seamless-immutable vs immer vs immutability-helper vs immutable
Immutable State Management in JavaScript Applications
seamless-immutableimmerimmutability-helperimmutable

Immutable State Management in JavaScript Applications

immer, immutability-helper, immutable, and seamless-immutable are libraries designed to help developers work with immutable data structures in JavaScript applications. Since JavaScript objects and arrays are mutable by default, these tools provide patterns or data types that enforce immutability—ensuring state changes create new references instead of modifying existing ones. This is especially valuable in UI frameworks like React, where predictable state updates improve performance and reduce bugs.

Npm Package Weekly Downloads Trend

3 Years

Github Stars Ranking

Stat Detail

Package
Downloads
Stars
Size
Issues
Publish
License
seamless-immutable436,3925,329-548 years agoBSD-3-Clause
immer028,980957 kB398 days agoMIT
immutability-helper05,184-76 years agoMIT
immutable033,040726 kB1282 months agoMIT

Immutable State Management: immer vs immmutability-helper vs immutable vs seamless-immutable

Managing state without accidental mutations is a core challenge in modern frontend apps. These four libraries offer different strategies—from proxy-based mutation emulation to fully custom data structures. Let’s compare how they handle real-world scenarios.

🧪 Core Philosophy: How Each Library Enforces Immutability

immer uses JavaScript Proxies to let you "mutate" a draft state, then produces a new immutable snapshot.

  • You write code as if you’re mutating an object.
  • Under the hood, it tracks changes and builds a new object.
import { produce } from 'immer';

const nextState = produce(baseState, draft => {
  draft.user.name = 'Alice'; // Looks like mutation
  draft.posts.push({ id: 3, title: 'New Post' });
});
// nextState is a new object; baseState unchanged

immutability-helper uses command objects with special keys ($set, $push, etc.) to describe changes.

  • No actual mutation occurs—you specify operations declaratively.
  • Relies on string paths to target nested properties.
import update from 'immutability-helper';

const nextState = update(baseState, {
  user: { name: { $set: 'Alice' } },
  posts: { $push: [{ id: 3, title: 'New Post' }] }
});

immutable replaces native objects/arrays with its own classes (Map, List, etc.).

  • All methods return new instances—mutation is impossible by design.
  • Requires converting data to and from Immutable.js types.
import { Map, List } from 'immutable';

const baseState = Map({
  user: Map({ name: 'Bob' }),
  posts: List([{ id: 1, title: 'Old Post' }])
});

const nextState = baseState
  .setIn(['user', 'name'], 'Alice')
  .updateIn(['posts'], posts => posts.push(Map({ id: 3, title: 'New Post' })));

seamless-immutable extends plain JavaScript objects with non-mutating methods.

  • Uses Object.freeze() in development to catch mutations early.
  • Provides helpers like setIn that return new objects.
import Immutable from 'seamless-immutable';

const baseState = Immutable({
  user: { name: 'Bob' },
  posts: [{ id: 1, title: 'Old Post' }]
});

const nextState = baseState
  .setIn(['user', 'name'], 'Alice')
  .updateIn(['posts'], posts => [...posts, { id: 3, title: 'New Post' }]);

🔌 Interoperability with Plain JavaScript Objects

immer: Works directly with standard JS objects/arrays. No conversion needed—input and output are plain data.

// Input and output are plain objects
const input = { count: 0 };
const output = produce(input, d => { d.count++ });
console.log(output instanceof Object); // true

immutability-helper: Also uses plain JS objects. Output matches input structure exactly.

const input = { count: 0 };
const output = update(input, { count: { $set: 1 } });
console.log(output instanceof Object); // true

immutable: Requires wrapping data in Immutable.js collections. To use with React or APIs, you must call .toJS().

const wrapped = Map({ count: 0 });
const plain = wrapped.toJS(); // { count: 0 }

seamless-immutable: Returns frozen plain objects. Can be used directly but may cause issues if downstream code tries to mutate them.

const state = Immutable({ count: 0 });
// state is a plain object, but frozen in dev mode

⚠️ Maintenance Status and Modern JavaScript Support

  • immer: Actively maintained, supports modern JS (including Symbols, Maps, Sets), and integrates well with Redux Toolkit.
  • immutability-helper: Deprecated—last updated in 2017. Not recommended for new projects.
  • immutable: Still maintained but in “long-term support” mode. The team recommends considering alternatives like immer for new code.
  • seamless-immutable: Unmaintained—last commit in 2020. Lacks support for newer language features.

🛠️ Nested Updates: Updating Deeply Structured Data

All libraries support updating nested paths, but syntax varies.

immer: Natural dot notation or bracket access.

produce(state, draft => {
  draft.ui.sidebar.isOpen = false;
});

immutability-helper: Nested command objects with path segments.

update(state, {
  ui: { sidebar: { isOpen: { $set: false } } }
});

immutable: setIn with array path.

state.setIn(['ui', 'sidebar', 'isOpen'], false);

seamless-immutable: setIn with array path.

state.setIn(['ui', 'sidebar', 'isOpen'], false);

📦 Performance Characteristics

  • immer: Efficient structural sharing. Only changed branches are copied. Uses Proxies, so minimal overhead in modern engines.
  • immutability-helper: Creates full copies of intermediate objects along the path—can be inefficient for deep trees.
  • immutable: Optimized persistent data structures (tries) enable fast reads/writes with minimal copying. But conversion cost (toJS()) can hurt performance.
  • seamless-immutable: Always creates shallow copies up the path—no advanced sharing. Freezing in dev adds overhead.

🧩 Real-World Recommendation

For New React/Redux Projects

Use immer. It’s the de facto standard in modern Redux (via Redux Toolkit) and lets you write clean, readable code without boilerplate. Teams adopt it quickly because it feels like regular JavaScript.

For Legacy Codebases

  • If you’re on immutability-helper, migrate to immer—the mental model shift is small.
  • If you’re on seamless-immutable, evaluate migration effort; immer is the natural successor.
  • If you’re on immutable, consider staying if you rely on its advanced collections—but for simple object trees, immer reduces friction.

When to Avoid Each

  • Don’t start new projects with immutability-helper or seamless-immutable—both are unmaintained.
  • Avoid immutable if your app mostly deals with plain JSON-like data and you need seamless integration with external libraries.
  • Avoid immer only if you need compile-time guarantees (e.g., via TypeScript with branded types)—though even then, immer works well with type guards.

✅ Summary Table

LibraryData TypeSyntax StyleMaintained?Interop with Plain JS
immerPlain objectsMutable-looking✅ Yes✅ Excellent
immutability-helperPlain objectsCommand objects❌ No✅ Good
immutableCustom classesMethod chaining⚠️ LTS only❌ Requires conversion
seamless-immutableFrozen objectsHelper methods❌ No⚠️ Limited (frozen)

💡 Final Thought

Immutability isn’t just about correctness—it’s about making change detection efficient and debugging easier. Among active options, immer strikes the best balance: it hides complexity without sacrificing power, and it plays nicely with the rest of the JavaScript ecosystem. Unless you have specific needs for persistent data structures, it’s the pragmatic choice for most teams today.

How to Choose: seamless-immutable vs immer vs immutability-helper vs immutable

  • seamless-immutable:

    Choose seamless-immutable if you prefer working with plain JavaScript objects and arrays but want lightweight immutability enforcement. It freezes objects recursively in development and provides mutation-safe methods like setIn and merge. However, it’s unmaintained as of 2023 and lacks support for modern JavaScript features. Only consider it for small projects or legacy systems where switching libraries isn’t feasible.

  • immer:

    Choose immer if you want to write code that looks like mutable assignments but produces immutable updates under the hood. It’s ideal for teams already using plain JavaScript objects and arrays who need a low-friction way to adopt immutability without learning new APIs or changing data shapes. Its produce function enables intuitive syntax while guaranteeing structural sharing and referential integrity.

  • immutability-helper:

    Avoid immutability-helper in new projects—it is deprecated and no longer maintained. Originally inspired by React’s old update() helper, it uses string-based path commands (like $set, $push) to modify nested structures. While functional, its syntax is verbose and error-prone compared to modern alternatives. Use only if maintaining legacy code that already depends on it.

  • immutable:

    Choose immutable when you need guaranteed, deeply immutable data structures with rich APIs (e.g., Map, List, Set) and built-in performance optimizations like hash maps and persistent tries. It enforces immutability at the type level, preventing accidental mutations. However, it requires wrapping and unwrapping data, which can complicate interoperability with libraries expecting plain JavaScript objects.

README for seamless-immutable

seamless-immutable

Immutable JS data structures which are backwards-compatible with normal Arrays and Objects.

Use them in for loops, pass them to functions expecting vanilla JavaScript data structures, etc.

var array = Immutable(["totally", "immutable", {hammer: "Can’t Touch This"}]);

array[1] = "I'm going to mutate you!"
array[1] // "immutable"

array[2].hammer = "hm, surely I can mutate this nested object..."
array[2].hammer // "Can’t Touch This"

for (var index in array) { console.log(array[index]); }
// "totally"
// "immutable"
// { hammer: 'Can’t Touch This' }

JSON.stringify(array) // '["totally","immutable",{"hammer":"Can’t Touch This"}]'

This level of backwards compatibility requires ECMAScript 5 features like Object.defineProperty and Object.freeze to exist and work correctly, which limits the browsers that can use this library to the ones shown in the test results below. (tl;dr IE9+)

build status NPM version coverage status

Performance

Whenever you deeply clone large nested objects, it should typically go much faster with Immutable data structures. This is because the library reuses the existing nested objects rather than instantiating new ones.

In the development build, objects are frozen. (Note that Safari is relatively slow to iterate over frozen objects.) The development build also overrides unsupported methods (methods that ordinarily mutate the underlying data structure) to throw helpful exceptions.

The production (minified) build does neither of these, which significantly improves performance.

We generally recommend to use the "development" build that enforces immutability (and this is the default in Node.js). Only switch to the production build when you encounter performance problems. (See #50 for how to do that in Node or using a build tool - essentially do explicitely refer to the production build.)

Intentional Abstraction Leaks

By popular demand, functions, errors, dates, and React components are treated as immutable even though technically they can be mutated. (It turns out that trying to make these immutable leads to more bad things than good.) If you call Immutable() on any of these, be forewarned: they will not actually be immutable!

Add-ons

seamless-immutable is tightly focused on the mechanics of turning existing JavaScript data structures into immutable variants. Additional packages are available to build on this capability and enable additional programming models:

LibraryDescription
CursorCompact Cursor Library built on top of the excellent seamless-immutable. Cursors can be used to manage transitions and manipulations of immutable structures in an application.
MergersA collection of mergers for use with seamless-immutable. Also includes documentation about custom mergers, with examples, for writing your own.

API Overview

Immutable() returns a backwards-compatible immutable representation of whatever you pass it, so feel free to pass it absolutely anything that can be serialized as JSON. (As is the case with JSON, objects containing circular references are not allowed. Functions are allowed, unlike in JSON, but they will not be touched.)

Since numbers, strings, undefined, and null are all immutable to begin with, the only unusual things it returns are Immutable Arrays and Immutable Objects. These have the same ES5 methods you’re used to seeing on them, but with these important differences:

  1. All the methods that would normally mutate the data structures instead throw ImmutableError.
  2. All the methods that return a relevant value now return an immutable equivalent of that value.
  3. Attempting to reassign values to their elements (e.g. foo[5] = bar) will not work. Browsers other than Internet Explorer will throw a TypeError if use strict is enabled, and in all other cases it will fail silently.
  4. A few additional methods have been added for convenience.

For example:

Immutable([3, 1, 4]).sort()
// This will throw an ImmutableError, because sort() is a mutating method.

Immutable([1, 2, 3]).concat([10, 9, 8]).sort()
// This will also throw ImmutableError, because an Immutable Array's methods
// (including concat()) are guaranteed to return other immutable values.

[1, 2, 3].concat(Immutable([6, 5, 4])).sort()
// This will succeed, and will yield a sorted mutable array containing
// [1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6], because a vanilla array's concat() method has
// no knowledge of Immutable.

var obj = Immutable({all: "your base", are: {belong: "to them"}});
Immutable.merge(obj, {are: {belong: "to us"}})
// This will return the following:
// Immutable({all: "your base", are: {belong: "to us"}})

Static or instance syntax

Seamless-immutable supports both static and instance syntaxes:

var Immutable = require("seamless-immutable").static;
var obj = {};

Immutable.setIn(obj, ['key'], data)
var Immutable = require("seamless-immutable");
var obj = {};

obj.setIn(['key'], data)

Although the later is shorter and is the current default, it can lead to collisions and some users may dislike polluting object properties when it comes to debugging. As such the first syntax is recommended, but both are supported.

Immutable.from

If your linter cringes with the use of Immutable without a preceding new (e.g. ESLint's new-cap rule), use Immutable.from:

Immutable.from([1, 2, 3]);
// is functionally the same as calling:
Immutable([1, 2, 3])

Immutable Array

Like a regular Array, but immutable! You can construct these by passing an array to Immutable():

Immutable([1, 2, 3])
// An immutable array containing 1, 2, and 3.

Beyond the usual Array fare, the following methods have been added.

flatMap

var array = Immutable(["here", "we", "go"]);
Immutable.flatMap(array, function(str) {
  return [str, str, str];
});
// returns Immutable(["here", "here", "here", "we", "we", "we", "go", "go", "go"])

var array = Immutable(["drop the numbers!", 3, 2, 1, 0, null, undefined]);
Immutable.flatMap(array, function(value) {
  if (typeof value === "number") {
    return [];
  } else {
    return value;
  }
});
// returns Immutable(["drop the numbers!", null, undefined])

Effectively performs a map over the elements in the array, except that whenever the provided iterator function returns an Array, that Array's elements are each added to the final result.

asObject

var array = Immutable(["hey", "you"]);
Immutable.asObject(array, function(str) {
  return [str, str.toUpperCase()];
});
// returns Immutable({hey: "HEY", you: "YOU"})

Effectively performs a map over the elements in the array, expecting that the iterator function will return an array of two elements - the first representing a key, the other a value. Then returns an Immutable Object constructed of those keys and values.

You can also call .asObject without passing an iterator, in which case it will proceed assuming the Array is already organized as desired.

asMutable

var array = Immutable(["hello", "world"]);
var mutableArray = Immutable.asMutable(array);

mutableArray.push("!!!");

mutableArray // ["hello", "world", "!!!"]

Returns a mutable copy of the array. For a deeply mutable copy, in which any instances of Immutable contained in nested data structures within the array have been converted back to mutable data structures, call Immutable.asMutable(obj, {deep: true}) instead.

isImmutable

var array = Immutable(["hello", "world"]);
var mutableArray = ["hello", "world"];

Immutable.isImmutable(array)
// returns true

Immutable.isImmutable(mutableArray)
// returns false

Returns whether an object is immutable or not.

Immutable Object

Like a regular Object, but immutable! You can construct these by passing an object to Immutable().

Immutable({foo: "bar"})
// An immutable object containing the key "foo" and the value "bar".

To construct an Immutable Object with a custom prototype, simply specify the prototype in options (while useful for preserving prototypes, please note that custom mutator methods will not work as the object will be immutable):

function Square(length) { this.length = length };
Square.prototype.area = function() { return Math.pow(this.length, 2) };

Immutable(new Square(2), {prototype: Square.prototype}).area();
// An immutable object, with prototype Square,
// containing the key "length" and method `area()` returning 4

Beyond the usual Object fare, the following methods have been added.

Stack overflow protection

Currently you can't construct Immutable from an object with circular references. To protect from ugly stack overflows, we provide a simple protection during development. We stop at a suspiciously deep stack level and show an error message.

If your objects are deep, but not circular, you can increase this level from default 64. For example:

Immutable(deepObject, null, 256);

This check is not performed in the production build.

merge

var obj = Immutable({status: "good", hypothesis: "plausible", errors: 0});
Immutable.merge(obj, {status: "funky", hypothesis: "confirmed"});
// returns Immutable({status: "funky", hypothesis: "confirmed", errors: 0})

var obj = Immutable({status: "bad", errors: 37});
Immutable.merge(obj, [
  {status: "funky", errors: 1}, {status: "groovy", errors: 2}, {status: "sweet"}]);
// returns Immutable({status: "sweet", errors: 2})
// because passing an Array is shorthand for
// invoking a separate merge for each object in turn.

Returns an Immutable Object containing the properties and values of both this object and the provided object, prioritizing the provided object's values whenever the same key is present in both objects.

Multiple objects can be provided in an Array in which case more merge invocations will be performed using each provided object in turn.

A third argument can be provided to configure the merge. It should be an object with any of the following fields:

{
  deep: true, // perform a deep merge
  merger: yourCustomMerger // supply a custom merger
}

You can find examples and documentation about custom mergers here.

replace

var obj1 = Immutable({a: {b: 'test'}, c: 'test'});
var obj2 = Immutable.replace(obj1, {a: {b: 'test'}}, {deep: true});
// returns Immutable({a: {b: 'test'}});
obj1 === obj2
// returns false
obj1.a === obj2.a
// returns true because child .a objects were identical

Returns an Immutable Object containing the properties and values of the second object only. With deep merge, all child objects are checked for equality and the original immutable object is returned when possible.

A second argument can be provided to perform a deep merge: {deep: true}.

set

var obj = Immutable({type: "parrot", subtype: "Norwegian Blue", status: "alive"});
Immutable.set(obj, "status", "dead");
// returns Immutable({type: "parrot", subtype: "Norwegian Blue", status: "dead"})

Returns an Immutable Object with a single property set to the provided value. Basically a more straightforward way of saying

var obj = Immutable({type: "parrot", subtype: "Norwegian Blue", status: "alive"});
Immutable.merge(obj, {status: "dead"});

(and more convenient with non-literal keys unless you have ES6 [computed_property_names]).

A second argument can be provided to perform a deep compare: {deep: true}.

setIn

Like set, but accepts a nested path to the property.

var obj = Immutable({type: {main: "parrot", sub: "Norwegian Blue"}, status: "alive"});
Immutable.setIn(obj, ["type", "sub"], "Norwegian Ridgeback");
// returns Immutable({type: {main: "parrot", sub: "Norwegian Ridgeback"}, status: "alive"})

A second argument can be provided to perform a deep compare: {deep: true}.

getIn

Returns the value at the given path. A default value can be provided as a second argument.

var obj = Immutable({type: {main: "parrot", subtype: "Norwegian Blue"}, status: "alive"});
Immutable.getIn(obj, ["type", "subtype"]);
// returns "Norwegian Blue"
Immutable.getIn(obj, ["type", "class"], "Aves");
// returns "Aves"

update

Returns an Immutable Object with a single property updated using the provided updater function.

function inc (x) { return x + 1 }
var obj = Immutable({foo: 1});
Immutable.update(obj, "foo", inc);
// returns Immutable({foo: 2})

All additional arguments will be passed to the updater function.

function add (x, y) { return x + y }
var obj = Immutable({foo: 1});
Immutable.update(obj, "foo", add, 10);
// returns Immutable({foo: 11})

updateIn

Like update, but accepts a nested path to the property.

function add (x, y) { return x + y }
var obj = Immutable({foo: {bar: 1}});
Immutable.updateIn(obj, ["foo", "bar"], add, 10);
// returns Immutable({foo: {bar: 11}})

without

var obj = Immutable({the: "forests", will: "echo", with: "laughter"});
Immutable.without(obj, "with");
// returns Immutable({the: "forests", will: "echo"})

var obj = Immutable({the: "forests", will: "echo", with: "laughter"});
Immutable.without(obj, ["will", "with"]);
// returns Immutable({the: "forests"})

var obj = Immutable({the: "forests", will: "echo", with: "laughter"});
Immutable.without(obj, "will", "with");
// returns Immutable({the: "forests"})

var obj = Immutable({the: "forests", will: "echo", with: "laughter"});
Immutable.without(obj, (value, key) => key === "the" || value === "echo");
// returns Immutable({with: "laughter"})

Returns an Immutable Object excluding the given keys or keys/values satisfying the given predicate from the existing object.

Multiple keys can be provided, either in an Array or as extra arguments.

asMutable

var obj = Immutable({when: "the", levee: "breaks"});
var mutableObject = Immutable.asMutable(obj);

mutableObject.have = "no place to go";

mutableObject // {when: "the", levee: "breaks", have: "no place to go"}

Returns a mutable copy of the object. For a deeply mutable copy, in which any instances of Immutable contained in nested data structures within the object have been converted back to mutable data structures, call Immutable.asMutable(obj, {deep: true}) instead.

Releases

7.1.4

Fixed bug with custom mergers treating all non-truthy values as undefined (#244).

7.1.3

Treat Blob instances as immutable. Use Array.isArray over instanceof.

7.1.2

Treat Error instances as immutable.

7.1.1

Fix .npmignore

7.1.0

Add getIn and assumption that Promises are immutable.

7.0.0

Add Immutable.static as the preferred API. Default to development build in webpack.

6.3.0

Adds optional deep compare for .set, .setIn and .replace

6.2.0

Adds static alternatives to methods, e.g. Immutable.setIn

6.1.4

Fixes bug with deep merge() on an array argument.

6.1.3

Fixes bug with setting a new object on an existing leaf array.

6.1.2

Fixes bug where on some systems arrays are treated as plain objects.

6.1.1

without now handles numeric keys the same way as string keys.

6.1.0

Alias Immutable.from() to Immutable() for linters.

6.0.1

React components are now considered immutable.

6.0.0

Add cycle detection.

5.2.0

Add update and updateIn.

5.1.1

Immutable(Object.create(null)) now works as expected.

5.1.0

Add predicate support to without()

5.0.1

Fix missing dev/prod builds for 5.0.0

5.0.0

In development build, freeze Dates and ban mutating methods. (Note: dev and prod builds were mistakenly not generated for this, so to get this functionality in those builds, use 5.0.1)

4.1.1

Make setIn more null safe.

4.1.0

Adds set and setIn

4.0.1

Now when you require("seamless-immutable"), you get the development build by default.

4.0.0

main now points to src/seamless-immutable.js so you can more easily build with envify yourself.

3.0.0

Add support for optional prototyping.

2.4.2

Calling .asMutable({deep: true}) on an Immutable data structure with a nested Date no longer throws an exception.

2.4.1

Arrays with nonstandard prototypes no longer throw exceptions when passed to Immutable.

2.4.0

Custom mergers now check for reference equality and abort early if there is no more work needed, allowing improved performance.

2.3.2

Fixes a bug where indices passed into iterators for flatMap and asObject were strings instead of numbers.

2.3.1

Fixes an IE and Firefox bug related to cloning Dates while preserving their prototypes.

2.3.0

Dates now retain their prototypes, the same way Arrays do.

2.2.0

Adds a minified production build with no freezing or defensive unsupported methods, for a ~2x performance boost.

2.1.0

Adds optional merger function to #merge.

2.0.2

Bugfix: #merge with {deep: true} no longer attempts (unsuccessfully) to deeply merge arrays as though they were regular objects.

2.0.1

Minor documentation typo fix.

2.0.0

Breaking API change: #merge now takes exactly one or exactly two arguments. The second is optional and allows specifying deep: true.

1.3.0

Don't bother returning a new value from #merge if no changes would result.

1.2.0

Make error message for invalid #asObject less fancy, resulting in a performance improvement.

1.1.0

Adds #asMutable

1.0.0

Initial stable release

Development

Run npm install -g grunt-cli, npm install and then grunt to build and test it.