gulp-sass vs grunt-sass
Task Runners for Sass Compilation Comparison
1 Year
gulp-sassgrunt-sass
What's Task Runners for Sass Compilation?

Grunt and Gulp are both task runners that automate repetitive tasks in web development, such as compiling Sass into CSS. They help streamline the development process by allowing developers to define tasks in a configuration file and execute them with a single command. While both packages serve similar purposes, they differ in their approach and underlying architecture, which can influence the choice of one over the other based on project needs and developer preferences.

NPM Package Downloads Trend
Github Stars Ranking
Stat Detail
Package
Downloads
Stars
Size
Issues
Publish
License
gulp-sass327,4881,57023.9 kB24a month agoMIT
grunt-sass148,9281,014-35 years agoMIT
Feature Comparison: gulp-sass vs grunt-sass

Configuration Style

  • gulp-sass:

    Gulp uses a code-based approach, allowing developers to define tasks using JavaScript functions. This results in more concise and readable code, enabling developers to leverage the full power of JavaScript for task automation, which can be more intuitive for those familiar with programming.

  • grunt-sass:

    Grunt uses a configuration file (Gruntfile.js) where tasks are defined in a structured manner. This can lead to more verbose configurations but provides a clear overview of all tasks and their settings, making it easier to manage larger projects with many tasks.

Performance

  • gulp-sass:

    Gulp is designed for speed and efficiency, utilizing Node.js streams to process files in memory. This allows for faster execution of tasks, as files can be transformed and passed along the pipeline without intermediate disk writes, making it more suitable for larger projects.

  • grunt-sass:

    Grunt processes files in a more sequential manner, which can lead to slower performance for larger projects. Each task runs one after the other, which may introduce delays, especially when dealing with multiple file transformations.

Ecosystem and Plugins

  • gulp-sass:

    Gulp also has a rich ecosystem of plugins, but its streaming architecture allows for more seamless integration of tasks. Developers can easily chain tasks together, which can simplify the build process and reduce the need for multiple plugins.

  • grunt-sass:

    Grunt has a large ecosystem of plugins available for various tasks, making it easy to extend functionality. However, the reliance on plugins can lead to a more complex configuration as multiple plugins may be needed to achieve desired outcomes.

Learning Curve

  • gulp-sass:

    Gulp's code-based approach is often considered easier to learn for those familiar with JavaScript, as it allows developers to write tasks in a more familiar programming style. This can lead to quicker onboarding for new team members.

  • grunt-sass:

    Grunt's configuration-driven approach may present a steeper learning curve for newcomers, as understanding the structure and syntax of the Gruntfile can take time. However, once mastered, it provides a clear framework for task management.

Community Support

  • gulp-sass:

    Gulp has gained significant traction in the web development community and has a vibrant ecosystem. The community actively contributes to its development, ensuring that it stays up-to-date with modern web practices.

  • grunt-sass:

    Grunt has been around for a longer time and has a well-established community, which means more resources, tutorials, and support are available. However, its popularity has waned in favor of Gulp in recent years.

How to Choose: gulp-sass vs grunt-sass
  • gulp-sass:

    Choose gulp-sass if you prefer a code-driven approach that emphasizes streaming and performance. Gulp's use of Node.js streams allows for faster processing of files, making it ideal for projects where speed and efficiency are critical.

  • grunt-sass:

    Choose grunt-sass if you prefer a configuration-driven approach and are already using Grunt for other tasks in your project. Grunt's extensive plugin ecosystem and its focus on configuration make it suitable for projects that require a more declarative style of task management.

README for gulp-sass

gulp-sass npm package version Build Status Join the chat at https://gitter.im/dlmanning/gulp-sass Node.js support

Sass plugin for Gulp.

Before filing an issue, please make sure you have updated to the latest version of gulp-sass and have gone through our Common Issues and Their Fixes section.

Migrating your existing project to version 5 or 6? Please read our (short!) migration guides.

Support

Only Active LTS and Current releases are supported.

Installation

To use gulp-sass, you must install both gulp-sass itself and a Sass compiler. gulp-sass supports both Embedded Sass, Dart Sass and Node Sass, although Node Sass is deprecated. We recommend that you use Dart Sass for new projects, and migrate Node Sass projects to Dart Sass or Embedded Sass when possible.

Whichever compiler you choose, it's best to install these as dev dependencies:

npm install sass gulp-sass --save-dev

Importing it into your project

gulp-sass must be imported into your gulpfile, where you provide it the compiler of your choice. To use gulp-sass in a CommonJS module (which is most Node.js environments), do something like this:

const sass = require('gulp-sass')(require('sass'));

To use gulp-sass in an ECMAScript module (which is supported in newer Node.js 14 and later), do something like this:

import dartSass from 'sass';
import gulpSass from 'gulp-sass';
const sass = gulpSass(dartSass);

Usage

Note: These examples are written for CommonJS modules and assume you're using Gulp 4. For examples that work with Gulp 3, check the docs for an earlier version of gulp-sass.

gulp-sass must be used in a Gulp task. Your task can call sass() (to asynchronously render your CSS), or sass.sync() (to synchronously render your CSS). Then, export your task with the export keyword. We'll show some examples of how to do that.

⚠️ Note: When using Dart Sass, synchronous rendering is twice as fast as asynchronous rendering. The Sass team is exploring ways to improve asynchronous rendering with Dart Sass, but for now, you will get the best performance from sass.sync(). If performance is critical, you can use sass-embedded instead.

Render your CSS

To render your CSS with a build task, then watch your files for changes, you might write something like this:

'use strict';

const gulp = require('gulp');
const sass = require('gulp-sass')(require('sass'));

function buildStyles() {
  return gulp.src('./sass/**/*.scss')
    .pipe(sass().on('error', sass.logError))
    .pipe(gulp.dest('./css'));
};

exports.buildStyles = buildStyles;
exports.watch = function () {
  gulp.watch('./sass/**/*.scss', buildStyles);
};

With synchronous rendering, that Gulp task looks like this:

function buildStyles() {
  return gulp.src('./sass/**/*.scss')
    .pipe(sass.sync().on('error', sass.logError))
    .pipe(gulp.dest('./css'));
};

Render with options

To change the final output of your CSS, you can pass an options object to your renderer. gulp-sass supports Sass's JS API compile options, with a few usage notes:

  • The syntax option is set to indented automatically for files with the .sass extension
  • The sourceMap and sourceMapIncludeSources options are set for you when using gulp-sourcemaps

For example, to compress your CSS, you can call sass({style: 'compressed'}. In the context of a Gulp task, that looks like this:

function buildStyles() {
  return gulp.src('./sass/**/*.scss')
    .pipe(sass({style: 'compressed'}).on('error', sass.logError))
    .pipe(gulp.dest('./css'));
};

exports.buildStyles = buildStyles;

Or this for synchronous rendering:

function buildStyles() {
  return gulp.src('./sass/**/*.scss')
    .pipe(sass.sync({style: 'compressed'}).on('error', sass.logError))
    .pipe(gulp.dest('./css'));
};

exports.buildStyles = buildStyles;

Include a source map

gulp-sass can be used in tandem with gulp-sourcemaps to generate source maps for the Sass-to-CSS compilation. You will need to initialize gulp-sourcemaps before running gulp-sass, and write the source maps after.

const sourcemaps = require('gulp-sourcemaps');

function buildStyles() {
  return gulp.src('./sass/**/*.scss')
    .pipe(sourcemaps.init())
    .pipe(sass().on('error', sass.logError))
    .pipe(sourcemaps.write())
    .pipe(gulp.dest('./css'));
}

exports.buildStyles = buildStyles;

By default, gulp-sourcemaps writes the source maps inline, in the compiled CSS files. To write them to a separate file, specify a path relative to the gulp.dest() destination in the sourcemaps.write() function.

const sourcemaps = require('gulp-sourcemaps');

function buildStyles() {
  return gulp.src('./sass/**/*.scss')
    .pipe(sourcemaps.init())
    .pipe(sass().on('error', sass.logError))
    .pipe(sourcemaps.write('./maps'))
    .pipe(gulp.dest('./css'));
};

exports.buildStyles = buildStyles;

Migrating to version 6

gulp-sass version 6 uses the new compile function internally by default. If you use any options, for instance custom importers, please compare the new options with the legacy options in order to migrate. For instance, the outputStyle option is now called style.

  function buildStyles() {
    return gulp.src('./sass/**/*.scss')
-     .pipe(sass({outputStyle: 'compressed'}).on('error', sass.logError))
+     .pipe(sass({style: 'compressed'}).on('error', sass.logError))
      .pipe(gulp.dest('./css'));
  };

If you want to keep using the legacy API while it's available, you can.

const sass = require('gulp-sass/legacy')(require('sass'));

If you use source maps, you may see the result change somewhat. The result will typically be absolute file: URLs, rather than relative ones. The result may also be the source itself, URL encoded. You can optionally add custom importers to adjust the source maps according to your own needs.

Migrating to version 5

gulp-sass version 5 requires Node.js 12 or later, and introduces some breaking changes. Additionally, changes in Node.js itself mean that Node fibers can no longer be used to speed up Dart Sass in Node.js 16.

Setting a Sass compiler

As of version 5, gulp-sass does not include a default Sass compiler, so you must install one (either sass, sass-embedded, or node-sass) along with gulp-sass.

npm install sass gulp-sass --save-dev

Then, you must explicitly set that compiler in your gulpfille. Instead of setting a compiler prop on the gulp-sass instance, you pass the compiler into a function call when instantiating gulp-sass.

These changes look something like this:

- const sass = require('gulp-sass'));
- const compiler = require('sass');
- sass.compiler = compiler;
+ const sass = require('gulp-sass')(require('sass'));

If you're migrating an ECMAScript module, that'll look something like this:

import dartSass from 'sass';
- import sass from 'gulp-sass';
- sass.compiler = dartSass;

import dartSass from 'sass';
+ import gulpSass from 'gulp-sass';
+ const sass = gulpSass(dartSass);

Using the legacy Sass API

If you need to use the deprecated render Sass API, gulp-sass still includes legacy support.

'use strict';

const gulp = require('gulp');
const sass = require('gulp-sass/legacy')(require('sass'));

function buildStyles() {
  return gulp.src('./sass/**/*.scss')
    .pipe(sass().on('error', sass.logError))
    .pipe(gulp.dest('./css'));
};

exports.buildStyles = buildStyles;
exports.watch = function () {
  gulp.watch('./sass/**/*.scss', buildStyles);
};

What about fibers?

We used to recommend Node fibers as a way to speed up asynchronous rendering with Dart Sass. Unfortunately, Node fibers are discontinued and will not work in Node.js 16. The Sass team is exploring its options for future performance improvements, but for now, you will get the best performance from sass.sync().

Issues

gulp-sass is a light-weight wrapper around either Dart Sass or Node Sass (which in turn is a Node.js binding for LibSass. Because of this, the issue you're having likely isn't a gulp-sass issue, but an issue with one those projects or with Sass as a whole.

If you have a feature request/question about how Sass works/concerns on how your Sass gets compiled/errors in your compiling, it's likely a Dart Sass or LibSass issue and you should file your issue with one of those projects.

If you're having problems with the options you're passing in, it's likely a Dart Sass or Node Sass issue and you should file your issue with one of those projects.

We may, in the course of resolving issues, direct you to one of these other projects. If we do so, please follow up by searching that project's issue queue (both open and closed) for your problem and, if it doesn't exist, filing an issue with them.