Customization and Extensibility
- prosemirror-state:
prosemirror-stateis designed to be highly extensible, allowing developers to create custom plugins, commands, and schemas. It provides a low-level API for manipulating the editor's state, making it suitable for building specialized editing features. - quill:
quillis customizable and allows developers to create custom formats, modules, and themes. Its API is designed for easy integration and extension, making it simple to add new functionality or modify existing features. - slate:
slateis built for extensibility, allowing developers to define their own rendering logic, data structures, and editing behaviors. Its plugin system and customizable architecture make it easy to create unique editing experiences tailored to specific use cases. - ckeditor5:
ckeditor5is highly customizable and supports a wide range of plugins, allowing developers to extend its functionality easily. It also provides a rich API for creating custom plugins and integrating third-party tools. - draft-js:
draft-jsoffers extensibility through its plugin architecture, enabling developers to create custom decorators, entities, and input components. Its flexible data model allows for deep customization of how content is rendered and edited. - mobx-state-tree:
mobx-state-treeprovides a structured approach to state management with built-in support for custom actions, views, and middleware. While it is not a UI library, its tree-like data model allows for extensibility in how state is managed and interacted with. - tiptap:
tiptapis highly customizable and built on top of ProseMirror, allowing developers to create and extend nodes, marks, and commands easily. Its modular architecture and well-documented API make it simple to add new features and integrate with other tools.
Collaboration Features
- prosemirror-state:
prosemirror-stateis designed to support collaborative editing, but it requires additional implementation. ProseMirror provides the building blocks for collaboration, including document versioning and conflict resolution, but developers need to create the infrastructure for real-time editing. - quill:
quilldoes not have built-in collaboration features, but its lightweight and modular design makes it easy to integrate with third-party collaboration tools and libraries. - slate:
slatedoes not include built-in collaboration features, but its flexible architecture allows developers to create custom collaborative editing solutions. The library provides the necessary tools to manage and synchronize the editor's state across multiple users. - ckeditor5:
ckeditor5includes built-in support for real-time collaboration, allowing multiple users to edit the same document simultaneously. It provides features like presence indicators, conflict resolution, and collaborative editing out of the box. - draft-js:
draft-jsdoes not provide built-in collaboration features, but its architecture allows developers to implement custom collaboration solutions. The focus is on managing the editor's state and content, leaving collaboration implementation to the developer. - mobx-state-tree:
mobx-state-treesupports collaboration through its tree-like data model and snapshot functionality. Developers can implement real-time collaboration by synchronizing state changes across clients using websockets or other technologies. - tiptap:
tiptapsupports collaboration through its integration with ProseMirror. It provides a foundation for building real-time collaborative editing features, including support for multiple cursors, conflict resolution, and document versioning.
State Management
- prosemirror-state:
prosemirror-stateprovides a low-level API for managing the editor's document state, allowing for fine-grained control over how content is structured and edited. It supports custom state management implementations, making it flexible for various use cases. - quill:
quillmanages the editor's content using a Delta data structure, which allows for efficient manipulation and serialization of rich text. It provides APIs for accessing and modifying the content, but state management is primarily handled by the editor. - slate:
slateprovides a customizable state management system for rich text content. It allows developers to define their own data structures and editing behaviors, providing flexibility in how state is managed and manipulated within the editor. - ckeditor5:
ckeditor5manages the editor's state internally, providing a rich API for accessing and manipulating the content. It supports undo/redo, content serialization, and custom data handling, but state management is primarily handled by the editor itself. - draft-js:
draft-jsprovides a robust state management system for handling rich text content. It allows developers to manage the editor's state programmatically, including support for undo/redo, content serialization, and custom state handling. - mobx-state-tree:
mobx-state-treeoffers a powerful state management solution with a tree-like data structure, making it easy to manage complex state in applications. It provides features like time-travel debugging, snapshots, and built-in support for asynchronous actions, making it ideal for managing state in large applications. - tiptap:
tiptapleverages ProseMirror's state management capabilities while providing a more user-friendly API. It allows developers to manage the editor's content, handle events, and implement custom state logic easily.
Ease of Use: Code Examples
- prosemirror-state:
Basic Usage of
prosemirror-stateimport { EditorState } from 'prosemirror-state'; import { Schema } from 'prosemirror-model'; import { DOMParser } from 'prosemirror-model'; const schema = new Schema({ nodes: { doc: { content: 'block+' }, paragraph: { content: 'text*', group: 'block' }, text: { inline: true }, }, }); const doc = DOMParser.fromSchema(schema).parse(document.querySelector('#content')); const state = EditorState.create({ schema, doc }); - quill:
Basic Usage of
quill<div id="editor"></div> <script src="https://cdn.quilljs.com/1.3.6/quill.js"></script> <link href="https://cdn.quilljs.com/1.3.6/quill.snow.css" rel="stylesheet"> <script> var quill = new Quill('#editor', { theme: 'snow' }); </script> - slate:
Basic Usage of
slateimport { createEditor } from 'slate'; import { Slate, Editable, withReact } from 'slate-react'; const editor = createEditor(); function App() { return ( <Slate editor={editor} value={initialValue} onChange={handleChange}> <Editable /> </Slate> ); } - ckeditor5:
Basic Usage of
ckeditor5import ClassicEditor from '@ckeditor/ckeditor5-build-classic'; ClassicEditor.create(document.querySelector('#editor')) .then(editor => { console.log(editor); }) .catch(error => { console.error(error); }); - draft-js:
Basic Usage of
draft-jsimport React from 'react'; import { Editor, EditorState } from 'draft-js'; class MyEditor extends React.Component { state = { editorState: EditorState.createEmpty() }; onEditorStateChange = (editorState) => { this.setState({ editorState }); }; render() { return ( <Editor editorState={this.state.editorState} onEditorStateChange={this.onEditorStateChange} /> ); } } - mobx-state-tree:
Basic Usage of
mobx-state-treeimport { types } from 'mobx-state-tree'; const Todo = types.model({ id: types.identifier, title: types.string, completed: types.boolean, }); const TodoStore = types.model({ todos: types.array(Todo), }).create({ todos: [ { id: '1', title: 'Learn MobX', completed: false }, ], }); - tiptap:
Basic Usage of
tiptapimport { Editor } from '@tiptap/core'; import StarterKit from '@tiptap/starter-kit'; const editor = new Editor({ element: document.querySelector('#editor'), extensions: [StarterKit], });