clipper-lib vs earcut vs polygon-clipping
Geometric Clipping Libraries
clipper-libearcutpolygon-clippingSimilar Packages:

Geometric Clipping Libraries

These libraries provide functionalities for geometric operations such as clipping, triangulation, and polygon manipulation. They are essential in applications involving graphics rendering, spatial analysis, and geographic information systems (GIS). Each library has its unique strengths and use cases, making them suitable for different types of geometric computations and visualizations.

Npm Package Weekly Downloads Trend

3 Years

Github Stars Ranking

Stat Detail

Package
Downloads
Stars
Size
Issues
Publish
License
clipper-lib0212215 kB7-BSL
earcut02,44457.3 kB259 months agoISC
polygon-clipping0625350 kB452 years agoMIT

Feature Comparison: clipper-lib vs earcut vs polygon-clipping

Clipping Operations

  • clipper-lib:

    clipper-lib supports a wide range of clipping operations including union, intersection, difference, and XOR. It can handle complex polygons with holes and overlapping shapes, making it ideal for applications that require precise geometric manipulations.

  • earcut:

    earcut does not perform clipping operations; instead, it focuses solely on triangulating polygons. It efficiently converts a polygon into a set of triangles, which is essential for rendering in graphics applications but does not handle clipping.

  • polygon-clipping:

    polygon-clipping provides basic clipping operations such as intersection and union. It is suitable for applications that require simple geometric manipulations without the complexity of handling intricate shapes.

Performance

  • clipper-lib:

    clipper-lib is optimized for performance, especially when dealing with complex polygons. It uses an efficient algorithm that minimizes the number of operations required for clipping, making it suitable for high-performance applications.

  • earcut:

    earcut is known for its exceptional speed in triangulating polygons. It is designed to be lightweight and fast, making it an excellent choice for real-time applications where performance is critical, such as in gaming or interactive graphics.

  • polygon-clipping:

    polygon-clipping is generally slower than clipper-lib and earcut due to its simpler algorithms. It is best suited for applications where performance is not the primary concern and where ease of use is more important.

Ease of Use

  • clipper-lib:

    clipper-lib has a steeper learning curve due to its comprehensive feature set and complexity. It requires a good understanding of geometric concepts to utilize effectively, making it less beginner-friendly.

  • earcut:

    earcut is very easy to use, with a straightforward API that allows developers to quickly implement polygon triangulation. It is designed for simplicity and can be integrated with minimal effort into existing projects.

  • polygon-clipping:

    polygon-clipping offers a user-friendly API that is easy to understand and implement. It is suitable for developers who need basic polygon operations without the overhead of complex configurations.

Library Size

  • clipper-lib:

    clipper-lib is relatively large due to its extensive functionality and support for various geometric operations. This may impact the overall bundle size of applications that include it.

  • earcut:

    earcut is lightweight and has a small footprint, making it an excellent choice for performance-sensitive applications where minimizing bundle size is crucial.

  • polygon-clipping:

    polygon-clipping is also lightweight, but it may not be as optimized as earcut. It strikes a balance between functionality and size, making it suitable for applications that need basic clipping without significant overhead.

Use Cases

  • clipper-lib:

    clipper-lib is ideal for applications requiring complex polygon operations, such as CAD software, GIS applications, and any scenario where precise geometric calculations are necessary.

  • earcut:

    earcut is perfect for real-time graphics applications, such as games and interactive visualizations, where fast triangulation of polygons is needed for rendering.

  • polygon-clipping:

    polygon-clipping is suitable for simpler applications that need basic geometric operations, such as web mapping tools or simple graphic editors.

How to Choose: clipper-lib vs earcut vs polygon-clipping

  • clipper-lib:

    Choose clipper-lib if you need a robust solution for polygon clipping and boolean operations. It excels in handling complex shapes and is suitable for applications requiring precise geometric calculations, such as CAD software or GIS applications.

  • earcut:

    Choose earcut if your primary focus is on fast and efficient polygon triangulation. It is particularly useful for rendering 2D shapes in WebGL or canvas, where performance is critical, and you need a lightweight solution for converting polygons into triangles.

  • polygon-clipping:

    Choose polygon-clipping if you require a straightforward library for basic polygon operations like intersection, union, and difference. It is user-friendly and ideal for simpler applications where advanced features are not necessary.

README for clipper-lib

ClipperLib

forked from Javascript Clipper

Description

The Javascript Clipper library performs clipping and offsetting for both lines and polygons. All four boolean clipping operations are supported - intersection, union, difference and exclusive-or. Polygons can be of any shape including self-intersecting polygons.

Javascript Clipper is a port of Angus Johnson's Clipper library: https://sourceforge.net/projects/polyclipping/

LIVE DEMO: http://jsclipper.sourceforge.net/6.2.1.0/main_demo.html

Information and examples: http://jsclipper.sourceforge.net/6.2.1.0/

Donate Javascript Clipper Project: https://sourceforge.net/p/jsclipper/wiki/Donations/

Use cases:

Javascript Clipper Web Site

Features

  • Line and polygon clipping - intersection, union, difference & xor
  • Line and polygon offsetting with 3 types of joining - miter, square and round
  • Polygons can be of any shape, including self-intersecting polygons
  • Minkowski Addition and Minkowski Difference functions included
  • The library is written in Javascript
  • Comprehensive documentation
  • Demos use inline SVG and Canvas libraries
  • The library is significantly faster than commercial alternatives
  • Uses Tom Wu's fast big integer library
  • UMD support

Categories

Algorithms, Graphics

Links

License

Boost Software License (BSL1.0)