execa, node-cmd may be suitable.

  • shelljs is a portable Unix shell commands for Node.js. It provides a comprehensive set of shell command implementations that work across different platforms. Shelljs allows you to write shell scripts in JavaScript, making it easy to execute commands and manage file operations. While it offers a rich set of features, it may be overkill if you only need to execute a few simple commands. If you are looking for a more extensive shell scripting solution, shelljs is a great option.

  • spawn-sync is a library that provides synchronous execution of shell commands. It is useful when you need to run commands in a blocking manner, ensuring that the command completes before moving on to the next line of code. However, synchronous execution can lead to performance issues in larger applications, as it blocks the event loop. If you require synchronous command execution and are aware of the potential downsides, spawn-sync can be a viable alternative.

To see how execa compares with these alternatives, check out the comparison: Comparing child_process vs cross-env vs execa vs node-cmd vs shelljs vs spawn-sync.

Similar Npm Packages to spawn-sync

spawn-sync is an npm package that provides a synchronous way to spawn child processes in Node.js. It allows developers to execute shell commands and scripts while blocking the main thread until the command completes. This can be particularly useful in scenarios where you need to ensure that a command has finished executing before proceeding with the next steps in your application. However, using synchronous processes can lead to performance bottlenecks, so it's important to consider the context in which it is used.

There are several alternatives to spawn-sync that offer more flexibility or asynchronous capabilities:

  • cross-spawn is a cross-platform solution for spawning child processes in Node.js. It provides a simple API for executing commands and handles platform-specific differences, making it easier to write scripts that work on both Windows and Unix-like systems. Unlike spawn-sync, cross-spawn is designed for asynchronous execution, allowing your application to continue running while the command is being executed. This makes it a great choice for applications that require non-blocking behavior and better performance.

  • execa is another powerful alternative that simplifies the process of executing shell commands in Node.js. It builds on the capabilities of child_process while providing a more user-friendly API. execa supports both synchronous and asynchronous execution, making it versatile for various use cases. It also includes features like promise-based handling, improved error handling, and the ability to easily handle input and output streams. If you need a robust solution for executing commands with a modern API, execa is an excellent choice.

To see how spawn-sync compares with cross-spawn and execa, check out the comparison: Comparing cross-spawn vs execa vs spawn-sync.

README for cross-spawn

cross-spawn

NPM version Downloads Build Status Build status

A cross platform solution to node's spawn and spawnSync.

Installation

Node.js version 8 and up: $ npm install cross-spawn

Node.js version 7 and under: $ npm install cross-spawn@6

Why

Node has issues when using spawn on Windows:

  • It ignores PATHEXT
  • It does not support shebangs
  • Has problems running commands with spaces
  • Has problems running commands with posix relative paths (e.g.: ./my-folder/my-executable)
  • Has an issue with command shims (files in node_modules/.bin/), where arguments with quotes and parenthesis would result in invalid syntax error
  • No options.shell support on node <v4.8

All these issues are handled correctly by cross-spawn. There are some known modules, such as win-spawn, that try to solve this but they are either broken or provide faulty escaping of shell arguments.

Usage

Exactly the same way as node's spawn or spawnSync, so it's a drop in replacement.

const spawn = require('cross-spawn');

// Spawn NPM asynchronously
const child = spawn('npm', ['list', '-g', '-depth', '0'], { stdio: 'inherit' });

// Spawn NPM synchronously
const result = spawn.sync('npm', ['list', '-g', '-depth', '0'], { stdio: 'inherit' });

Caveats

Using options.shell as an alternative to cross-spawn

Starting from node v4.8, spawn has a shell option that allows you run commands from within a shell. This new option solves the PATHEXT issue but:

  • It's not supported in node <v4.8
  • You must manually escape the command and arguments which is very error prone, specially when passing user input
  • There are a lot of other unresolved issues from the Why section that you must take into account

If you are using the shell option to spawn a command in a cross platform way, consider using cross-spawn instead. You have been warned.

options.shell support

While cross-spawn adds support for options.shell in node <v4.8, all of its enhancements are disabled.

This mimics the Node.js behavior. More specifically, the command and its arguments will not be automatically escaped nor shebang support will be offered. This is by design because if you are using options.shell you are probably targeting a specific platform anyway and you don't want things to get into your way.

Shebangs support

While cross-spawn handles shebangs on Windows, its support is limited. More specifically, it just supports #!/usr/bin/env <program> where <program> must not contain any arguments.
If you would like to have the shebang support improved, feel free to contribute via a pull-request.

Remember to always test your code on Windows!

Tests

$ npm test
$ npm test -- --watch during development

License

Released under the MIT License.

npm-compare.com is an independent website designed to help developers choose the most suitable npm packages. We are not affiliated with npm, Inc or npmjs.com, the official website for the npm registry. Please note that npm is a registered trademark of npm, Inc. For more details, please refer to our Terms & Privacy.