execa vs cross-env vs shelljs vs spawn-sync vs child_process vs node-cmd
Node.js Process Management Libraries Comparison
1 Year
execacross-envshelljsspawn-syncchild_processnode-cmdSimilar Packages:
What's Node.js Process Management Libraries?

These libraries provide various functionalities for managing child processes in Node.js applications. They allow developers to execute shell commands, manage environment variables, and handle asynchronous process execution effectively. Each library has its own strengths, making them suitable for different use cases in process management and command execution within Node.js applications.

Package Weekly Downloads Trend
Github Stars Ranking
Stat Detail
Package
Downloads
Stars
Size
Issues
Publish
License
execa85,743,5097,028324 kB123 months agoMIT
cross-env7,872,5316,365-14 years agoMIT
shelljs7,769,79014,314212 kB101-BSD-3-Clause
spawn-sync846,29335-07 years agoMIT
child_process773,955159-48 years agoISC
node-cmd33,525285-74 years agoMIT
Feature Comparison: execa vs cross-env vs shelljs vs spawn-sync vs child_process vs node-cmd

Execution Model

  • execa:

    'execa' offers a promise-based API for executing commands, making it easier to work with asynchronous code. It supports both standard output and error streams, and provides options for handling timeouts and killing processes gracefully.

  • cross-env:

    'cross-env' does not execute commands directly but modifies the environment variables for the command that follows it. It ensures that environment variables are set correctly across different operating systems, making it a utility for command execution rather than a process management tool.

  • shelljs:

    'shelljs' mimics Unix shell commands in JavaScript, allowing you to write scripts that look and feel like shell scripts. It provides a synchronous API for executing commands, making it intuitive for users familiar with shell scripting.

  • spawn-sync:

    'spawn-sync' provides a synchronous interface to spawn child processes, blocking the execution until the command completes. This is useful for scenarios where you need to ensure that a command finishes before moving on to the next operation.

  • child_process:

    The 'child_process' module allows you to spawn child processes using methods like spawn, exec, execFile, and fork. It provides a low-level API for managing processes, allowing for detailed control over input/output streams and process lifecycle.

  • node-cmd:

    'node-cmd' provides a simple interface to execute shell commands as if you were typing them in the terminal. It abstracts away the complexities of process management, focusing on ease of use for straightforward command execution.

Cross-Platform Compatibility

  • execa:

    'execa' inherits the cross-platform capabilities of 'child_process' but simplifies the process of executing commands and handling environment variables, making it easier to write cross-platform scripts without worrying about platform-specific issues.

  • cross-env:

    'cross-env' is specifically designed for cross-platform compatibility, allowing you to set environment variables in a way that works seamlessly on both Windows and Unix-like systems, making it an essential tool for multi-platform Node.js applications.

  • shelljs:

    'shelljs' provides a consistent API that works across platforms, allowing you to write scripts that run on both Windows and Unix-like systems without modification. It abstracts away the differences in command syntax and behavior.

  • spawn-sync:

    'spawn-sync' is also cross-platform but, like 'child_process', requires careful attention to command syntax and environment variables to ensure compatibility across different operating systems.

  • child_process:

    While 'child_process' is cross-platform, it requires careful handling of command syntax and environment variables to ensure compatibility across different operating systems, which can add complexity to your code.

  • node-cmd:

    'node-cmd' is designed to work across platforms but may require additional handling for certain commands that differ between Windows and Unix-like systems. It's straightforward but may not cover all edge cases for cross-platform execution.

Error Handling

  • execa:

    'execa' provides built-in error handling features, throwing errors with detailed messages if the command fails. This makes it easier to debug issues and handle exceptions in a more user-friendly way.

  • cross-env:

    'cross-env' does not handle errors related to command execution directly, as it focuses on setting environment variables. Error handling must be implemented in the command being executed.

  • shelljs:

    'shelljs' allows for error handling through its API, providing options to check the exit status of commands and handle failures gracefully, making it easier to manage errors in scripts.

  • spawn-sync:

    'spawn-sync' throws an error if the command fails, allowing for straightforward error handling. However, since it blocks execution, it can lead to performance issues if not used judiciously.

  • child_process:

    'child_process' requires manual error handling for process execution. You need to listen for error events and handle them appropriately, which can add complexity to your code if not managed carefully.

  • node-cmd:

    'node-cmd' has basic error handling capabilities, returning error messages when commands fail. However, it may not provide as much detail as other libraries, requiring additional handling for complex scenarios.

Simplicity and Usability

  • execa:

    'execa' is designed for usability, offering a clean and modern API that simplifies command execution. Its promise-based structure makes it easy to integrate into asynchronous workflows, enhancing developer experience.

  • cross-env:

    'cross-env' is extremely simple to use, requiring just a single command to set environment variables. Its straightforward syntax makes it accessible for developers of all skill levels.

  • shelljs:

    'shelljs' provides a familiar shell-like syntax, making it easy for developers accustomed to shell scripting to transition to Node.js. Its command set is intuitive and straightforward to use.

  • spawn-sync:

    'spawn-sync' is simple to use for synchronous command execution, but its blocking nature may not be suitable for all applications, particularly those requiring high performance or responsiveness.

  • child_process:

    'child_process' is powerful but can be complex to use due to its low-level API. It requires a good understanding of Node.js process management and event handling, which may pose a learning curve for new developers.

  • node-cmd:

    'node-cmd' is very user-friendly, allowing developers to execute commands with minimal setup. Its simplicity makes it ideal for quick scripts and tasks without the overhead of complex configurations.

Performance

  • execa:

    'execa' is optimized for performance, providing efficient handling of process execution and output. Its promise-based nature allows for non-blocking operations, making it suitable for high-performance applications.

  • cross-env:

    'cross-env' has minimal performance impact as it only sets environment variables. The performance of the overall command execution depends on the command being run rather than 'cross-env' itself.

  • shelljs:

    'shelljs' offers good performance for scripting tasks, but its synchronous nature can lead to performance issues in long-running scripts or when executing multiple commands in sequence.

  • spawn-sync:

    'spawn-sync' can lead to performance degradation in applications that require high responsiveness, as it blocks the event loop until the command completes, making it less suitable for concurrent execution scenarios.

  • child_process:

    'child_process' offers high performance and flexibility, allowing for fine-tuned control over process execution. However, it requires careful management of resources to avoid performance bottlenecks, especially with multiple concurrent processes.

  • node-cmd:

    'node-cmd' is generally fast for simple command execution, but it may not be as efficient as other libraries for complex tasks that require extensive process management.

How to Choose: execa vs cross-env vs shelljs vs spawn-sync vs child_process vs node-cmd
  • execa:

    Opt for 'execa' if you want a modern, promise-based wrapper around 'child_process' that simplifies the API and adds features like better error handling and support for streaming. It's ideal for developers looking for a more user-friendly experience when executing commands.

  • cross-env:

    Select 'cross-env' when you need to set environment variables in a cross-platform manner. It ensures that your scripts work seamlessly on both Windows and Unix-like systems without worrying about platform-specific syntax.

  • shelljs:

    Choose 'shelljs' if you prefer a shell-like syntax in your Node.js scripts. It provides a rich set of shell commands that can be used directly in JavaScript, making it great for scripting tasks that require a familiar command-line interface.

  • spawn-sync:

    Select 'spawn-sync' when you need synchronous execution of commands. This is useful in scenarios where you need to wait for a command to finish before proceeding, but be cautious as it can block the event loop.

  • child_process:

    Choose 'child_process' if you need a built-in, low-level solution for spawning child processes and executing shell commands directly. It provides full control over the execution environment and is suitable for applications requiring fine-tuned process management.

  • node-cmd:

    Use 'node-cmd' for a straightforward solution to execute shell commands without the complexity of handling streams or buffers. It's best suited for simple command execution where you don't need extensive process management features.

README for execa
execa logo

Coverage Status

Process execution for humans





Execa runs commands in your script, application or library. Unlike shells, it is optimized for programmatic usage. Built on top of the child_process core module.


One of the maintainers @ehmicky is looking for a remote full-time position. Specialized in Node.js back-ends and CLIs, he led Netlify Build, Plugins and Configuration for 2.5 years. Feel free to contact him on his website or on LinkedIn!


Features

Install

npm install execa

Documentation

Execution:

Input/output:

Advanced usage:

Examples

Execution

Simple syntax

import {execa} from 'execa';

const {stdout} = await execa`npm run build`;
// Print command's output
console.log(stdout);

Script

import {$} from 'execa';

const {stdout: name} = await $`cat package.json`.pipe`grep name`;
console.log(name);

const branch = await $`git branch --show-current`;
await $`dep deploy --branch=${branch}`;

await Promise.all([
	$`sleep 1`,
	$`sleep 2`,
	$`sleep 3`,
]);

const directoryName = 'foo bar';
await $`mkdir /tmp/${directoryName}`;

Local binaries

$ npm install -D eslint
await execa({preferLocal: true})`eslint`;

Pipe multiple subprocesses

const {stdout, pipedFrom} = await execa`npm run build`
	.pipe`sort`
	.pipe`head -n 2`;

// Output of `npm run build | sort | head -n 2`
console.log(stdout);
// Output of `npm run build | sort`
console.log(pipedFrom[0].stdout);
// Output of `npm run build`
console.log(pipedFrom[0].pipedFrom[0].stdout);

Input/output

Interleaved output

const {all} = await execa({all: true})`npm run build`;
// stdout + stderr, interleaved
console.log(all);

Programmatic + terminal output

const {stdout} = await execa({stdout: ['pipe', 'inherit']})`npm run build`;
// stdout is also printed to the terminal
console.log(stdout);

Simple input

const getInputString = () => { /* ... */ };
const {stdout} = await execa({input: getInputString()})`sort`;
console.log(stdout);

File input

// Similar to: npm run build < input.txt
await execa({stdin: {file: 'input.txt'}})`npm run build`;

File output

// Similar to: npm run build > output.txt
await execa({stdout: {file: 'output.txt'}})`npm run build`;

Split into text lines

const {stdout} = await execa({lines: true})`npm run build`;
// Print first 10 lines
console.log(stdout.slice(0, 10).join('\n'));

Streaming

Iterate over text lines

for await (const line of execa`npm run build`) {
	if (line.includes('WARN')) {
		console.warn(line);
	}
}

Transform/filter output

let count = 0;

// Filter out secret lines, then prepend the line number
const transform = function * (line) {
	if (!line.includes('secret')) {
		yield `[${count++}] ${line}`;
	}
};

await execa({stdout: transform})`npm run build`;

Web streams

const response = await fetch('https://example.com');
await execa({stdin: response.body})`sort`;

Convert to Duplex stream

import {execa} from 'execa';
import {pipeline} from 'node:stream/promises';
import {createReadStream, createWriteStream} from 'node:fs';

await pipeline(
	createReadStream('./input.txt'),
	execa`node ./transform.js`.duplex(),
	createWriteStream('./output.txt'),
);

IPC

Exchange messages

// parent.js
import {execaNode} from 'execa';

const subprocess = execaNode`child.js`;
await subprocess.sendMessage('Hello from parent');
const message = await subprocess.getOneMessage();
console.log(message); // 'Hello from child'
// child.js
import {getOneMessage, sendMessage} from 'execa';

const message = await getOneMessage(); // 'Hello from parent'
const newMessage = message.replace('parent', 'child'); // 'Hello from child'
await sendMessage(newMessage);

Any input type

// main.js
import {execaNode} from 'execa';

const ipcInput = [
	{task: 'lint', ignore: /test\.js/},
	{task: 'copy', files: new Set(['main.js', 'index.js']),
}];
await execaNode({ipcInput})`build.js`;
// build.js
import {getOneMessage} from 'execa';

const ipcInput = await getOneMessage();

Any output type

// main.js
import {execaNode} from 'execa';

const {ipcOutput} = await execaNode`build.js`;
console.log(ipcOutput[0]); // {kind: 'start', timestamp: date}
console.log(ipcOutput[1]); // {kind: 'stop', timestamp: date}
// build.js
import {sendMessage} from 'execa';

const runBuild = () => { /* ... */ };

await sendMessage({kind: 'start', timestamp: new Date()});
await runBuild();
await sendMessage({kind: 'stop', timestamp: new Date()});

Graceful termination

// main.js
import {execaNode} from 'execa';

const controller = new AbortController();
setTimeout(() => {
	controller.abort();
}, 5000);

await execaNode({
	cancelSignal: controller.signal,
	gracefulCancel: true,
})`build.js`;
// build.js
import {getCancelSignal} from 'execa';

const cancelSignal = await getCancelSignal();
const url = 'https://example.com/build/info';
const response = await fetch(url, {signal: cancelSignal});

Debugging

Detailed error

import {execa, ExecaError} from 'execa';

try {
	await execa`unknown command`;
} catch (error) {
	if (error instanceof ExecaError) {
		console.log(error);
	}
	/*
	ExecaError: Command failed with ENOENT: unknown command
	spawn unknown ENOENT
			at ...
			at ... {
		shortMessage: 'Command failed with ENOENT: unknown command\nspawn unknown ENOENT',
		originalMessage: 'spawn unknown ENOENT',
		command: 'unknown command',
		escapedCommand: 'unknown command',
		cwd: '/path/to/cwd',
		durationMs: 28.217566,
		failed: true,
		timedOut: false,
		isCanceled: false,
		isTerminated: false,
		isMaxBuffer: false,
		code: 'ENOENT',
		stdout: '',
		stderr: '',
		stdio: [undefined, '', ''],
		pipedFrom: []
		[cause]: Error: spawn unknown ENOENT
				at ...
				at ... {
			errno: -2,
			code: 'ENOENT',
			syscall: 'spawn unknown',
			path: 'unknown',
			spawnargs: [ 'command' ]
		}
	}
	*/
}

Verbose mode

await execa`npm run build`;
await execa`npm run test`;
execa verbose output

Custom logging

import {execa as execa_} from 'execa';
import {createLogger, transports} from 'winston';

// Log to a file using Winston
const transport = new transports.File({filename: 'logs.txt'});
const logger = createLogger({transports: [transport]});
const LOG_LEVELS = {
	command: 'info',
	output: 'verbose',
	ipc: 'verbose',
	error: 'error',
	duration: 'info',
};

const execa = execa_({
	verbose(verboseLine, {message, ...verboseObject}) {
		const level = LOG_LEVELS[verboseObject.type];
		logger[level](message, verboseObject);
	},
});

await execa`npm run build`;
await execa`npm run test`;

Related

Maintainers