react-waypoint vs react-scrollspy vs react-in-viewport vs react-intersection-observer vs react-scroll
React Scroll and Intersection Libraries
react-waypointreact-scrollspyreact-in-viewportreact-intersection-observerreact-scrollSimilar Packages:

React Scroll and Intersection Libraries

These libraries are designed to enhance user experience in web applications by providing functionalities related to element visibility and scrolling behaviors. They allow developers to create dynamic and interactive interfaces that respond to user scrolling, making it easier to implement features like lazy loading, animations, and navigation highlights based on the user's viewport and scroll position.

Npm Package Weekly Downloads Trend

3 Years

Github Stars Ranking

Stat Detail

Package
Downloads
Stars
Size
Issues
Publish
License
react-waypoint294,1264,03960.7 kB59-MIT
react-scrollspy41,949428-846 years agoMIT
react-in-viewport035185.6 kB020 days agoMIT
react-intersection-observer05,538168 kB1a month agoMIT
react-scroll04,398139 kB2302 years agoMIT

Feature Comparison: react-waypoint vs react-scrollspy vs react-in-viewport vs react-intersection-observer vs react-scroll

Visibility Detection

  • react-waypoint:

    react-waypoint allows you to define waypoints in your application that trigger actions when scrolled into view. This can include loading additional content, triggering animations, or changing styles, making it a flexible tool for scroll-based interactions.

  • react-scrollspy:

    react-scrollspy tracks the scroll position of the page and highlights the corresponding navigation links based on the current section in view. This feature improves navigation usability, especially in long single-page applications, by providing visual feedback to users as they scroll.

  • react-in-viewport:

    react-in-viewport provides a simple way to detect when an element enters or exits the viewport. It uses a higher-order component to wrap your target elements, allowing you to easily manage visibility states and trigger actions based on whether the element is visible or not.

  • react-intersection-observer:

    react-intersection-observer utilizes the Intersection Observer API to efficiently monitor the visibility of multiple elements. This library is optimized for performance and can handle complex scenarios, such as lazy loading images or triggering animations when elements come into view, without the need for manual scroll event listeners.

  • react-scroll:

    react-scroll does not focus on visibility detection but rather on managing scroll behavior within a page. It allows you to create smooth scrolling effects and navigate between sections seamlessly, enhancing the overall user experience during scrolling actions.

Performance

  • react-waypoint:

    react-waypoint is designed to be lightweight and efficient, allowing you to trigger actions based on scroll position without significant performance overhead. It is suitable for applications that require dynamic interactions based on scrolling.

  • react-scrollspy:

    react-scrollspy is efficient in tracking scroll positions and updating navigation links, but it is dependent on the overall performance of the scroll event handling in the application. It works best in conjunction with other performance optimizations in the app.

  • react-in-viewport:

    react-in-viewport is lightweight and easy to implement, but it may not be as performant as other libraries when dealing with many elements due to its reliance on manual visibility checks. It is best suited for simpler applications where performance is not a critical concern.

  • react-intersection-observer:

    react-intersection-observer is highly performant as it leverages the native Intersection Observer API, which is designed to handle visibility checks efficiently without causing layout thrashing or excessive reflows, making it ideal for applications with many elements to observe.

  • react-scroll:

    react-scroll is optimized for smooth scrolling and provides a good user experience, but it may not handle performance as well when many scroll events are triggered simultaneously. It is best for applications where scroll navigation is a primary feature.

Ease of Use

  • react-waypoint:

    react-waypoint is also easy to use, with a clean API that allows developers to define waypoints and trigger actions with minimal code. It is suitable for developers looking to add scroll-triggered events quickly.

  • react-scrollspy:

    react-scrollspy is easy to integrate into existing navigation systems, providing a simple way to enhance user experience with minimal configuration. Its API is user-friendly, making it accessible for developers of all skill levels.

  • react-in-viewport:

    react-in-viewport is very easy to use, with a simple API that allows developers to wrap components and manage visibility states with minimal setup. It is ideal for developers looking for quick implementation without extensive configuration.

  • react-intersection-observer:

    react-intersection-observer has a slightly steeper learning curve due to its reliance on the Intersection Observer API, but it provides a powerful and flexible solution once understood. It is suitable for developers who need advanced visibility management features.

  • react-scroll:

    react-scroll is straightforward to implement for creating smooth scroll effects and navigation. Its API is intuitive, making it easy for developers to get started with scroll-based navigation without much overhead.

Use Cases

  • react-waypoint:

    react-waypoint is versatile and can be used in various scenarios, such as triggering animations, loading content, or changing styles based on scroll position. It is suitable for applications that require dynamic interactions based on user scrolling.

  • react-scrollspy:

    react-scrollspy is best suited for long single-page applications where you want to provide users with a clear indication of their current section. It enhances navigation usability and is often used in portfolio sites or documentation pages.

  • react-in-viewport:

    react-in-viewport is best used for scenarios where you need to manage the visibility of specific elements, such as lazy loading images or triggering animations when elements come into view. It is ideal for applications with limited visibility requirements.

  • react-intersection-observer:

    react-intersection-observer is perfect for complex applications that require monitoring multiple elements' visibility, such as infinite scrolling lists or triggering animations for various components as they enter the viewport.

  • react-scroll:

    react-scroll is ideal for single-page applications where smooth scrolling navigation is essential. It is commonly used for creating landing pages or documentation sites that require easy navigation between sections.

How to Choose: react-waypoint vs react-scrollspy vs react-in-viewport vs react-intersection-observer vs react-scroll

  • react-waypoint:

    Choose react-waypoint if you need to trigger actions based on scroll position, such as animations or loading data when an element comes into view. It is versatile for implementing scroll-based events and can be combined with other libraries for enhanced functionality.

  • react-scrollspy:

    Use react-scrollspy when you want to highlight navigation links based on the current scroll position. This is particularly useful for creating a dynamic navigation menu that updates as users scroll through different sections of your page, enhancing usability and engagement.

  • react-in-viewport:

    Choose react-in-viewport if you need a straightforward solution for detecting when elements enter or leave the viewport. It is simple to use and provides a clean API for managing visibility without the overhead of additional features.

  • react-intersection-observer:

    Select react-intersection-observer for a more robust and performant solution that leverages the Intersection Observer API. It is ideal for complex scenarios where you need to observe multiple elements and manage their visibility efficiently, especially in large applications.

  • react-scroll:

    Opt for react-scroll if your primary goal is to create smooth scrolling navigation within a single-page application. It is perfect for implementing scroll-to-anchor functionality and provides a simple way to manage scroll behavior with customizable options.

README for react-waypoint

React Waypoint

npm version Build Status

A React component to execute a function whenever you scroll to an element. Works in all containers that can scroll, including the window.

React Waypoint can be used to build features like lazy loading content, infinite scroll, scrollspies, or docking elements to the viewport on scroll.

Inspired by Waypoints, except this little library grooves the React way.

Demo

Demo of React Waypoint in action

View demo page

Installation

npm

npm install react-waypoint --save

yarn

yarn add react-waypoint

Usage

import { Waypoint } from 'react-waypoint';

<Waypoint
  onEnter={this._handleWaypointEnter}
  onLeave={this._handleWaypointLeave}
/>

A waypoint normally fires onEnter and onLeave as you are scrolling, but it can fire because of other events too:

  • When the window is resized
  • When it is mounted (fires onEnter if it's visible on the page)
  • When it is updated/re-rendered by its parent

Callbacks will only fire if the new position changed from the last known position. Sometimes it's useful to have a waypoint that fires onEnter every time it is updated as long as it stays visible (e.g. for infinite scroll). You can then use a key prop to control when a waypoint is reused vs. re-created.

<Waypoint
  key={cursor}
  onEnter={this._loadMoreContent}
/>

Alternatively, you can also use an onPositionChange event to just get notified when the waypoint's position (e.g. inside the viewport, above or below) has changed.

<Waypoint
  onPositionChange={this._handlePositionChange}
/>

Waypoints can take a child, allowing you to track when a section of content enters or leaves the viewport. For details, see Children, below.

<Waypoint onEnter={this._handleEnter}>
  <div>
    Some content here
  </div>
</Waypoint>

Example: JSFiddle Example

Prop types

  propTypes: {

    /**
     * Function called when waypoint enters viewport
     */
    onEnter: PropTypes.func,

    /**
     * Function called when waypoint leaves viewport
     */
    onLeave: PropTypes.func,

    /**
     * Function called when waypoint position changes
     */
    onPositionChange: PropTypes.func,

    /**
     * Whether to activate on horizontal scrolling instead of vertical
     */
    horizontal: PropTypes.bool,

    /**
     * `topOffset` can either be a number, in which case its a distance from the
     * top of the container in pixels, or a string value. Valid string values are
     * of the form "20px", which is parsed as pixels, or "20%", which is parsed
     * as a percentage of the height of the containing element.
     * For instance, if you pass "-20%", and the containing element is 100px tall,
     * then the waypoint will be triggered when it has been scrolled 20px beyond
     * the top of the containing element.
     */
    topOffset: PropTypes.oneOfType([
      PropTypes.string,
      PropTypes.number,
    ]),

    /**
     * `bottomOffset` can either be a number, in which case its a distance from the
     * bottom of the container in pixels, or a string value. Valid string values are
     * of the form "20px", which is parsed as pixels, or "20%", which is parsed
     * as a percentage of the height of the containing element.
     * For instance, if you pass "20%", and the containing element is 100px tall,
     * then the waypoint will be triggered when it has been scrolled 20px beyond
     * the bottom of the containing element.
     * 
     * Similar to `topOffset`, but for the bottom of the container.
     */
    bottomOffset: PropTypes.oneOfType([
      PropTypes.string,
      PropTypes.number,
    ]),

    /**
     * Scrollable Ancestor - A custom ancestor to determine if the
     * target is visible in it. This is useful in cases where
     * you do not want the immediate scrollable ancestor to be
     * the container. For example, when your target is in a div
     * that has overflow auto but you are detecting onEnter based
     * on the window.
     *
     * This should typically be a reference to a DOM node, but it will also work
     * to pass it the string "window" if you are using server rendering.
     */
    scrollableAncestor: PropTypes.any,

    /**
     * fireOnRapidScroll - if the onEnter/onLeave events are to be fired
     * on rapid scrolling. This has no effect on onPositionChange -- it will
     * fire anyway.
     */
    fireOnRapidScroll: PropTypes.bool,

    /**
     * Use this prop to get debug information in the console log. This slows
     * things down significantly, so it should only be used during development.
     */
    debug: PropTypes.bool,
  },

All callbacks (onEnter/onLeave/onPositionChange) receive an object as the only argument. That object has the following properties:

  • currentPosition - the position that the waypoint has at the moment. One of Waypoint.below, Waypoint.above, Waypoint.inside, and Waypoint.invisible.
  • previousPosition - the position that the waypoint had before. Also one of Waypoint.below, Waypoint.above, Waypoint.inside, and Waypoint.invisible.

In most cases, the above two properties should be enough. In some cases though, you might find these additional properties useful:

  • event - the native scroll event that triggered the callback. May be missing if the callback wasn't triggered as the result of a scroll.
  • waypointTop - the waypoint's distance to the top of the viewport.
  • viewportTop - the distance from the scrollable ancestor to the viewport top.
  • viewportBottom - the distance from the bottom of the scrollable ancestor to the viewport top.

If you use es6 object destructuring, this means that you can use waypoints in the following way:

<Waypoint onEnter={({ previousPosition, currentPosition, event }) => {
    // do something useful!
  }}
/>

If you are more familiar with plain old js functions, you'll do something like this:

<Waypoint onEnter={function(props) {
    // here you can use `props.currentPosition`, `props.previousPosition`, and
    // `props.event`
  }}
/>

Offsets and Boundaries

Two of the Waypoint props are topOffset and bottomOffset. To appreciate what these can do for you, it will help to have an understanding of the "boundaries" used by this library. The boundaries of React Waypoint are the top and bottom of the element containing your scrollable content (although this element can be configured). When a waypoint is within these boundaries, it is considered to be "inside." When a waypoint passes beyond these boundaries, then it is "outside." The onEnter and onLeave props are called as an element transitions from being inside to outside, or vice versa.

The topOffset and bottomOffset properties can adjust the placement of these boundaries. By default, the offset is '0px'. If you specify a positive value, then the boundaries will be pushed inward, toward the center of the page. If you specify a negative value for an offset, then the boundary will be pushed outward from the center of the page.

Here is an illustration of offsets and boundaries. The black box is the scrollableAncestor. The pink lines represent the location of the boundaries. The offsets that determine the boundaries are in light pink.

Horizontal Scrolling Offsets and Boundaries

By default, waypoints listen to vertical scrolling. If you want to switch to horizontal scrolling instead, use the horizontal prop. For simplicity's sake, all other props and callbacks do not change. Instead, topOffset and bottomOffset (among other directional variables) will mean the offset from the left and the offset from the right, respectively, and work exactly as they did before, just calculated in the horizontal direction.

Example Usage

Positive values of the offset props are useful when you have an element that overlays your scrollable area. For instance, if your app has a 50px fixed header, then you may want to specify topOffset='50px', so that the onEnter callback is called when waypoints scroll into view from beneath the header.

Negative values of the offset prop could be useful for lazy loading. Imagine if you had a lot of large images on a long page, but you didn't want to load them all at once. You can use React Waypoint to receive a callback whenever an image is a certain distance from the bottom of the page. For instance, by specifying bottomOffset='-200px', then your onEnter callback would be called when the waypoint comes closer than 200 pixels from the bottom edge of the page. By placing a waypoint near each image, you could dynamically load them.

There are likely many more use cases for the offsets: be creative! Also, keep in mind that there are two boundaries, so there are always two positions when the onLeave and onEnter callback will be called. By using the arguments passed to the callbacks, you can determine whether the waypoint has crossed the top boundary or the bottom boundary.

Children

If you don't pass a child into your Waypoint, then you can think of the waypoint as a line across the page. Whenever that line crosses a boundary, then the onEnter or onLeave callbacks will be called.

If you do pass a child, it can be a single DOM component (e.g. <div>) or a composite component (e.g. <MyComponent />).

Waypoint needs a DOM node to compute its boundaries. When you pass a DOM component to Waypoint, it handles getting a reference to the DOM node through the ref prop automatically.

If you pass a composite component, you can wrap it with React.forwardRef (requires react@^16.3.0) and have the ref prop being handled automatically for you, like this:

class Block extends React.Component {
  render() {
    return <div ref={this.props.innerRef}>Hello</div>
  }
}

const BlockWithRef = React.forwardRef((props, ref) => {
  return <Block innerRef={ref} {...props} />
})

const App = () => (
  <Waypoint>
    <BlockWithRef />
  </Waypoint>
)

If you can't do that because you are using older version of React then you need to make use of the innerRef prop passed by Waypoint to your component. Simply pass it through as the ref of a DOM component and you're all set. Like in this example:

class Block extends React.Component {
  render() {
    return <div ref={this.props.innerRef}>Hello</div>
  }
}
Block.propTypes = {
  innerRef: PropTypes.func.isRequired,
}

const App = () => (
  <Waypoint>
    <Block />
  </Waypoint>
)

The onEnter callback will be called when any part of the child is visible in the viewport. The onLeave callback will be called when all of the child has exited the viewport.

(Note that this is measured only on a single axis. What this means is that for a Waypoint within a vertically scrolling parent, it could be off of the screen horizontally yet still fire an onEnter event, because it is within the vertical boundaries).

Deciding whether to pass a child or not will depend on your use case. One example of when passing a child is useful is for a scrollspy (like Bootstrap's). Imagine if you want to fire a waypoint when a particularly long piece of content is visible onscreen. When the page loads, it is conceivable that both the top and bottom of this piece of content could lie outside of the boundaries, because the content is taller than the viewport. If you didn't pass a child, and instead put the waypoint above or below the content, then you will not receive an onEnter callback (nor any other callback from this library). Instead, passing this long content as a child of the Waypoint would fire the onEnter callback when the page loads.

Containing elements and scrollableAncestor

React Waypoint positions its boundaries based on the first scrollable ancestor of the Waypoint.

If that algorithm doesn't work for your use case, then you might find the scrollableAncestor prop useful. It allows you to specify what the scrollable ancestor is. Pass a reference to a DOM node as that prop, and the Waypoint will use the scroll position of that node, rather than its first scrollable ancestor.

This can also be the string "window", which can be useful if you are using server rendering.

Example Usage

Sometimes, waypoints that are deeply nested in the DOM tree may need to track the scroll position of the page as a whole. If you want to be sure that no other scrollable ancestor is used (since, once again, the first scrollable ancestor is what the library will use by default), then you can explicitly set the scrollableAncestor to be the window to ensure that no other element is used.

This might look something like:

<Waypoint
  scrollableAncestor={window}
  onEnter={this._handleWaypointEnter}
  onLeave={this._handleWaypointLeave}
/>

Troubleshooting

If your waypoint isn't working the way you expect it to, there are a few ways you can debug your setup.

OPTION 1: Add the debug={true} prop to your waypoint. When you do, you'll see console logs informing you about the internals of the waypoint.

OPTION 2: Clone and modify the project locally.

  • clone this repo
  • add console.log or breakpoints where you think it would be useful.
  • npm link in the react-waypoint repo.
  • npm link react-waypoint in your project.
  • if needed rebuild react-waypoint module: npm run build-npm

Limitations

In this component we make a few assumptions that we believe are generally safe, but in some situations might present limitations.

  • We determine the scrollable-ness of a node by inspecting its computed overflow-y or overflow property and nothing else. This could mean that a container with this style that does not actually currently scroll will be considered when performing visibility calculations.
  • We assume that waypoints are rendered within at most one scrollable container. If you render a waypoint in multiple nested scrollable containers, the visibility calculations will likely not be accurate.
  • We also base the visibility calculations on the scroll position of the scrollable container (or window if no scrollable container is found). This means that if your scrollable container has a height that is greater than the window, it might trigger onEnter unexpectedly.

In the wild

Organizations and projects using react-waypoint.

Credits

Credit to trotzig and lencioni for writing this component, and Brigade for open sourcing it.

Thanks to the creator of the original Waypoints library, imakewebthings.

License

MIT


Make sure to check out other popular open-source tools from the Brigade team: dock, overcommit, haml-lint, and scss-lint.